The Dispatch: More from CWR...

Canadian Catholics retain identity more than U.S. Catholics, but decline in practice is similar

John Longhurst By John Longhurst for EWTN News
Interior of the Notre-Dame Cathedral Basilica, Ottawa, Canada. (Image: Marc-Olivier Jodoin/Unsplash.com)

WINNIPEG, Manitoba, Canada — If someone is raised Catholic in the United States, there is a 75% chance that as an adult, that person is no longer Catholic — or he or she is still a Catholic but hardly ever attends Mass.

Ryan Burge, an American political scientist who specializes in research about religion in American life, published these findings and others on his website titled Graphs About Religion.

Using information from the U.S. General Social Survey and the Pew Religious Landscape Survey, Burge found that in 2024, nearly three-quarters of Americans raised Catholic were either no longer Catholic, or they identified as Catholic but never or seldom attended Mass.

How does that compare with Canada?

Catholics in Canada retain more of their identity than Americans, but how they practice their faith is similar to what is happening in the U.S., said Sarah Wilkins-Laflamme, who teaches sociology and studies religion in Canada at the University of Waterloo in Ontario.

“Catholic identity is important and is retained by many in Canada, but the practice for many started disappearing in the 1990s,” she said. “This is definitely true in Quebec, but also, to a lesser extent, in the rest of Canada.”

Wilkins-Laflamme said her research shows retention rates for Catholics are higher in Canada, but mostly as a cultural expression.

These are people who “value the identity of being Catholic, they see that as strongly tied to their family heritage, maybe their regional and national identity, like in Quebec,” she said.

“But for the most part, they have no practical ties with the Church. They don’t like the Church that much. And they don’t really agree with any of its policies.”

These Catholics might go to church services on special occasions or holidays, like Christmas or Easter. For the most part they are “very detached from the institution, but even that is now disappearing,” she said.

Only 10% of Catholics in Quebec say they practice their religion “with any regularity, let alone weekly,” Wilkins-Laflamme added, noting that in the rest of Canada “it’s not much more than that.”

Overall, Canadian Catholics have a good retention of their Catholic identity, but not of practice, she stated.

“It’s kind of, yes, there’s some religion, maybe like some vague beliefs in God. But it’s essentially a cultural identity, a tie to your family heritage. And even that is going down in Canada, although not by the same numbers as in the U.S.,” she said.

One source of the decline, Wilkins-Laflamme said, is that Catholic parents are not raising their children in the faith.

“Parents might say they’re Catholic, but if they don’t bother raising their kids Catholic, the children will remember their childhood as nonreligious,” she said. “They’ll just look like cradle nonreligious, raised nonreligious.”

Where the Catholic Church might have gained from immigration in the past, the federal government now is limiting the number of newcomers, she observed. “So they might not be getting as much from that source in the future, and their birth rates are quite low. They’re aging,” she said.

Joel Thiessen studies religion as a sociologist at Ambrose University in Calgary, Alberta, and is director of the Flourishing Congregations Institute. He agreed with Wilkins-Laflamme.

“I think Catholic parents in Canada are not terribly Catholic themselves,” he said. “So that’s part of the reason for the challenges of retention.”

Catholic schools and parishes could play a role in helping with religious transmission, but “there isn’t a lot of integration happening between those different institutional spaces, despite their best attempts,” he said. “And I think that weakens things.”

One of the challenges is a lack of youth workers in parishes, compared with Protestant churches, where many churches hire youth pastors to work with teens, which aids with higher retention among some Protestant churches.

“I think that in part helps to account for why Catholics are hemorrhaging more than Protestants,” Thiessen said.

Since personal ties to someone like a youth worker make a big difference for retention, that is a crucial piece, Thiessen said. “The current infrastructure doesn’t support it,” he said.

This story was first published by Canadian Catholic News and has been reprinted here, with adaptations, with permission.


If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!

Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.


12 Comments

  1. “Canadian Catholics retain identity more than U.S. Catholics, but decline in practice is similar”

    What the h#ll is that supposed to mean? Yikes!

