
Baltimore, Md., Nov 13, 2017 / 02:30 pm (CNA/EWTN News).- As the conclusion of a lengthy discussion on migration, the US Conference of Catholic Bishops decided Monday to draft a statement from their president expressing the need for humane and just immigration reform.
The Nov. 13 proposal was first floated by Archbishop Michael Sheehan, Archbishop Emeritus of Santa Fe. After debating how to go about preparing a statement, it was agreed by oral assent that Cardinal Daniel DiNardo of Galveston-Houston, president of the conference, would issue a statement with the assistance of the Committee on Migration, chaired by Bishop Joe Vasquez of Austin, assisted by Archbishop Jose Gomez of Los Angeles.
The discussion followed brief presentations from Archbishop Gomez and Bishop Vasquez. The Los Angeles archbishop outlined the principles which guide the US bishops’ work on migration, which come from Strangers No Longer, a 2003 pastoral letter issued jointly by the US and Mexican bishops’ conferences.
“This is a time when newcomers [to the US] are fleeing violence or persecution or cannot find a livelihood in their own country,” he reflected, adding that the Trump administration has taken several steps on immigration that demand a response from the Church because they “have a direct impact on our pastoral care of immigrants, refugees, and DACA youth.”
The first of these is the decision to allow only 45,000 refugees in the coming fiscal year – the lowest level since the program’s founding in 1980, and the second consecutive year in which the number of refugees admitted will be reduced.
This move, Archbishop Gomez said, “is simply inhumane, particularly when our great nation has the resources and ability to do more” for those “fleeing tyranny and persecution.”
He urged the preservation of DACA, which provides reprieve from the threat of deportation for undocumented persons who were brought to the US as minors, many of whom only know the US “and are by every social measure, American youth.”
Bishop Vasquez then spoke, saying the bishops are advocating for a solution for the DACA youth in the form of the DREAM Act, which would provide those young people with residency in the US.
He encouraged the bishops to contact their legislators to pass the DREAM Act or similar legislation as a prompt and humane solution, noting that 85 percent of Dreamers have lived in the US 10 years or longer, 89 percent have gainful employment, and 93 percent have a high school degree.
The Bishop of Austin also addressed temporary protected status, which has been extended to migrants from El Salvador, Honduras, and Haiti because of acute conditions of insecurity in their home countries.
“It is not the proper time to return 300,000 individuals” to their home countries when they remain insecure due to natural and manmade disasters, he said. These individuals have jobs and support their families, many have mortgages, and they have some 270,000 children who are US citizens.
“ A longer term legislative solution for these brothers and sisters” is necessary, he said.
The US bishops’ “vigourous opposition” to many of the administration’s actions on immigration has been taken because the Gospels “compel us to do so,” Bishop Vasquez stated.
“ Along with the right choices on refugee resettlement, DACA, and TPS, we also need comprehensive immigration reform,” he added, saying there is a need for a path to legalization and citizenship, acknowledging at the same time that “our country also has the right, and the responsibility, to secure its borders.”
Responding to the migration committee’s presentation, Bishop Jaime Soto of Sacramento maintained that “the existence of the TPS population is in a certain sense a condemnation of the inability of Congress and administrations over the past 21 years to provide comprehensive immigration reform,” saying that having held them “in this holding pattern for decades is unconscionable.”
Archbishop Gomez stated that “all of us have to have a conversion, and that’s why it’s so important to talk about this, because people don’t know what the Church teaches,” which echoed comments made by Cardinal Blase Cupich of Chicago.
The Chicago archbishop had lamented the “the poisoning rhetoric that is degrading of immigrants, and even demonizing of them,” which “is having an effect on our own people, because they pick up that language … there’s something wrong in our churches when the gospel is proclaimed but people leave parishes with that rhetoric still in their hearts.”
Archbishop Gomez commented that “it’s important for us to call people to conversion, and explain to them what is it we teach; it’s so essential for the future of our country.”
Bishop Vasquez reiterated the importance of conveying the Church’s teaching, and also of fostering personal encounters with immigrants or refugees. “Once you do that you understand the situation of persons … just like us, therefore we empathize and are in solidarity with them; that’s what brings conversion and change of mind.”
Bishop Oscar Cantu of Las Cruces raised the question of how to counter charges that immigration policy is a matter of prudential judgement, and that the faithful may therefore in good conscience come to a judgement which differs from that of the bishops.
Bishop Thomas Wenski of Miami responded that “we’re making our prudential judgement, too … in the light of Catholic teaching.” He emphasized that “immigrants are not problems, but brothers and sisters; strangers, but strangers who should be embraced as brothers and sisters. We’re offering what we think is best, not only for the immigrants, but for our society as a whole. We can make America great, but you don’t make America great by making America mean.”
Immigration reform, he maintained, must “include the common good of everyone: Americans and those who wish to be Americans.”
Bishop Soto responded that deportations do not fall under the category of prudential judgement, but rather were included by St. John Paul II in his 1995 encyclical Evangelium vitae among the sins which cry out to heaven, and so is not merely “consistent with Church teaching,” but “to discard it as a prudential judgement doesn’t reflect our tradition.”
Archbishop Salvatore Cordileone of San Francisco recommended the five principles from Strangers No Longer as a sine qua non, on which “there can be no disagreement” among Catholics. “While there’s room for prudential judgement, it’s not something that can be taken lightly” because it “involves such basic considerations of justice.”
