The Dispatch: More from CWR...

Carl Trueman chronicles the spiral from sexual revolution to desecration

The Desecration of Man is a thoughtful meditation on how secular society has negatively transformed attitudes towards the human person and proposes the only true solution to the problem.

"The Desecration of Man: How the Rejection of God Degrades Our Humanity" is the most recent book by Carl R. Trueman. (Images: Sentinel/Penguin)

Carl R. Trueman’s most recent book is a study of the profound problems caused by a loss of belief in the supernatural and how that loss affects humanity’s understanding of itself, especially in the areas of sex, reproduction, and death.

The Desecration of Man: How the Rejection of God Degrades Our Humanity poses fundamental questions about life and belief. Early in the book, Trueman poses these ultimate questions:

To ask, “What is moral?” is to ask, “How should man behave?” And to answer that question one needs to know what “man” is. Is human life to have a particular goal or goals? Are these shared by all human beings or are they created or chosen by communities or even individuals? Do we define ourselves, or is who and what we are to some extent determined by the fact that we all share something called “human nature” that involves a given set of expectations for our behavior that constitute what we call morality?

How we view man is intrinsically linked to how we view God and religion. What makes human beings unique is our ability to give personal meaning to acts such as eating, drinking, and sexual activity. Christians believe that human beings are created in God’s image and likeness. While we are free beings, we must operate within certain moral limits. But if we do not accept that man is made in God’s image, the picture changes. Trueman states:

If God does not exist…our idea of what it means to be human must change. We do not have the limits, the obligations and dependencies, nor the given ends that being made in his image connotes. We are born free, we are defined by our autonomy, and we are masters of our own destiny. We are to decide what limits and what ends we will respect. In sum, we create ourselves.

This Promethean spirit has led to what Trueman calls ‘expressive individualism’. This mentality, he argues, causes people to see all forms of external authority as oppressive and creates an iconoclastic spirit and a desire to desecrate all that was once considered holy.

The sexual revolution as desecration 

Trueman sees the most obvious area of desecration in the modern West as that relating to sex and sexuality. The sexual revolution, more than anything else, has served to undermine the Christian identity of the West. It has even been sacralized in the form of Pride parades. Yet it has essentially created a commodified humanity as Trueman summarizes very well:

…for all of the sexual revolution’s success, there is nowhere that the dehumanizing aspect of modernity’s desecration can be seen more dramatically. For at the heart of the sexual revolution lies a problem. It asserts that the destruction of old sexual codes—codes based on religious premises and a view of sex as sacred—is the path to liberation. But in practice it has turned us all into objects and things that exist merely for the benefit—for the sexual pleasure—of others. In the modern world, sex is endless, both in the sense that it is a ubiquitous obsession and in the sense that it really has no broader meaning or purpose beyond recreation.

The sexual revolution has meant more than just a change in attitude towards certain types of sexual lifestyles. A person’s sexuality has become a part of their identity as an individual, and to criticize it is to question that person’s very right to exist. Thus, we cannot simply tolerate unorthodox lifestyles—we must celebrate them:

It is not enough to tolerate sexual minorities. All differences in treatment on the basis of sexual identity must be removed. Hence, marriage must cease to be a monopoly of heterosexual relationships, employment hiring practices must be blind to sexual orientation or, in the interests of diversity, biased toward sexual minorities, and anything that hints that sexual minorities represent some kind of deviance has to be eliminated. This has implications for traditional religion: Christianity’s moral codes, for example, come to be seen as oppressive, and the God who imposes them as both offensive and implausible.

Trueman shows how the sexual revolution pursues its cause through acts of desecration, such as that seen at the opening of the 2024 Paris Olympics. Further, this revolution will continue pushing the envelope so that a practice such as abortion will move from being seen as a regrettable necessity, ‘safe, legal and rare’, to becoming a positive social good to be celebrated.

The commodification of reproduction

Another area highlighted by Trueman as causing a desecration of humanity is the rise of artificial reproduction. Foremost among these practices is that of commercial surrogacy, whereby a woman carries a child on behalf of another. Surrogacy has caused the mother to become ‘a service provider, her body the tool for the production of a commodity.’ Reproduction, one of the most intimate human experiences, has become a lucrative business:

As has been noted many times, this is the real Handmaid’s Tale—not a story of abusive religious fundamentalism treating women like nothing more than baby-making machines, but rather that of a society committed to technological innovation doing exactly the same thing. The woman is nothing more than a womb, and the womb nothing more than rental space.

As with surrogacy, so with IVF:

… just as surrogates function as containers for gestation, so sperm and egg donors are simply suppliers of raw materials…once children are the outcome of a technical medical procedure that manufactures life, the tendency to start seeing them as consumer products, as another form of commodity, is greater and greater…biological parenthood is downgraded or relativized.

Trivializing death

An excellent chapter in the book addresses the problem of death and how this, too, has been desacralized in modern society. In the affluent West, funerals have been turned into ‘celebrations of life’ aimed at distracting the bereaved from their loss rather than solemn reminders to the attendees about the reality of their own mortality.

Trueman argues that this trivializes the reality of death and is the result of a loss of belief in God. As with sex, modern society prefers to ignore the reality and consequences of death. Trueman writes:

Like the traditional sacredness of sex, death’s loss of this sense of the sacred is not a trivial cultural matter but something of great importance. Life lived without acknowledgment of the reality and power of death is life lived as a lie. It is the lie that sits at the heart of the desecration of man: the idea that we have neither given limits nor ends, that we are obliged to nobody and nothing, and that we can live this way with impunity. But death does have the last word. It is the limit that all of our technical brilliance cannot overcome. It is a sacred boundary that contradicts all our autonomous, disembodied posturing.

