The Dispatch: More from CWR...

The new legal landscape after the abortion ballot initiatives

While efforts to secure legal protections for unborn babies should never cease, increased focus should be directed toward building a culture that values life.

(Image: kishivan | us.fotolia.com)

Election post-mortems are in full swing, with finger-pointing, recriminations, and Monday-morning quarterbacking for some, vindication or validation for others.

As the dust settles, those who lost need to regroup, including pro-life advocates in three states. In Nevada and Virginia, where voters added abortion to their state constitutions, and in Missouri, where they declined to repeal a 2024 abortion amendment, efforts to protect unborn babies will require perseverance.

But first, the good news.

Idahoans resoundingly defeated a ballot initiative that would have bypassed the state legislature and the governor to establish a statutory “right to abortion.” If approved, Proposition 1 would have been “liberally construed in favor of” abortion and would have overruled Idaho’s abortion limits and other laws protecting unborn babies and their mothers. Instead, this pro-life state can continue to enforce its abortion laws.

That is not the case in Nevada or Virginia, where new constitutional amendments will eviscerate current protections and handicap future pro-life efforts. Granted, neither state’s laws were particularly pro-life before the election. Nevada has long been an abortion-friendly state, permitting abortion for any reason through 24 weeks of pregnancy and throughout pregnancy if necessary to preserve a woman’s life or “health.” Health is undefined, leaving that evaluation to abortionists. However, before Tuesday, the state constitution did not prevent lawmakers from enacting pro-life laws. Rather, it was silent on abortion, and the Supreme Court of Nevada has not misinterpreted its provisions to protect abortion.

Virginia’s protections for unborn babies and their mothers were significantly reduced in 2020 when the legislature repealed several laws. Abortion is currently legal in the state in the first and second trimesters for any reason and in the third trimester if the pregnancy is likely to result in death or “substantially and irremediably impair the mental or physical health of the woman.” As in Nevada, Virginia’s constitution was silent on abortion until Tuesday, and its Supreme Court has not misinterpreted it to protect abortion.

Nevada’s and Virginia’s amendments are so broad that the states must show a “compelling state interest” achieved “by the least restrictive means” to enact any law that restricts abortion. A “compelling state interest” is defined as “limited” to those that maintain or improve the health of pregnant women, thereby excluding any specific interest in the lives of unborn children. Nevada may regulate abortion at viability, and Virginia may regulate it in the third trimester; however, abortions must be permitted to protect pregnant women’s lives or “health,” a determination left to the abortionist. Virginia explicitly includes mental health in this exception.

Very few existing pro-life laws will remain in force under these amendments. A court may even strike down Virginia’s parental consent requirement for a minor’s abortion because the amendment does not permit laws that “infringe on [an] individual’s autonomous decision making.” Virginia’s amendment also provides that the state “shall not penalize, prosecute, or otherwise take adverse action against an individual based on such individual’s…own actual, potential, perceived, or alleged pregnancy outcomes, including miscarriage, stillbirth, or abortion.” If a law enforcement investigation is classified as an “adverse action” regarding an “alleged pregnancy outcome,” the amendment could prevent the discovery of infanticides disguised as “stillbirths.”

Voters in Missouri, in contrast, declined to repeal a draconian pro-abortion amendment they narrowly approved in 2024. Over the past two years, abortion advocates have predictably filed successful legal challenges to the state’s abortion limits and other pro-life laws under the amendment.

The vote in Missouri, however, should not be viewed as a moratorium on abortion policy, given that the lengthy amendment was not simply a repeal of the 2024 pro-abortion amendment. Its abortion provisions were multifaceted, permitting abortions in some cases while limiting or allowing limits in others, adding pro-life measures such as parental notification to the state constitution, and permitting additional abortion regulations. It also stated what should be obvious: that the state may not infringe on access to care in cases of miscarriage, ectopic pregnancy, and other medical emergencies.