    • Agree. I had time to only skim the study, but I did not see any clearly succinct definitions of “identity” or “retention.” Also, I saw no numerical demarcations for what constituted “identity” or “retention.” Was a person considered Catholic if he claimed to be so? Was he considered Catholic if he was Baptized? Was he categorized Catholic only if his parents had been? What defined a “Catholic”?

      For retention: Was a person considered “retained” if he attended Mass once a year or twice? Was he retained if he claimed he still belonged to the faith, or if he received Eucharist once/year? What were the parameters for belonging to one or another category?

      Finally, comparing one study for Americans vs. another study (with completely different parameters and definitions) gives spurious (false or misleading) results.

      IOW, a complete waste of time. Disingenuous, infantile, meaningless. The study could have been nothing more than a designed sociological jab at American Catholicism. It could be that some professor’s tenure hinged on a study gaining inordinate computer clicks.

      I could be wrong, but someone with time (and skill – Peter Beaulieu perhaps) to look more deeply into the study can tell us.

      • meiron: right on point. And besides, what in h#ell is a “Canadian Catholic”? Is that a separate and distinct Sacramental System?

  2. As a Canadian (practising Catholic), I question some of these comments.
    Quebec is a bit of an extreme. I think it is similar to traditionally Catholic countries in Europe (Belgian-born Canadian here), where the whole culture seems to go down en masse.
    Not to say that religious practice is healthy in the rest of Canada but we’re still here.

    • If you don’t mind, what was the opinion of conservative Canadians when they froze those trucker funds for those who were protesting the vaccines during covid?

  3. I too have to question this claim. Catholics — esp. Catholics in the Liberal Party, incl. prominent ones like Prime Ministers Trudeau pere et fils and Carney — laud the evisceration of Catholicism in the “Silent Revolution” of Quebec. Canada has abortion-on-demand through birth and no real political vehicle to challenge that regime. Canada is now in year 10 of creepingly expansive euthanasia. And pardon me, but while a few high-placed American hierarchs may wish the “culture warriors” in the U.S. Church disappeared, it’s them and not their Seamy Garment buddies that put an end to the reign of Roe. I don’t see the faintest echo of that north of the border, either politicallyv or within the Canadian Catholic Conference. So, how is it that Canadian Catholic identity is “more intact” than its American counterpart? Because it put on such a nice show for Pope Francis when he came on his indigenous apologies tour in 2022, whose “offenses” remain in large measure to be proven?

  4. We read: “These Catholics might go to church services on special occasions or holidays, like Christmas or Easter.”

    Which reminds of the joke about two pastors. Both had problems with rodent infestations in their aging church buildings. For one, nothing seemed to work in getting rid of the vermin. Every day they could be seen swarming across the floor.

    But the second priest soon had the rat and mouse problem licked. Asked his secret, he responded: “I baptized them and now they only show up twice a year.”

  5. I agree with DiogenesRedux that so-called “Catholic identity” of people who don’t even “bother” to give justice to God seems rather devoid of meaning.

    Surely Jesus understands just how much they appreciate him and all.

    • I expect He understands precisely how little they appreciate Him.

      That said, there are fallen-away Catholics who retain specifically Catholic practices, like Marian devotion. These people can retain a Catholic identity while failing to do justice to God.

      Skipping Mass is a mortal sin, but it is apostasy, heresy, and schism that make someone no longer Catholic – so a “Cafeteria Catholic” who is at Mass every Sunday is objectively in a worse state than a Catholic who believes Church teaching and considers themselves Catholic but doesn’t go to Mass. Of course, many non-practicing Catholics also reject Church teaching, so…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

All comments posted at Catholic World Report are moderated. While vigorous debate is welcome and encouraged, please note that in the interest of maintaining a civilized and helpful level of discussion, comments containing obscene language or personal attacks—or those that are deemed by the editors to be needlessly combative or inflammatory—will not be published. Thank you.


*