The Dispatch: More from CWR...

Dobbs hysteria and Russian disinformation

Distorting the things of God for political purposes is yet another tactic in the creation of an alternative reality.

An abortion demonstrator in Washington is seen outside the U.S. Supreme Court May 3, 2022, after the leak of a draft opinion on the court's upcoming abortion ruling was published. (CNS photo/Evelyn Hockstein, Reuters)

There are striking parallels between the Russian disinformation campaign that continues to foul the global communications space in the third month of the war on Ukraine and the hysterical screeds of pro-abortion American politicians after a draft Supreme Court decision in the Dobbs case leaked. In both instances, those who’ve lost an argument — or who had no argument to begin with — resort to creating an alternative reality through euphemisms that are the functional equivalent of lies.

President Joe Biden’s contribution to alternative reality was to declare that Roe v. Wade (which created the world’s most libertine abortion law) “says what all basic mainstream religions have historically concluded, that the existence of a human life and being is a question.” Buried within that muddled syntax was the pernicious claim that the question of when human life begins is religious, not empirical. It is not; it never has been; and it never will be. That human life begins at conception is a scientific fact, once known to high school sophomores from biology class.

And isn’t there an ominous parallel between President Biden’s nonsensical assertion that there’s no settled answer to when life begins and President Vladimir Putin’s equally nonsensical claim that Ukraine is neither a real nation nor a sovereign state, but rather an integral part of the “Russian world” that must be restored to its proper place within that “world”? Both claims bespeak an alternative reality to, well, reality.

Then there is the mantra invoked by Speaker Nancy Pelosi and others, that the Roe v. Wade regime of abortion-on-demand is essential to “reproductive health care.” The corruption of language here is staggering — and finds its parallel in Putin’s insistence that his invasion of Ukraine was a “special military operation,” not an act of war.

In a seminal 1946 essay, “Politics and the English Language,” George Orwell argued that “ugly and inaccurate” language in politics “is designed to make lies sound truthful and murder respectable, and to give an appearance of solidity to pure wind.” This is what Pelosi and Putin do when they refuse to call things by their right names, when they deploy euphemisms to mask the reality of something brutal and repulsive, and when, in doing so, they deceive the publics they claim to lead. Many Americans are rightly aghast at the levels of Russian popular support for Putin’s murderous aggression, which is partially the result of the Russian people being fed a steady diet of lies by state-controlled media. But isn’t that lethal diet of euphemisms and falsehoods analogous to tarting up abortion as “reproductive health care” essential to “women’s empowerment”?

President Biden and Speaker Pelosi have cut through the smog of Putin’s propaganda and told the truth about Russia and Ukraine. That they cannot or will not see that they are deploying Putinesque tactics in their support of the constitutionally indefensible Roe v. Wade tells us just how debased, even grotesque, the defense of abortion-on-demand has become.

Distorting the things of God for political purposes is yet another tactic in the creation of an alternative reality.

On May 3, the president of the House of Deputies of the Episcopal Church, the Rev. Gay Clark Jennings, decried pro-lifers’ efforts to “exercise theocratic control” over others and declared that, “As Episcopalians, we have a particular obligation to stand against Christians who seek to destroy our multicultural democracy and recast the United States as an idol to the cruel and distorted Christianity they advocate.” Thus, she concluded, “we must make our Christian witness to the dignity of every human being by insisting that we support the right to safe and legal reproductive health care because our faith in a compassionate God requires us to do so.”

Query to the Rev. Jennings: Does our “compassionate God” have nothing to say about the tens of millions of innocents killed in vitro by “safe and legal reproductive health care”?

The Rev. Jennings’ May 3 summons to the pro-abortion barricades will have struck orthodox Christian ears as bizarre, even heretical. But was it materially different from a sermon preached that same day in the Kremlin’s Archangel Cathedral? There, Patriarch Kirill of Moscow and All Rus’ declared that “Russia has never attacked anyone. It is amazing that a great and powerful country never attacked anyone — it only defended its borders. God grant that…our country [will continue to] be like this — strong and powerful and at the same time loved by God.”

Jennings and Kirill betray the Gospel by embracing two forms of the culture of death. No humane society can be built on that lethal foundation.


If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!

Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.