While abortion advocates had no trouble voting against this amendment, the amendment’s length and scope may have deterred some middle-ground voters from supporting it. Given that Missouri has historically been a pro-life state, it is unlikely to sit well with many Missourians if the state becomes the abortion capital of the Midwest.

Pro-life work will continue in these three states—as it must. While efforts to secure legal protections for unborn babies should never cease, increased focus should be directed toward building a culture that values life. We must continue growing and supporting networks for women with unexpected pregnancies and educating the public about the indisputable humanity of the unborn.

The goal is for women to choose life, and we must pursue that goal even in states with pro-abortion amendments. Progress may feel slow, but we must never stop working to protect innocent human lives.


If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!

Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.


About Mary E. Harned, J.D. 1 Article
Mary E. Harned, J.D. is an associate scholar at Charlotte Lozier Institute.

19 Comments

  1. “The goal is for women to choose life…”
    Very true, but another way to put it is to have the goal for women not to murder their unborn children. There is a very good article on CRISIS today on “One abortion – Two victims” regarding the lack of responsibility we apply to women who have abortions.
    The abortion industry says that 40% of those getting an abortion are repeat customers – 2nd, 3rd, 4th abortions. Hardly victims.
    Within the Church there should be some emphasis on the immorality of abortion and the possible eternal consequences.

      • Cosmopolitan magazine had an article on what the best abortion procedures are. They may still have guides available.

        The media codify this sick stuff as acceptable societal practice.

      • I believe Mrscracker that your response illustrates the truthfulness of the CRISIS article. Certainly there are exceptions. I have seen cars pull into the local abortion facility with an apparently 40ish woman driving and with a teenager in the passenger seat crying. It is not hard to figure out who is responsible there. But those are a small minority of cases.
        I believe that indicating that typically the women who obtain abortions are victims is not complementary to women. It says they are not responsible for their actions. Canon Law says at least officially) that women are responsible for obtaining an abortion since there is an automatic excommunication associated with it.

    • The goal for women really ought to be abstaining from sex when a baby isn’t desired. Same for men. Don’t want to go to Pittsburg? Why get on the bus to Pittsburg?
      .
      Obviously if someone is being trafficked, that’s a different matter, but I’m guessing a lot of abortions have nothing to do with being trafficked.

      • Better yet, the principle I advise young persons every chance I get is this: “Don’t have sex with anyone you’re not married to.”

    • The goal is for everyone to choose and support life. Every abortion is a failure. A failure of medicine, money, or social support.

      • We’re going to have to pluck these children from the near grasp of the mighty forceps on a one-by one basis, as our legal oversight efforts have largely failed. MI had prop 3 under Whitmer and recently has been named the worst state in the union for religious freedom.

        Perhaps CWR can start a separate site to facilitate setting up local pregnancy support through the parishes? This would be up to and including adoption expense assistance. Those of you with extra time could work with Mr.Olson on this. This could be coordinated with local pregnancy centers as well.

        The idea would be no questions asked we will help you with your child within you, irregardless of whether the male is participating or not. You have to have a come hither system where we’d 1)be known as an organization that makes the baby the priority, while assessing/considering the mother’s life situation and 2)one they’re not afraid to approach.

        As a parent, I would certainly pluck one of my kids that I could reach, out of the floodwaters and certain death.

  2. The consequences of abortion are profound – and not just for the aborted. Consider the world population drop it portends. In 1955 the average surviving births/woman was 3. Today it is 1 (i.e. ONE !) I wonder how may people will be around in 150 years.

  3. “If a law enforcement investigation is classified as an ‘adverse action’ regarding an ‘alleged pregnancy outcome,’ the amendment could prevent the discovery of infanticides disguised as ‘stillbirths’” (Mary E. Harned, J.D.).
    Mary Harned’s knowledge of the ethical repercussions of Virginia’s constitutional amendment seems to say her J.D. stands for Doctor of Jurisprudence.
    Unfortunately with the present virtual single party domination we’re likely to have much more of the same proliferation of abortion rights and absence of full disclosure.

