Opinion: What the bishops hope to accomplish with Eucharist document

In the end, the Eucharist is the answer to the problems we face, the way forward from the situation in which we find ourselves, and the medicine we need to heal our sin-sick souls.

Elevation of the Eucharist is depicted in a stained-glass window at St. Anthony's Church in North Beach, Md., July 15, 2021. (CNS photo/Bob Roller)

All eyes are on Baltimore this week as the U.S. bishops discuss, debate, and vote on the long-awaited document on the Eucharist, drafted by the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops’ doctrine committee.

The document finds its origin in the concerns that have arisen, on the part of many shepherds and lay faithful, by the counter-witness of Catholics who serve as elected officials and support abortion. These concerns have been particularly aggravated with the 2020 election of Catholic President Joe Biden, who supports pro-abortion policies without restriction.

The bishops’ document, however, is not expected to have as its focus Catholic politicians, nor will it name names. Rather, it will be a teaching document that considers Eucharistic practice and teaching, as well as the Eucharist’s central role in the life and mission of the Church.

Explicitly or implicitly, what the bishops teach about the Eucharist — be it our preparation to receive that gift with a spirit of humility, or our obligation to live in conformity with the Church’s life when we present ourselves to receive the sacrament of our unity — will create controversy. After all, what doesn’t these days? The rubber meets the road in Catholic life when we do not just profess our belief in Christ and his Real Presence in the Eucharist, but when we live as eucharistic icons in the world, bringing Christ to all and bringing all to Christ.

As Cardinal Francis E. George, OMI — late archbishop of Chicago and president of the U.S. Bishops’ conference from 2007-2010 — once said: “No one receives the Eucharist on any other terms except those of Christ himself, just as no one is a Catholic on any other terms but Christ’s.”

Living eucharistically — which, if the document passes, seems to be what the majority of U.S. bishops will be imploring Catholics to do — is akin to being a voice crying out in the wilderness today in our secularized, selfish culture. It’s also a cri de coeur for the Church, which suffers on account of the culture’s hold on us all. Pro-abortion Catholic politicians is just one — albeit, a most grievous one — of the many ways Catholics in the United States today fall short of our call.

If we truly lived as people of the Eucharist, perhaps studies would not show that an overwhelming majority of Catholics do not believe in the real presence of Christ in the Eucharist. Maybe we’d have more pro-life politicians among our ranks. Maybe more couples would marry in the Church and more babies be baptized. Maybe we would be closing fewer parishes and schools. Maybe we’d experience less rancor and division — even, to an ever-increasing degree, in the Church.

Taking into consideration all these things, and more, into account, it’s obvious why the bishops have proceeded with a document on the mystery of the Eucharist in the life of the Church. And it’s also why they are moving forward with plans for a Eucharistic revival over the next few years.

In the end, the Eucharist is the answer to the problems we face, the way forward from the situation in which we find ourselves, and the medicine we need to heal our sin-sick souls. And given the origins of the bishops’ document — the acute crisis of Catholics in public office unapologetically supporting the most selfish of acts under the banner of freedom — perhaps deepening eucharistic understanding and strengthening eucharistic living can provide the lens through which to understand true freedom.

The freedom we find in the Eucharist is not the freedom of Illinois U.S. Sen. Dick Durbin, who recently announced he has found a parish in the Archdiocese of Chicago that would give him Communion after past and current bishops in Springfield restricted his reception of the sacrament in light of his pro-abortion politics. “The freedom Christ gives us with himself in the Eucharist” is, however — again turning to Cardinal George — “more than freedom to do; it is also freedom to give ourselves totally, even to the point of self-sacrifice, as Christ gave himself to death on the cross.”

If the bishops’ document can call us more clearly to this way of living, it will be a success.

If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!

Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.

About MIchael R. Heinlein 8 Articles
Michael R. Heinlein is editor of OSV's SimplyCatholic.com and author of a forthcoming biography of Cardinal Francis E. George, OMI.


  1. The belief that one must be worthy to receive the living God in His humanity and in His divinity is as old as Christianity itself.

    Regardless of the state of one’s soul and of one’s personal culpability in doing so, openly advocating or brazenly facilitating the murder of the children of the living God by the millions renders one unworthy to receive Him in the Eucharist. If it doesn’t then nothing does.

    To allow politicians well known for advocating and facilitating the mass murder of children to receive the Eucharist is a public declaration that the bishops are willing to render unto Caesar authority over innocent human life that belongs to God alone. That is idolatry.

    The state has no authority whatsoever to legalize the murder of innocent humanity. That was established at the Nuremberg Trials, the prosecutors of which referred to “legal” abortion as a crime against humanity.

  2. Eucharistic coherence aside, how will the bishops rescind their implicit approval of abortion-derived fetal cell research through accepting the currently available morally tainted vaccines and teaching that they are morally acceptable? They cannot. Joe Biden not only approves of abortion on demand, he has removed the committee that formerly provided oversight to the ethics of fetal cell research. It’s a free-for-all that now has the approval of the USCCB. The bishops owed it to their flock to demand from the beginning a vaccine researched, developed, produced and tested with moral means. They continue to compromise the teaching of the Church by acting in opposition. They won’t stand up for the Eucharist either.

  3. The bishops would have more credibility with the people in the pew if they were seen at Eucharistic Adoration every day, even for 15-30 minutes, at their parish, and if they promoted it in Sunday homilies. I believe people respond more to seeing their bishops and pastors praying, promoting Adoration by being present, than by homilies about Adoration. Example wins over talk every timw. If there was ever a time when ALL Catholics need to spend time before the Blessed Sacrament every week, even if not for a full hour… And if EVERY church within a diocese offered Eucharist Adoration. Even if this was inconvenient for some. In our diocese, weekly E.A. is common in most parishes.

  4. Sadly the train has left the station with engineer Durbin at the throttle.Conductors
    Biden & Obama punch the passengers tickets.While Pelosi serves the ice cold ice cream.
    Savoy Brown provides the onboard musical accompaniment.With 1972’s “Hell Bound Train”
    released in February of that year. As the first lives were being extinguished of the over 60 million.We see today.One can only pray the baggage car isn’t loaded down with the USCCB’s luggage.
    and still counting we see today.

  5. What is hoped to accomplish and what must be accomplished on this one moral issue are inseparable. That is protection of human life created in God’s image and the non negotiable right to life. Non negotiable contrary to the Vatican’s current misguided idea of negotiability with errant politicians over a law which is neither just not humane, the right to murder the innocent.

1 Trackback / Pingback

  1. Opinion: What the bishops hope to accomplish with Eucharist document – Catholic World Report – The Old Roman

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

All comments posted at Catholic World Report are moderated. While vigorous debate is welcome and encouraged, please note that in the interest of maintaining a civilized and helpful level of discussion, comments containing obscene language or personal attacks—or those that are deemed by the editors to be needlessly combative or inflammatory—will not be published. Thank you.