About George Weigel 400 Articles
George Weigel is Distinguished Senior Fellow of Washington's Ethics and Public Policy Center, where he holds the William E. Simon Chair in Catholic Studies. He is the author of over twenty books, including Witness to Hope: The Biography of Pope John Paul II (1999), The End and the Beginning: Pope John Paul II—The Victory of Freedom, the Last Years, the Legacy (2010), and The Irony of Modern Catholic History: How the Church Rediscovered Itself and Challenged the Modern World to Reform. His most recent books are The Next Pope: The Office of Peter and a Church in Mission (2020), and Not Forgotten: Elegies for, and Reminiscences of, a Diverse Cast of Characters, Most of Them Admirable (Ignatius, 2021).

8 Comments

  1. Has there ever been a more tenuous rhetorical parallel than the one drawn in this article? There is no conceivable connection whatsoever between the American abortion debate and the situation in Ukraine. But Weigel is so overcome by the prospect of mounting two hobbyhorses at once that he presses on, heedless of his own absurdity. It would almost be admirable, this degree of chutzpah, were the consequences not so deadly.

    But hold on. Perhaps there is a connection after all, and much more apposite one: Both George Weigel and the pro-abortion lobby are happy to sacrifice the lives of others for their own ends.

    Never forget that Weigel tirelessly advocated for the “special military operation” in Iraq, which cost hundreds of thousands of lives and left an entire region in disarray. Weigel is likewise serene over the prospect of fighting Russia to the last Ukrainian, and given his history, we might even speculate that he would not be greatly disturbed if NATO were drawn into direct military conflict with Russia.

    Why does CWR continue to indulge this unrepentant warmonger? We all make mistakes, but Weigel is reliably wrong, and his errors contribute to death on a mass scale. Yes, he’s written books about popes, but isn’t there a limit?

    • How does one muddle things in this fashion? The criticism of abortion arguments are both clear and indisputable. Bravo Weigel. The assertions about Russian disinformation are ludicrous and serve to undercut his general credibility. One could easily demonstrate the American led NATO propaganda that Weigel is pushing here.

  2. I decided not to put any argument for or against. But I noticed that so far there was only 1 comment. So I decided to say hello to the author and wish him well at the seminar in Poland, May 18-19.

    I also wish the seminar well.

    As a matter of fact, I am moved to say that the alternative to the vision of the Porochenko-Zelensky-Biden group, for Ukraine’s “place in things”, would be productive and stable and benefiting to everybody. It’s only common sense.

    There’d be no fighting or carnage or death or euphemisms or insulting names. No fast-moving attention-grabbing stuff. It would bring a lot of discipline everywhere and there would be no use for false comparisons and reverse labeling, et hoc genus omne.

    https://www.avemarialaw.edu/john-paul-iis-natural-law-legacy-international-human-rights/

    https://www.catholicnewsagency.com/news/251228/church-leaders-and-scholars-to-explore-st-john-paul-ii-s-natural-law-legacy

  3. Somehow, I believe abortion & Putin’s Ukraine invasion could be classified,as a “special
    operation”.The result in them both is the same.Death and Misery.One has snuffed out 60
    million lives.The other thousands.”One death is a tragedy.Millions are just a statistic”
    Joe Stalin.

    • G. Raff none of it makes common sense. Same for George Weigel where, see above, he got stuck:

      ‘ President Biden and Speaker Pelosi have cut through the smog of Putin’s propaganda and told the truth about Russia and Ukraine. That they cannot or will not see that they are deploying Putinesque tactics in their support of the constitutionally indefensible Roe v. Wade tells us just how debased, even grotesque, the defense of abortion-on-demand has become.

      Distorting the things of God for political purposes is yet another tactic in the creation of an alternative reality. ‘

      I had resolved not to have a go at him; but I had not made that resolution for you.

  4. Your comments relating to Russia and Putin, are wrong, ‘period’. For any informed person, let alone educated. You have the smug audacity to consider yourself both worthy and entitled to make public comments in an international Catholic periodical on Russia and Putin that you are utterly and appallingly ignorant of. It is pathetic. Pushing an agenda that is nothing but collected propaganda and gossip from anybody who can watch a television. You purport to seek truth, that’s what it really means to be a Catholic.
    So seek it.

1 Trackback / Pingback

  1. Dobbs hysteria and Russian disinformation – Via Nova Media

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

All comments posted at Catholic World Report are moderated. While vigorous debate is welcome and encouraged, please note that in the interest of maintaining a civilized and helpful level of discussion, comments containing obscene language or personal attacks—or those that are deemed by the editors to be needlessly combative or inflammatory—will not be published. Thank you.


*