The Dispatch: More from CWR...

War of words over New York’s compulsory COVID vaccines

Gov. Kathy Hochul says there are no legitimate religious objections; Thomas More Society’s Christopher Ferrara accuses her of bullying and ‘strong-arm’ tactics.

New York Gov. Kathy Hochul at a Sept. 27, 2021 press event. (Photo: Screen capture / YouTube)

The war over compulsory COVID-19 shots for health care workers spilled from the federal courtroom onto the streets of the Bronx as New York Gov. Kathy Hochul stated her intention to replace health care workers who refuse the gene-serum shots and are fired as a result. Hochul appeared unconcerned about the temporary restraining order by U.S. District Judge David N. Hurd that bars the state from enforcing the vaccine policy that officially took effect Sept. 27.

“Today is a significant deadline,” Hochul said at a press conference. “It reflects my priority to stop this virus dead in its tracks. We are over it, we are done and we want to move on, and the only way we can do that is to ensure that everyone is vaccinated, but particularly individuals who take care of the people who are sick.”

Under then-Gov. Andrew Cuomo, New York had a policy that allowed health care workers with sincerely held religious objections to refuse to take the COVID-19 shots. That policy changed under Hochul, who was sworn into office Aug. 24 after Cuomo resigned amid a sexual-harassment scandal. The new policy allows no religious exemptions, and gave health care workers until Sept. 27 to show proof of their first COVID shot. The mandate prompted two federal lawsuits by health care workers: one filed by the Thomas More Society in the Northern District of New York and another filed by Liberty Counsel in the Eastern District of New York.

Judge Hurd extended the restraining order until Oct. 12 and said he will rule before then on Thomas More Society’s request for a preliminary injunction against New York and the vaccine mandate. A hearing has been set for Oct. 19 in the federal court’s Eastern District in the Liberty Counsel case on behalf of 1,500 health care workers who challenge the shot mandate.

In her Monday press event, Hochul blamed unvaccinated health care workers for the looming staff shortages sure to occur if hundreds or even thousands of care workers are fired or resign for refusing the COVID shot. She also discounted the notion of a religious exception to the shot policy.

“There are not legitimate religious exemptions, because the leaders of all the organized religions have said there’s no legitimate reason,” Hochul said, “and we’re going to win that in court in a matter of days. This is so unnecessary.”

Those comments drew a strong rebuke from Christopher A. Ferrara, Thomas More Society special counsel, who accused the governor of strong-arm tactics and demagoguery.

“New York’s Governor Hochul is using every strong-arm tactic she can to attempt to coerce employees into taking vaccines against their will,” Ferrara said in a statement. “She is also demonstrating disrespect, at a minimum, if not outright hostility to the deeply held religious convictions of our clients as well as thousands of others. We have solid grounds for prevailing on our motion for a preliminary injunction.”

A group of 16 Catholic and one Baptist health care workers filed suit against Gov. Hochul and the State of New York on Sept. 13 in U.S. District Court in Utica, N.Y. Judge Hurd issued the restraining order less than 24 hours later. The plaintiffs include doctors, nurses, medical technologists, a cognitive rehabilitation therapist and a physician’s liaison. At the time, Ferrara ripped the State of New York for what he called “a flagrantly illegal mandate from constitutionally clueless government bureaucrats.”

Although the Catholic Hochul scoffed at the idea of religious exemptions to the coercive shot policy, she cloaked her arguments for the shots in religious overtones. Appearing at a Baptist assembly, Hochul told attendees to be “not just the true believers, but our apostles to go out there and spread the word that we can get out of this once and for all if everybody gets vaccinated.” At a Christian center in Brooklyn, she told a gathering that health care workers refusing the vaccines “aren’t listening to God and what God wants.”

Ferrara said the governor’s message amounts to coercion. “The Governor’s bullying is intended to coerce as many as possible into taking the vaccine before the court rules,” Ferrara said. “And now she threatens to declare a state of emergency based on the emergency she herself has created by calling for the firing of dedicated front line health care workers who were yesterday’s heroes but are suddenly pariahs because they will not bend to the governor’s arbitrary will.”

