Documentary tells the story of “a great player, but an even greater man”

A review of Soul of a Champion: The Gil Hodges Story.

(Image: Screenshot /

MPAA Rating: Not rated
USCCB Rating: Not rated
Reel Rating: 3 out of 5 reels

Baseball is, I think, God’s favorite sport. This is no doubt a controversial opinion and admittedly purely subjective, but I stand firmly by it. In its game play, history, and characters, baseball best mirrors the cadence and drama of life, so beautifully that even atheist comedian George Carlin recognized its divine nature. Many of the legendary figures of America’s history were involved in the national pastime, such as Babe Ruth, Jackie Robinson, and Branch Ricky.

Despite my affinity for the game, I was largely unfamiliar with Gil Hodges, the beloved Dodgers player and Mets manager. Baseball historian Mark Langill has said that “there are two great mysteries about the Dodgers: first, what happened to Kirk Gibson’s home run ball and second, why isn’t Gil Hodges in the Hall of Fame?” While Gibson’s ball may be lost forever, the documentary Soul of a Champion makes a compelling case that Hodges absolutely should be in the Hall, which may indeed happen quite soon.

The documentary follows a standard plotline, beginning with Hodges’ childhood. He was raised in an upstanding Catholic family with several siblings and two hard working parents. His father was a poor coal miner who was determined his sons have more success in life and even more determined they would go to heaven. Masses, rosaries, and meatless Fridays were staples of the Hodges household. Year later, even when on the road with nothing else to eat, Gil would never eat a steak on Friday. Throughout his life, Gil attended Mass not just on Sundays but often throughout the week, without fanfare.

Jackie Robinson called Hodges “the core of the Dodgers” and his teammate Duke Snider said, “Gil was a great player, but an even greater man.” Considered one of the greatest first basemen of all time, he was frequently in the top ten of the National League in batting average, hits, runs, RBIs, and homers during the 1950s. He earned three Golden Glove awards, was chosen for the All-Star team seven times, and was the seventh man to hit over 300 home runs in his league. Apart from statistics, he was a calming and positive influence on his teammates and fans, demonstrating exceptional sportsmanship. Several Dodgers players and coaches have stated he was the only player never booed at Ebetts Field. It is only fitting that he was the last man to score a run in that ballpark before the team moved to Los Angeles in 1958.

After a successful playing career which included the sole World Series win in 1955 for the Brooklyn Dodgers, he became manager for the New York Mets in the late 1960s. The newly formed Mets had a less than stellar reputation, earning the nickname “lovable losers.” Yet they steadily improved throughout the decade and, to the shock of the country, found themselves in the 1969 World Series. In the fifth game, Mets batter Cleon Jones claimed to have been hit by a pitch. When Hodges showed the umpire a speck of shoe polish on the ball, Jones was awarded the base which turned the tide of the game. The “Miracle Mets” won the series 4-1 over the heavily favored Baltimore Orioles. Only in his late 40s, he had a promising managerial career ahead of him but died suddenly of a massive heart attack on April 3, 1972 after a round of golf. Thousands attended his funeral. Hodges’ son found Jackie Robinson crying alone in his car outside the church, wracked with grief and fear. Robinson himself died only a few months later, and the Hodges family were present at his funeral as well.

Produced by the Catholic Association of Athletes, Soul of a Champion has two primary goals. First, it makes a compelling case that Hodges should be in the Hall of Fame in Cooperstown. There will be a vote on his inclusion on December 9th, so the release timing of the program is certainly no accident. Second, it puts Hodges forward as an example of how “to let your light shine before men, that they may see your good deeds and praise your Father in Heaven.” Hodges was a Catholic man of tremendous faith, not known for political activism or pious proclamations, but for quiet dignity, integrity, and doing his job well. I was reminded of G.K. Chesterton’s quote: “the most extraordinary thing in the world is an ordinary man and an ordinary woman and their ordinary children.”

I don’t review many films that are online and free, but here is Soul of a Champion for free and legal viewing. It’s a simple story made for a specific reason that will probably be boring for some. Yet, as a Catholic father and baseball fanatic, it was one the my favorite films I’ve watched this year.

(Editors’ note: Cleon Jones was erroneously identified as “Cleon James” in this review. That error has been corrected.)

If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!

Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.

About Nick Olszyk 198 Articles
Nick Olszyk teaches theology at Marist Catholic High School in Eugene, Oregon. He was raised on bad science fiction movies, jelly beans, and TV shows that make fun of bad science fiction movies. Visit him online and listen to his podcast at "Catholic Cinema Crusade".


  1. HIGHLY recommended reading: ‘Praying for Gil Hodges’ – a memoir of the 1955 World Series – specifically the final game – by Thomas Oliphant. Best description – “A small masterpiece”. A lovely piece of writing.

    You can thank me later.

  2. Vaguely remember Gil Hodges. Anyways while a good MLB player think his stats fall short of Hall of Fame (HOF) status. For example his lifetime Win Above Replacement or WAR is somewhere around 43 where the average first basemen in the baseball is in the mid 60’s. First basemen is generally a power position ie homerun and RBI’s, his stats, while good, are not HOF caliber.

    While this documentary is something I would like to see, more deserving players not in the HOF are Detroit Tigers stars Bill Freeman and Lou Whitaker.

  3. Gil Hodges nearly spoiled Don Larsen’s perfect game in the 1956 World Series. He hit a drive deep to left field but the great Yankee centerfielder, Mickey Mantle, made a spectacular catch and robbed Hodges. My older brother was in Yankee Stadium for that game. If you were not, you can still see it on Youtube. Don’t miss it.

  4. Gil Hodges was born and raised in my hometown of Petersburg, IN and is still considered our hometown hero. Great story about Gil: He was mired in a hitting slump during the long, hot days of August. During Sunday mass in Brooklyn, the priest gets up to deliver his homily. “It’s too hot for a homily. Pray for Gil Hodges.” He was a great man and a great baseball player. Statistics do not show the whole story. He belongs in the Hall of Fame.

  5. Thank you for opening the story by acknowledging that baseball may be God’s favorite sport. I can’t prove it, but I am convinced that on the 8th Day, he created baseball.

  6. Seems my, what I thought were innocent posts about baseball, were censored. Just like they do on Google and Facebook. They were innocent posts. Sorry to offend who ever got offended. All over Gil Hodges and baseball? This will be my last post. Very disappointed in this publication. Take me off your mailing and subscriber list please. Merry Christmas and God Bless. PS-the post waiting for moderation? Just cancel it.

    • Willard: No one censored your comments; they put through. But because we actually moderate every comment and because WordPress isn’t perfect, there is sometimes a delay.

1 Trackback / Pingback

  1. Documentary tells the story of “a great player, but an even greater man” – Catholic World Report – The Old Roman

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

All comments posted at Catholic World Report are moderated. While vigorous debate is welcome and encouraged, please note that in the interest of maintaining a civilized and helpful level of discussion, comments containing obscene language or personal attacks—or those that are deemed by the editors to be needlessly combative or inflammatory—will not be published. Thank you.