
Buenos Aires, Argentina, Jul 30, 2025 / 08:00 am (CNA).
Opus Dei has denounced the “manipulation of judicial proceedings to create a media and public opinion case” in the lawsuit advanced by former assistant numeraries in Argentina, which now seeks to implicate the highest authorities of the organization in alleged human trafficking.
The case was formally filed in court in 2024, but media coverage began years earlier. According to the lawsuit, Opus Dei authorities allegedly recruited women while they were still minors and subjected them to a regime of semi-slavery in their residences.
The conflict began as a labor complaint and then progressed into a lawsuit for compensation for damages, eventually leading to allegations of alleged labor exploitation. As of June 2023, a judicial investigation has been underway following a complaint alleging that a group of women were victims of human trafficking and labor exploitation.
The Argentine prosecutor’s office has requested an investigation into the last four regional vicars of Opus Dei in Argentina, including the current auxiliary vicar of Opus Dei and the organization’s second in command, Monsignor Mariano Fazio. The plaintiff’s lawyer is calling on prosecutors to also request a statement from the prelate of Opus Dei, Monsignor Fernando Ocáriz.
However, the prelature has pointed out that the presiding judge has not yet charged any crimes, ruled on whether to grant the request, or named those whom he might summon.
Opus Dei issued a statement to clarify that the judicial investigation is based on the personal situation of one woman when she was part of the apostolate and that within this context, the plaintiff’s lawyer “announced in the media that he has requested the prosecutors’ office that Monsignor Fernando Ocariz, the prelate of Opus Dei, be summoned for questioning.”
The prelature believes this request has no factual or legal basis but is part of “a deceptive and sustained media strategy that, from the beginning, has attempted to distort the purposes of a criminal investigation to address a labor compensation claim.”
“The case as a whole represents an attempt at manipulation by introducing the charge of a committing a criminal offense (human trafficking) that actually has no connection with the facts described by the complainants themselves, much less with the reality of Opus Dei,” the apostolate pointed out.
Opus Dei asserts that the request to summon Ocáriz for questioning is an attempt to “artificially extend the scope of the criminal investigation to include people whose direct connection to the alleged events described by the complainant is nonexistent,” with the purpose of “amplifying the impact on public opinion and exerting pressure on the justice system.”
The apostolate also pointed out that something similar happened “with the request that Monsignor Mariano Fazio be summoned to testify, which was announced with an orchestrated media blitz.”
The conflict, the statement adds, reflects a “complete decontextualization of the freely chosen vocation of the assistant numerary of Opus Dei.”
The prelature regretted “that judicial mechanisms are being used to sustain a prefabricated narrative that seeks to establish blame without any basis in the facts that actually occurred” and called for respect for the presumption of innocence.
Opus Dei therefore reiterated that it rejects “these allegations” and maintains its “complete willingness to cooperate with the judicial authorities, trusting that the truth will prevail.”
This story was first published by ACI Prensa, CNA’s Spanish-language news partner. It has been translated and adapted by CNA.
If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!
Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.



I was also a victime of Opus Dei’s manipulation and than also a perpetrator myself because OD told me that it is the will of God and I believed them.
They told me that I had a divine vocation when I was 15 years old, and that I will forever unhappy if I do not follow Gods plan. I believe them, because they where nice ladies and giving me a lot of attention and love. Once I wrote the letter they told me that there is no going back and that having doubts if my vocation is really from God was considered a temptation from the devil. (So the years of „discernment“ as they call it now are a scam.) They told me that I have to YES at all times, and that I have to do it „of my own free will“. So I cried and tried to force my own free will. They told me, it is normal to be afraid and that everything will be fine if I stay „faithful to my vocation“ = do and think everything they tell me to do and think. It was 15 years of complete mind control and also control of every aspect of my life – specifically my thoughts. Thy thoughts me how to I continuously tell myself „ OD this is the best, because it is what God wants from me“.
I just managed to leave because my parents noticed that I was completely exhausted and with a psychological and physical breakdown. This was a lucky insident because I just saw my parents every 2-3 years for some hours, and I would never have told my parents that I am really in a bad state. (This was considered a betrayal to the „Opus Dei Family“ because no one should think something bad of Opus Dei because it is from God. (Being Happy and in a good mood is a norm that you have to follow. Not being happy is considered to be „allies with the enemy“. I was even protecting Opus Dei when I was already suicidal and trying to pretend everything was fine. We were constantly listening to books and courses that emphasized on how „free“ we are, and that nobody is forcing us and we do all of our Opus Dei duties freely.
This message was constantly repeated so we ourselves do not notice that it is not true.
It took me a lot of time after leaving the organization and the control in the spiritual direction to realize that this was completely manipulated. Now I realize that this is normal for any high control group, abusive relationship or cult.
I am very happy that I can live a happy and free life with god in my normal parish without the mind control. (I do not need thousand of classes telling me that I should feel happy and free – because I simply am. Finally being able to choose my friends, deciding when and how long to pray, deciding to which priest to go, where to live, when to go to bed, etc. etc. is a blessing. And I thank God every day that I made it out of Opus Dei alive.)
In this article Opus Dei showes that it does not admit that the whole thing of „freely chosen vocation“ is a scam. If It would be „free“ an „from God“ they would allow a real discernment and would encourage people to also talk to other priests like all the other institutions and religious orders of the church do.
I hope the pope puts and end to the manipulation in the name of our lord Jesus Christ.