“The same doctors and nurses who treated patients for 18 months without being vaccinated—often contracting COVID, recovering, and returning to front line medical care—are now being depicted as disease-carrying villains,” Ferrara said. “This is not science. This is demagoguery.”

Liberty Counsel Chairman Mat Staver said, “All New York health care workers have the legal right to request reasonable accommodation for their sincerely held religious beliefs, and forcing COVID shots without any religious exemptions is unlawful. We look forward to presenting this evidence in court on behalf of these employees who are being unlawfully bullied.”

Hochul said she would sign an emergency declaration allowing her to activate National Guard members with medical training to fill in if a rash of firings create severe staff shortages at hospitals, nursing homes and other health facilities. Other options include bringing workers from other states or countries, she said.

“First of all, those of you who have been vaccinated, I thank you from the bottom of my heart for doing what was right and helping lead the way so we do have the confidence we need,” the governor said. “To those who have not yet made that decision, please do the right thing. We have a lot of facilities, a lot of your employers are anxious to just give you the jab in the arm and say, ‘You’re part of the family, we need your help (to) continue on.’ ”

Judge Hurd’s restraining order forbids the state from interfering with issuance of religious exemptions to the shot mandates. Hochul said she had spoken to facility administrators who are “making some accommodations” for workers who try to claim a religious exemption, but then she quickly added “they’re also not going to let them do that. They’re not going to let them work until they … so they want to see what’s going to happen with the court case as well.”

Plaintiffs in the New York cases cite the COVID-19 shots’ use of cell lines derived from abortions in the research, testing and production of the mRNA shots from Pfizer-BioNTech, Johnson & Johnson, Moderna and AstraZeneca.

Catholics have had to navigate choppy seas of disparate advice from bishops and theologians on whether the COVID-19 shots are morally permissible. The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (CDF) said in a 2020 document that “vaccination is not, as a rule, a moral obligation” and therefore “it must be voluntary.” The CDF document said if no “ethically irreproachable” vaccines are available, it is morally acceptable to receive vaccines that used cells lines from aborted children in research or production. Receiving vaccines in this circumstance “does not constitute formal cooperation with the abortion…”

As the growing list of federal and state lawsuits has made clear, the reasons for opposing inoculation with the mRNA shots goes well beyond the abortion debate into whether the shots are safe or effective. The federal Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) lists 15,386 deaths related to COVID-19 vaccines since December 2020. That is more deaths tied to COVID vaccines than for all other kinds of vaccines—combined—since 1990. The voluntary VAERS reporting database is said to reflect less than 10 percent of actual deaths and injuries. Nearly 50 percent of the COVID vaccine deaths occurred within a week of getting the shot, according to an analysis by OpenVAERS. More than 38 percent of deaths occurred within three days of getting a COVID shot.

Adding to those concerns are worries the federal government and mainstream media outlets are not being truthful about the COVID shots and possible side effects, such as myocarditis, heart attack, miscarriage, Bell’s Palsy and anaphylaxis. Public discussion of preventive regimens that use drugs like ivermectin are routinely censored on social media, as are stories about COVID treatment protocols using hydroxychloroquine, fluvoxamine, pravastatin, budesonide, ivermectin and other medications. 

Even the very definition of “vaccine” seems to flow with the current. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) listed the following definition for vaccine on its web site prior to Sept. 1, 2021: “A product that stimulates a person’s immune system to produce immunity to a specific disease, protecting the person from that disease.” Immunity was defined as “protection from an infectious disease. If you are immune to a disease, you can be exposed to it without becoming infected.” The wording was confirmed using a snapshot of the web site archived by the WayBack Machine at Internet Archive. 

The new definition of vaccine removed any reference to immunity: “A preparation that is used to stimulate the body’s immune response against diseases.” The CDC definition for “vaccination” was changed from a vaccine used to produce immunity, to a vaccine used “to produce protection.” (Emphasis added.)