    • The western countries keep the older people alive as long as possible, at tremendous expense to their Treasuries, and younger people through their payroll tax deductions and deficit spending, which appears to be out of control. Why are we not planning for the future with more children, instead of just one side of the human ledger records?

  4. The impact of the electoral situation in Miss and other states: Please see just a few of many examples of how the two parties differ when it comes to defending the life of the unborn. Please notice the links I provide so you can check the origin of the news and their veracity or falsehood:

    –The Republican Administration Department of Health and Human Services has rescinded previous Democrat Administration departmental guidance that could force pharmacists to stock and dispense abortion pills in violation of pharmacists’ religious beliefs.

    –The Democrat Administration had collaborated with pro-abortion groups to target pro-lifers and weaponize the FACE Act against pro-life defendants.
    UNDER THE REPUBLICAN ADMINISTRATION THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE HAS SUBSEQUENTLY RESTRICTED “THE MISUSE OF THE FACE ACT AGAINST PRO-LIFE ADVOCATES, DISMISSING SEVERAL CASES AIMED AT PERSECUTING PRO-LIFE AMERICANS.”

    –DEMOCRAT ADMINISTRATION ANTI-CATHOLIC MEMO: FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION HAS CONDUCTED TERMINATIONS AND OVERSEEN RESIGNATIONS FOLLOWING AN ANTI-CATHOLIC MEMO AUTHORED BY THE FBI DURING THE DEMOCRAT ADMINISTRATION.

    –The Democrat Administration had collaborated with pro-abortion groups to target pro-lifers and weaponize the FACE Act against pro-life defendants.
    THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE HAS SUBSEQUENTLY RESTRICTED “THE MISUSE OF THE FACE ACT AGAINST PRO-LIFE ADVOCATES, DISMISSING SEVERAL CASES AIMED AT PERSECUTING PRO-LIFE AMERICANS.”

    –Defending Life: actions that include restrictions on abortion-related funding and conscience protections.
    “Food and Drug Administration is conducting a review of the abortion drug mifepristone.”
    https://www.catholicworldreport.com/2026/09/18/white-house-touts-list-of-victories-for-people-of-faith/

    The DEMOCRAT-DOMINATED MASSACHUSETTS STATE SENATE PASSED A LATE-TERM ABORTION BILL on Friday and sent it to Gov. Maura Healey’s (D) desk for approval.
    The bill, called “An Act Prioritizing Patient Access to Care” or H.5595, would ultimately allow unborn babies to be aborted throughout pregnancy in the state and would strike down the state’s current 24-week limit, which has exceptions for the life of the mother and a deadly fetal diagnosis. Under the bill, doctors would have the discretion to decide whether or not to perform a late-term abortion, the Washington Post reported.
    https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2026/07/31/massachusetts-senate-passes-bill-to-allow-late-term-abortions-sends-to-governors-desk/

    Democrat Governor Maura Healey signs late-term abortion bill into law
    https://thehill.com/homenews/state-watch/6025901-maura-healey-signs-late-abortion-bill/

    Undercover Video Shows Democrat Talarico’s Pastor Declaring Support for Atheists, Abortion, LGBTQ
    https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2026/09/17/exclusive-undercover-video-shows-democrat-james-talaricos-pastor-supporting-atheists-lets-them-join-his-church/

  5. Mrs. Hess above (5:40 a.m.) –
    I hear you.
    I think pro-lifers, including Catholics, have bought into the belief that contraception is the antidote to abortion.
    That belief needs to be challenged.

    • Cleo:
      .
      I’ve always thought it was because they themselves did not want to give up contraception. It makes the marital debt (without the “risk” of children) easier to manage.

1 Trackback / Pingback

  1. The new legal landscape after the abortion ballot initiatives - Lozier Institute

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

All comments posted at Catholic World Report are moderated. While vigorous debate is welcome and encouraged, please note that in the interest of maintaining a civilized and helpful level of discussion, comments containing obscene language or personal attacks—or those that are deemed by the editors to be needlessly combative or inflammatory—will not be published. Thank you.


*