Cardinal Arinze cautions priests against lengthy homilies

 

Cardinal Francis Arinze during the centenary celebrations of Bigard Memorial Major Seminary in Rome in November 2024. / Credit: Bigard Memorial Major Seminary

Enugu, Nigeria, Nov 17, 2024 / 07:00 am (CNA).

Vatican-based Nigerian Church leader Cardinal Francis Arinze has urged priests to avoid lengthy homilies, saying a homily should not be an exhibition of “theological acrobatics” but rather a reflection of the priest’s prayer life and a clear, concise proclamation of the Gospel.

In his keynote address during the 12-day centenary celebrations of Nigeria’s Bigard Memorial Major Seminary, Arinze emphasized the importance of priests delivering homilies that are deeply rooted in Scripture, liturgical texts, and sound theology.

“A homily well prepared should last around 10 minutes. A university lecture of 45 minutes is for a different setting. A homily is not a display of theological acrobatics nor a harangue about money,” the cardinal said during a Nov. 13 event.

A homily, Arinze added, “is not an exposition of the local political climate nor a social disquisition on the economic hardships of the people. It should be the sharing of the prayer life of the priest for the past week in the presence of the Lord Jesus in the holy Eucharist.”

He explained that the major points of the homily are best put in writing and that the language of a homily should be clear — “not an admixture of English and the local language, nor an exhibition of the preacher’s ability to navigate in idioms.”

“A poor homily is an offense against the Word of God and against God’s people gathered to hear his word,” the cardinal said.

In his address titled “The Impact of Formations House on Education in Nigeria,” Arinze reflected on the priestly vocation and the role of seminaries in preparing future priests.

“It is expected that the seminary will train the future priest to be a good pastor of God’s people. He is the spiritual director of individual Catholics and of their associations … [h]is patient attendance at their meetings, where he delivers well-prepared addresses, is one of the ways in which he serves them,” the cardinal continued. “Lay leaders remain necessary according to the nature of each association. But the priest is their irreplaceable shepherd. As a good shepherd, he is neither in front nor behind his people; he is in their midst. As the pope would put it, he has the smell of the sheep.”

Arinze noted the alarming trend of young people drifting from the Catholic faith, turning instead to African traditional religions and other superstitions.

“In many parts of our country, Nigeria, there is a lamentation that many young people today are rather poor in their knowledge of the Catholic faith. Many of them relapse into practices of the African traditional religion,” he said.

“They may engage in real idol worship; they believe in charms; they consult fortune tellers and some go so far as to kill even a relative in the hope that that will attract big money. It is not a surprise if such young people keep away from the sacraments.”

Arinze continued: “The problem is not solved by blaming the catechists for a job not well done. Some Nigerian dioceses have a remarkable increase in the number of their priests … Suppose such a diocese adopts the policy that a priest is to be the teacher of religion in every class in schools primary or secondary. It is not below the dignity of the priest to teach the young about God and religion. Moreover, the teenagers need answers to life’s challenges.”

“The seminary also has the role of preparing its [students] to be good preachers. A priest should be a convinced announcer of the good news of salvation in Jesus Christ.”

In his keynote address at the beginning of the 12-day centenary celebrations, Arinze reflected on the challenge of inculturation in the Catholic Church in Nigeria.

The cardinal pointed to ongoing efforts in the Church to respect local cultures, including the adoption of local names in baptism and hymns in Indigenous languages.

However, he underscored the need for a more thorough and careful process of inculturation, involving bishops, theologians, and cultural experts.

“For an element of culture to be inculturated, the bishops’ conference of the area or country in question has first to set up a multidisciplinary study commission of experts in theology, liturgy, scriptural studies, ethnology, psychology, and music. Such a high-powered commission will have to sift the many sides of an indicated custom or tradition and, if it considers it ripe, make recommendations to the bishops’ conference,” he said.

“Inculturation is very demanding on a local Church,” Arinze pointed out. “It is not a one-man affair. It is not the fruit of someone’s over-fertile imagination, which concocts an idea on Saturday evening and forces it down the throat of the innocent and unsuspecting Sunday Mass congregation the following morning.”

As Bigard Memorial Seminary enters its second century of formation, Arinze expressed gratitude for its successes, calling on future generations of seminarians and priests to continue the work of evangelization and faith integration.

“Bigard Memorial Seminary has come a long way in 100 years in preparing clergy for evangelization. It has done a good job!” the cardinal said. “May the Lord of the harvest continue to bless and guide this respected alma mater of ours as it walks into its second century. May the Most Blessed Virgin Mary, Queen of Apostles, intercede for Bigard.”

Bigard Memorial Major Seminary in Enugu was founded in Onitsha in 1922 and officially opened in 1924. It was moved to its current location in 1951. It was named after benefactors Stephanie and Jeanne Bigard, a French mother and daughter who were foundresses of the Pontifical Society of St. Peter the Apostle, who donated the funds for the main building.

In 1982, Pope John Paul II visited Bigard Memorial Major Seminary, the first Nigerian seminary to receive such a guest.

This story was first published by ACI Africa, CNA’s news partner in Africa, and has been adapted by CNA.


If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!

Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.