Be a real Christian, not a cultural Christian 

Trueman concludes that the solution to the problem of desecration, which he describes so well, is a return to traditional Christianity. He acknowledges that leading thinkers of our time, including even the atheist Richard Dawkins, have embraced ‘cultural Christianity’ or acknowledged Christianity’s contribution to the West.

But that, says Trueman, is not enough. Real Christianity consists of three things: cult (attendance at a serious and reverent Christian liturgy), code (adhering to Christian morality), and creed (actual belief in Christian dogmas such as those expressed in the Nicene Creed).

Trueman’s book is a thoughtful meditation on how secular society has negatively transformed attitudes towards the human person and proposes the only true solution to the problem: a return to sincere Christian belief and practice.

• Related at CWR: “Disenchantment or Desecration? An interview with Carl R. Trueman” (April 6, 2026) by Carl E. Olson

The Desecration of Man: How the Rejection of God Degrades Our Humanity
By Carl R. Trueman
Sentinel/Penguin, 2026
Hardcover, 256 pages


If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!

Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.


About Piers Shepherd 12 Articles
Piers Shepherd is a freelance writer currently based in Colombia. He has had articles published in the Catholic Herald, The Wanderer, Chronicles: A Magazine of American Culture, The Scottish Mail on Sunday, Crisis and The Conservative Woman among others.

10 Comments

  1. Death has been desacralized in modern society. In the affluent west, funerals have been turned into ‘celebrations of life’ (Piers Shepherd paraphrasing Carl Trueman).
    Perhaps the clearest bellwether of our desecration as I would describe as desecration of our creation in God’s image. My thoughts on our creation prior to noting Trueman referencing it thrice. We retain that dignity eternally, which is why in God’s justice Lucifer is recognized by God as ruler of his realm, permitted to tempt us.
    I’m OK You’re OK by psychiatrist Thomas A Harris [Harris was alleged to have committed suicide apparently a hoax by a detractor] best seller assured we’re all in good stead whether or not there’s a God. That indicates the desire for many now the majority who distance from God although they seek assurance by the celebration of life funeral Mass priest and deacon in white endless eulogies of the wonder that was the deceased [thankfully the Church now prohibits eulogies during Mass].
    Rude awakening in store? This trend well given account by Calvinist Trueman is why I hammered [gracefully perhaps not] on this modern heresy through the years of complacency and wind breaking sermons.

  2. Mr. Trueman’s (very apt name) reasoning is sound. The sexual revolution is not the cause of the desecration however but just another symptom. This desecration began much earlier than even that revolution with the acceptance of chattel slavery to build empires and nations. The temporal consequences of that sin infects and affects history of the Western nations to this day.

    • That same trade in human beings existed earlier in the East and lasted longer there. Right into the 20th century in places like Arabia and Ethiopia. And it still operates under the radar today.

    • Slavery had nothing to do with it. Progressive Boomers like yourself created the world we live in today – the sexual revolution, drug culture, abortion on demand, no fault divorce, feminism, LGBT agendas, the welfare state – thanks for that.

      • Slavery has everything to do with viewing some humans as less than human. I am not a boomer but neither is that an issue. The sin of dehumanization existed longer than one generation.

  3. The Anglican LAMBETH Conference of 1930:
    …where the vote was 193 for contraception and 67 against. Very synodal, that! Of which, later in 1948, the defeated minority still TOLD IT LIKE IT IS:

    “It is, to say the least, suspicious that the age in which contraception has won its way is not one which has been conspicuously successful in managing its sexual life. Is it possible that, by claiming the right to manipulate his physical processes in this manner, man may, without knowing it, be stepping over the boundary between the world of Christian marriage and what one might call the world of Aphrodite[!], the world of sterile eroticism?” (Cited in Wright, “Reflections on the Third Anniversary of a Controverted Encyclical,” St. Louis: Central Bureau Press, 1971).

    Then GEORGES BERNANOS:

    “Purity is not imposed upon us as though it were a kind of punishment, it is one of those mysterious but obvious conditions of that supernatural knowledge of ourselves in the Divine, which we speak of as faith. Impurity does not destroy this knowledge, it slays our need for it. I no longer believe, because I have not wished to believe. You no longer wish to know yourself” (“The Diary of a Country Priest,” 1937).

    “The modern world will shortly no longer possess sufficient spiritual reserves to commit genuine evil. Already . . . we can witness a lethal slackening of men’s conscience that is attacking not only their moral life, but also their very heart and mind, altering and decomposing even their imagination . . . The menacing crisis is one of INFANTILISM.” (Interview with Samedi-Soir, Nov. 8, 1947, cited in Hans Urs von Balthasar, “Bernanos: An Ecclesial Existence” [San Francisco: Ignatius, 1996], 457, caps added).

    CONNECT THE DOTS: contraceptive culture, cohabitation, the abortion backstop, IVF Petrie dish roulette, the “sterile eroticism” of gay marriage and LGBTQ tribal religion, transgender/gender theory with 57 variants (like Heinze steak sauce and not unlike COVID “variants”!), human composting—and even a U.S. Supreme Court Justice who with a “straight” (!) face can no longer tell us what a “woman” is.

  4. Many of us moderns have made a Faustian pact for autonomy and it is harming us in demographic self destruction.

    Lewis examines it in terms of rejection of the Natural Law (Tao) in ‘the Abolition of Man’ and Trueman reminds us yet again in ‘the Desecration of Man’.
    The conditioners are closing in.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

All comments posted at Catholic World Report are moderated. While vigorous debate is welcome and encouraged, please note that in the interest of maintaining a civilized and helpful level of discussion, comments containing obscene language or personal attacks—or those that are deemed by the editors to be needlessly combative or inflammatory—will not be published. Thank you.


*