New Florida law requiring parental consent for abortion limits harm, Catholic bishops say

CNA Staff, Jul 1, 2020 / 01:37 pm (CNA).- After Gov. Ron DeSantis signed a new law requiring parental consent for a minor’s abortion, the Florida Conference of Catholic Bishops praised the effort for reducing the “grave harm” of abortion.

“This common-sense measure simply holds abortion to the same consent requirements as most every other medical decision involving a child, including simple interventions such as taking an aspirin or getting ears pierced,” the bishops said June 30.

“As Catholics, we condemn abortion as a grave injustice that denies the fundamental human right to life. However, as long as abortion is legal, we support measures such as parental consent that will reduce the grave harm it inflicts.”

Under the new law, minors seeking an abortion will be required to receive notarized approval from at least one parent or guardian. The minor may seek a waiver from a circuit court judge.

Doctors who perform abortions without the parental consent of a girl under 18 would face up to five years in prison for a third-degree felony.

The Florida House of Representatives passed SB 404 by a 75-43 vote Feb. 20. It had cleared the Senate 23-17 in an earlier vote.

“We are especially grateful to the legislative leaders who advanced this pro-life legislation, particularly bill sponsors Senator Kelli Stargel (R-Lakeland) and Representative Erin Grall (R-Vero Beach),” the bishops said. “We also commend the Democratic lawmakers who courageously crossed party lines and voted in support of this good bill.”

The bishops thanked Republican Gov. DeSantis for signing the bill into law.

Senate President Bill Galvano, a Republican, praised the legislation.

“The serious and irrevocable decision to end a pregnancy involves undergoing a significant medical procedure that results, in many cases, in lifelong emotional and physical impacts,” he said in a statement. “The parents of a minor child considering an abortion must be involved in such a substantial and permanent decision.”

The bill would expand restrictions under the current Florida law, approved by voters in 2004, which only requires a minor to give notice to their parent, guardian, or a judge that they intend to procure an abortion

The Florida legislature first enacted a parental consent law in 1979, but the state Supreme Court struck it down a decade later, saying it violated privacy rights. Backers of the new law are confident it with withstand legal challenge, given changes on the court.

Florida’s Catholic bishops commented the day after the U.S. Supreme Court overturned a Louisiana law holding abortion clinics to the same standards as other surgical centers.

“While deeply disappointed in the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision yesterday regarding an abortion case out of Louisiana, we are pleased that Florida has taken a step forward today in ensuring vital protections for parents and their children,” said the bishops.

Planned Parenthood of Florida said the parental consent law would “endanger young people who, in many cases, have experienced abuse at the hands of their own parents or guardians.” The group said few court clerks could offer information on the judicial bypass, and access to the courts is hindered by coronavirus epidemic restrictions, CBS 4 Miami reports.

Stephanie Fraim, president and CEO of Planned Parenthood of Southwest and Central Florida, said the bill “could open the door to a reinterpretation of our constitutional right to privacy and the right to a safe and legal abortion in Florida.”

The law also strengthens legal protections for infants who survive an abortion.

“This law sends a clear message that here in Florida, we will do everything we can to prevent the abomination of infanticide in our state,” Galvano said. “When a child miraculously survives this brutal medical procedure, that child’s life must be preserved and treated with great respect and care. The penalty for refusing to provide medical care to an infant struggling for life should be significant.”

If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!

Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.


  1. This dilemma has been with us and the only answer is a qualified “warning’ to doctors who break the “law”. Today, parental consent is full of holes. Some girls, perhaps the most vulnerable, are estranged from their parents which places the poor girl as a ward of the courts. “Doctors who perform abortions without the parental consent of a girl under 18 would face up to five years in prison for a third-degree felony”. I have asked before how is the law properly executed? Is a monsignor going to stand outside of an operating room waiting to nail the doctor. Ireland had the Magdalene laundries where a pregnant girl was whisked into a veritable jail until she delivered. The baby was then placed in a foster home never to know his/her mother. We fortunately do not have a jail for young pregnant girls. I feel if religion gets more involved a disastrous result will further fail to address the quandary. Pregnant young girls need nurturing and love, not the wrath of anyone in authority.

    • Morgan,
      No one would disagree that pregnant young girls need nurturing and protection. Just as their unborn children do.

  2. Governor Desantis is a major figure and a cause in Florida’s ignoring experts warning on the coronavirus. It appears that Florida’s current status with the pandemic is grave and its’ exploding cases and hospital burden says they are out of control.

    VP Pence traveled to Florida this week to say on the coronavirus: ‘The people of Florida can rest easy’.

    Abortion on demand and coronavirus deaths present a sinful picture of death that could have been largely prevented. However, the acknowledgment of a rouge governor is overstated when his Trumpo allegiance caused many of the virus deaths and he still mimics Trump and Pence’s disgraceful glossing over the pandemic. The church hierarchy pouring praise on this governor is sadly misplaced.

    • You might want to explain, then, why Florida’s death rate per 1,000 from COVID-19 is 17, while New Jersey is at 170, NY is at 165, and so forth. It’s well down in the bottom half of that stat. NY State alone has 70% more deaths just in nursing homes than Florida does as a state.

    • Morgan,
      I have family in Florida and things may certainly change in the future but many FL hospitals are now full of folks who had put off surgeries when the epidemic was at its peak. They are coming in for delayed procedures, not necessarily because of Covid.
      Where I live, that’s been the story also. A small town hospital here has 40 “Covid patients” who tested positive for the virus but only 2 of them are actually hospitalized due to the virus itself. The other 38 are there because of other ailments but they had been exposed to Covid recently. A nurse my daughter knows told her there’s a financial incentive to list patients that way. Federal funds or something.
      No one has a crystal ball and things could get scary again so we need to proceed cautiously. I just hate to see politics mixed up with public health. That’s a dangerous combination and we should seriously attempt to avoid it.
      God bless!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

All comments posted at Catholic World Report are moderated. While vigorous debate is welcome and encouraged, please note that in the interest of maintaining a civilized and helpful level of discussion, comments containing obscene language or personal attacks—or those that are deemed by the editors to be needlessly combative or inflammatory—will not be published. Thank you.