About Catholic News Agency 12520 Articles
Catholic News Agency (www.catholicnewsagency.com)

7 Comments

  1. (HIGHLY) RECOMMENDED READING – ‘The Great Sermon Handicap’ by P.G. Wodehouse. I never thought I would get the opportunity to say something about him at this site – thanks for proving me wrong.

    My day is now made.

  2. Whenever I hear a bishop or cardinal on lengthy sermons I’m reminded of the Apostle in Acts 20:7-12. Paul was speaking in an upper room when Eutychus fell asleep while sitting in a window. Paul went on and on, and Eutychus eventually fell three stories to his death. Paul went down to Eutychus, embraced him, and said, ‘Don’t worry, he’s alive!’. Eutychus was carried back upstairs and Paul talked until dawn.
    Unfortunately, few priests are able to raise the dead to life. Fortunately, we rarely preach in places where parishioners can sit on high window ledges [although the choir loft poses a danger]. A main complaint I hear from Catholics who no longer go to Mass is the length of sermons.
    Cardinal Arinze notwithstanding theological acrobatics is required in our day because we’re fed doctrinal double entendre. It’s always the content and the manner of delivery. Some of the best ‘sermons’ I’ve read were excerpts from Augustine, John Chrysostom, Aquinas in the breviary Office of Readings that read at leisure would take 5 minutes or so, and to, and to deliver.

  3. Most speakers can only hold an audience for five to ten minutes. Beyond that, their attention is lost. There are exceptions,such as the late Fr John Delclos of Baltimore, who could hold the congregation in rapt attention, but they are the exception.

  4. Thank you, Cardinal Arinze! But, the mind of this distracted reader still wandereth….

    The word count for the Instrumentum Laboris for Synod 2024 was 20,428, including the term “synod” a full 228 times –more than one percent. And, from this and the other ninety-nine percent, the Synod hath spun-off the now enthusiastically-awaited verbosity of ten new “study groups,” each hammering relentlessly on its very own word processor until June 2025. The gift that keeps on giving!

    Save a tree; save a chandelier; save a neuron; save an electron!

  5. Part of it also depends upon the content and delivery; ten minutes, while an excellent guideline, need not be a hard and fast rule. Some priests can preach at length and it seems as if it’s going rather quickly, while others could speak for only ten minutes and make it feel like twenty-five. The other point for priests to remember is that Jesus in the Sacrament of Holy Communion, is the focal point– the source and summit– of the Mass, not the homily. Too many people both clerics and laity, tend to forget that. Putting too much focus on a homily is like treating a salad as if it were more important than the main course in a Thanksgiving dinner– yet we also need to consider that the homily is the priest’s one chance each week to reach people who are being brainwashed by secular media and culture the rest of the week. Of course, as the saying goes, Rome wasn’t built in a day, so a priest can’t expect to say everything in one homily.

  6. Although I agree that the Mass is not the appropriate occasion for a lengthy homily/sermon, as a convert from Evangelical Protestantism, I was used to sermons (or “messages” as they were often called) that lasted at least 30 minutes, and in some churches, 45-60 minutes. Even as a young teen, I had no trouble staying awake if the long sermon/message was interesting and well-spoken, and often, I took notes. I think that it would be well to make available to non-Catholics (and lapsed Catholics who are visiting!), perhaps in the pew rack that holds the missalettes, a brief explanation of the Catholic Mass, with a description of the purpose of the homily and a message that the homily is not meant to be a lengthy lecture. This would possibly stop Protestants from criticizing (in their minds and perhaps out loud) what they think is a “sermon that’s too short and simple.” And of course, there should be information available to visitors about ministries in the parish, e.g., a Bible study or a special group like That Man Is You! or an apologetics class in which the speaker gives a more detailed (and longer!) talk. With the increased interest in Catholicism from Evangelical and Mainline Protestants, I think this would be a hospitable action for our parishes.

  7. A Venerable Cardinal Francis wrote about his favorite prayers, them also short and also proclaiming the Gospel.

    “If you ask what are your favorite prayers, in all sincerity, I would say I love best the short and simple prayers of the Gospel:

    ‘They have no more wine . . .’ (Jn 2:3).
    ‘Magnificat . . .’ (Lk 1:46-55).
    ‘Father, forgive them . . .’ (Lk 23:34).
    ‘Into your hands . . .’ (Lk 23:46).
    ‘That they may be one . . .’ (Jn 17-21).
    ‘Be merciful to me a sinner . . .’ (Lk 18:13).
    ‘Remember me when you come into your kingdom’ (Lk 23:42).

    “I also love to pray with the whole of God’s word, with the liturgical prayers, the psalms, the canticles. I greatly love Gregorian chant, which in large part I recall from memory. Thanks to my seminary formation, these liturgical songs entered deep into my heart! Then there are the prayers of my native language, so moving, that my whole family prayed together every evening in our chapel, which reminds me of my childhood. Above all, there are the three Hail Marys and the Memorare that my mother taught me to recite morning and evening.”

    Five Loaves and Two Fish, Francis Xavier Nguyen Van Thuan, Pauline Books & Media, Boston 2002, p. 28

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

All comments posted at Catholic World Report are moderated. While vigorous debate is welcome and encouraged, please note that in the interest of maintaining a civilized and helpful level of discussion, comments containing obscene language or personal attacks—or those that are deemed by the editors to be needlessly combative or inflammatory—will not be published. Thank you.


*