[…]
A very special man. Articulate, compassionate, having excellent understanding and leadership abilities! God sends us men and women to show the way forward. We know that only our Lord and saviour is perfect, still King brought us humanity and a closer walk with the Lord.
1 Peter 4:10 As each has received a gift, use it to serve one another, as good stewards of God’s varied grace:
2 Timothy 2:15 Do your best to present yourself to God as one approved, a worker who has no need to be ashamed, rightly handling the word of truth.
Romans 12:11 Do not be slothful in zeal, be fervent in spirit, serve the Lord.
Romans 7:6 But now we are released from the law, having died to that which held us captive, so that we serve in the new way of the Spirit and not in the old way of the written code.
Acts 20:35 In all things I have shown you that by working hard in this way we must help the weak and remember the words of the Lord Jesus, how he himself said, ‘It is more blessed to give than to receive.’”
John 12:26 If anyone serves me, he must follow me; and where I am, there will my servant be also. If anyone serves me, the Father will honour him.
Blessings for his family.
We read: “Beyond remembering and quoting Dr. King today, we must act to address racial disparities in the criminal justice system, access to affordable housing and health care, and economic opportunities,” [Archbishop] Broglio wrote. “The USCCB continues to support policy changes in these areas of society.”
Thank you for this observance, and in full agreement…But also a caution about any “policy changes” for society as viewed from inside the Beltway.
Recalling, here, that family income disparities are reportedly correlated much more with single parent families than with race. So, with an eye to “society” as distinct from government, maybe a “policy,” within the Church itself, of preaching the meaning and indissolubility of marriage? And sexual morality? All related to the spousal union between Christ and His Church, and the meaning of ongoing Eucharistic coherence/revival.
Also recalling the global economic recession of 2008! Starting with the collapse of real-estate giant Washington Mutual, and then spreading nationally and globally (an economic pandemic!), and as bad apples, finally infecting bundled financial instruments (called “derivatives”). The meltdown attributed by the establishment to greedy banks, but the little-reported backstory was that banks were threatened with loss of their charters if they refused to issue insecure home loans—a homeownership inclusion (!) policy from good ol’ Uncle Sam (the guy with the $31 Trillion national debt).
The Law of Unintended Consequences….The overall message here is to not be lured into assuming, possibly and ideologically, that the Administrative State is the go-to solution for deeper and systemic pathologies within “society.”
It’s so disappointing to see that all CWR could publish on MLK Jr Day is this news piece and not essays or reflections about the man and his message for us today. It is obvious that CWR like many conservative white Catholics have embraced the hard right agenda in fighting anti-racism which aims to erase MLK Jr’s legacy and perpetuate racism to maintain white supremacy. Consider the anti-woke hysteria of recent times which CWR has editorially taken and promoted. This is indicative of the often misunderstood or forgotten understanding that to be a true Catholic is to be neither conservative nor progressive but to be radical. It is to be rooted (radix) in Jesus Christ whose Gospel is the reconciliation of all divisions that Paul declared to the Galatians (Gal 3:28). In today’s terms this message can be taken to mean that in Jesus Christ there is neither black nor white; Democrat nor Republican; rich nor poor; alien nor citizen; straight nor queer; inmate nor free; housed nor unhoused…. It’s best that more Catholics especially those of the conservative bent to cease the almost second-nature hate towards Pope Francis and read his 2020 encyclical letter, Fratelli Tutti, on Fraternity and Social Friendship.
“It is obvious that CWR like many conservative white Catholics have embraced the hard right agenda in fighting anti-racism which aims to erase MLK Jr’s legacy and perpetuate racism to maintain white supremacy.”
You obviously don’t really know CWR or read it carefully. You certainly don’t me (for the record, I’ve been the Editor of CWR for a decade). I’ll have to share your comments with my children, who are black and Hispanic (they are adopted). I’m sure they’d like to learn more about how I’ve been helping CWR embrace and promote “white supremacy” and racism.
I’ll also mention it to my good friend Deacon Harold Burke-Sivers, who has written about racism for CWR and who has a book coming out soon on the topic.
Of course, your crude rhetorical approach gives you away. In short, you employ politically-loaded language to misrepresent what CWR actually publishes, while complaining about what CWR doesn’t publish (and also while overlooking this other CNA piece we posted on racism in the U.S., etc.) And never mind the numerous pieces CWR has posted over the years on Dr. King and similar figures.
And your misrepresentation of St. Paul’s words and intent in Galatians is just as revealing. You like to smear and slander. How very Christ-like of you.
Dear Mr Brice:
Catholics typically want to support the pope. It makes sense and yet, the incumbent steps outside of the bounds of church tradition, not to mention fidelity to Christ. It is not difficult to touch on recent examples. Should the faithful remain mute?
Titus 2:15 Declare these things; exhort and rebuke with all authority. Let no one disregard you.
2 Timothy 4:2 Preach the word; be ready in season and out of season; reprove, rebuke, and exhort, with complete patience and teaching.
1 Timothy 5:20 As for those who persist in sin, rebuke them in the presence of all, so that the rest may stand in fear.
These guidelines pertain to liberal and conservative followers of Christ. Where there is disharmony it needs to be addressed. If the cause of the problem happens to come from the top, the same rules apply.
God bless you,
Brian Young