Vice President Kamala Harris suggested on Twitter Sept. 12 that people vaccinated against COVID-19 need protecting from the unvaccinated. That kind of logic causes some observers to question the accepted narrative and call for more robust discussion, not less.

Dr. Janet E. Smith, recently retired from the Father McGivney Chair of Life Ethics at Sacred Heart Major Seminary in Detroit, published a Sept. 27 essay, “The Fake Theology Behind Vaccine Mandates,” citing a dozen concerns of the unvaccinated and explaining the proper role of conscience in vaccine discussions.

“People who get vaccinated still die from COVID-19; how effective can the vaccine be?” Smith wrote. “What other vaccine requires that the vaccinated be protected against the unvaccinated?”

Ferrara raised the same point in the lawsuit seeking a preliminary injunction against the New York vaccine mandate. “As things now stand, according to ‘public health authorities’ the vaccinated can infect the unvaccinated, the unvaccinated can infect the vaccinated, both the vaccinated and the unvaccinated can infect each other, and everyone must wear masks indoors in ‘high transmission’ areas—that is, virtually the entire country—as if no one at all had been vaccinated.”

If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!

Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.

About Joseph M. Hanneman 101 Articles
Joseph M. Hanneman writes from Madison, Wisconsin.


  1. This is the same person that said they weren’t looking to the Constitution when they ramrodded Obamacare down the throats of the American people.

    Apparently the right to health care and the right not to be sick trump the right to freedom of religion and freedom of conscience.

  2. For the Marxist Hochul. It’s only a “Hop-Skip-and a Jump” to replace the Police with the Treasonous General Milley and our Military {National Guard}.If she can do it to our medical care employees? It’s not to hard to picture a scenario not unlike what befell the Catholic Diem Brothers on November 2nd,1963.Aided and abetted of course by our own CIA.Along with the FBI this time around as willing useful idiots.

  3. Bring back the sexual harasser! At lease he understood that there are people with sincerely-held religious beliefs who cannot in good conscience promote immoral acquisition of vaccines or fetal cell research going forward. Hochul doesn’t believe in religious exemptions, so one might wonder how she has the audacity to speak for God.

  4. If a woman can say regarding abortion My Body My Choice. This is accepted.
    The constitution says I have the right to life liberty adnd the pursuit of happiness.
    You do not have the right to take away my freedom to choose or not to choose a vaccination.

  5. I don’t get all this fuss about the COVID vaccines. Not mentioned in this article is what a large impact for good they have had once you get up to a high enough proportion of the population, as we have in the UK. We’re still getting cases, but if you are vaccinated and in good health there is no longer risk of needing to go to hospital or dying. Be picky if you want about this kind of vaccine not stopping infection – but who cares when the weakened form of the virus you might get is no worse than a bad flu-ey cold?

    Talk of people sacked from jobs is unnecessary, at least it is here. There are plenty of health care jobs which don’t involve direct patient interaction, which staff who can’t or won’t be vaccinated can be deployed to.

    Lastly, be careful with numbers of deaths, especially those claimed following vaccination. In the early days here when it was the very elderly or otherwise unwell who were being vaccinated, many unfortunately were still catching COVID before they had both shots or before enough time had passed for it to take effect.

  6. She is doing the work of the evil one the vaccination does not work!. I can see down the line the world walking around like the Zombies on The walking dead once the consequences kick in from the vax. Yah I am sure this is what God wants! Just like God wanted Hitler to create his so called perfect race! She is a “fake” Catholic just like Biden. She is worse then Cuomo!

  7. Vaccinated people are giving vaccinated and unvaccinated people covid, thus it’s illogial, irrational and unreasonable to punish unvaccinated people. A more reasonable approach is to mandate masks and rapid testing for employees. Duh.

1 Trackback / Pingback

  1. War of words over New York’s compulsory COVID vaccines – Catholic World Report – The Old Roman

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

All comments posted at Catholic World Report are moderated. While vigorous debate is welcome and encouraged, please note that in the interest of maintaining a civilized and helpful level of discussion, comments containing obscene language or personal attacks—or those that are deemed by the editors to be needlessly combative or inflammatory—will not be published. Thank you.