The Dispatch: More from CWR...

Wanted: A Catholic Chaim Potok

The fictional battles in The Chosen and The Promise mirror some of the modern-day challenges in the U.S. Church.

Jewish novelist and historian Chaim Potok (1929-2002) in 1986 (Image: Deborah Thomas/Wikipedia)

In the three decades since the Revolution of 1989, Poland’s many cultural achievements include mastering the craft of creating the 21st-century historical museum.

Examples include the Warsaw Uprising Museum in the national capital; Kraków Under Nazi Occupation 1939-1945, built on the site of Oskar Schindler’s factory; and The Family Home of John Paul II — Papal Museum, in the late pope’s hometown, Wadowice. Each of these exemplary museums combines a traditional, linear approach to telling a historical story, using the artifacts often found in such exhibitions, with brilliantly executed interactive displays that lead the visitor “into” the history being explored. I know of nothing so well done in the United States; the Polish museums put the Smithsonian’s Museum of American History to shame.

The greatest of these contemporary Polish efforts is Polin: The Museum of the History of Polish Jews, which is built on the site of the wartime Warsaw Ghetto and opened in 2013. I spent many hours there in October 2016 and left with the thought that this just might be the greatest historical museum in the world. Using the contemporary Polish method of combining traditional ways of historical storytelling with digital and interactive displays, Polin (which in Hebrew can mean either “Poland” on “Here you shall rest”) unveils a complex, too-often tragic, and unfailingly interesting story of overlapping cultures with rigorous honesty and palpable compassion. Religious and cultural artifacts, paintings and photographs, and those interactive displays combine to immerse the visitor in a millennium of human experiences and encounters, all of which teach important truths. Polin’s 430-page catalogue has an honored place in my home, and I never cease to be amazed by its riches.

During my visit to Polin in 2016, I was struck by how much of the history of Hasidic Judaism in Poland and Lithuania was somehow familiar. And then I figured out why: it was thanks to two wonderful novels by the late Chaim Potok: The Chosen, published in 1967, and its sequel, The Promise, published in 1969. I recently re-read both books and was struck again by how much of an education in central and eastern European Jewish history Potok offers his readers through the character of David Malter, an expatriate Russian Talmudic scholar living in Brooklyn. Hasidic Jews who have somehow escaped Hitler’s murder machine are resettling in Professor Malter’s neighborhood in the immediate post-World War II years, and Malter’s explanations to his son, Reuven (the novels’ narrator), of how the Hasidim came to be and what they believe are fascinating. They’re also accurately crafted nuggets of the turbulent religious and cultural history that’s explicated in depth at Polin.

I’ve probably read The Chosen and The Promise a half-dozen times, and on each reading I find that, in David Malter, Chaim Potok drew a portrait of the perfect father: a man of firm conviction, but also of infinite patience with the struggles of youth and the eternal foibles of humanity; a deeply pious and traditional man who is not afraid of modernity; a profound teacher whose reverence for revealed truth does not lock him into an intellectual bunker; a parent with whom an emerging adult can talk freely, knowing that the older person respects the intelligence and freedom of the younger.

Potok’s novels are intensely Jewish and deeply American in a way that hasn’t really been replicated by U.S. Catholic authors. American Catholicism could use a Chaim Potok today. For the fictional battles in The Chosen and The Promise between David Malter and his reform-minded colleagues in a modern Orthodox yeshiva, and the scholars at the venerable Hirsch Talmudic academy who refuse to concede an inch to modern methods of studying ancient texts, mirror some of the modern-day challenges in the U.S. Church. How can we learn from what modern archaeology, linguistic studies, and historical research teach us about the Bible without treating the Scriptural text as a literary corpse to be dissected? How do we gratefully receive and honor ancient rituals and forms of worship while avoiding their fossilization and allowing for their development? How do religious authorities and religious scholars interact for their mutual benefit, and for the good of the community they share?

Reading The Chosen and The Promise is an uplifting experience. And, in the ways of Providence, it happened that I finished the latter on the day the Divine Office included this great text from St. Paul’s Letter to the Romans: “To the Israelites belong the adoption, the glory, the covenants, the law-giving, the worship, and the promises; theirs were the patriarchs, and from them came the Messiah….”

If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!

Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.

About George Weigel 419 Articles
George Weigel is Distinguished Senior Fellow of Washington's Ethics and Public Policy Center, where he holds the William E. Simon Chair in Catholic Studies. He is the author of over twenty books, including Witness to Hope: The Biography of Pope John Paul II (1999), The End and the Beginning: Pope John Paul II—The Victory of Freedom, the Last Years, the Legacy (2010), and The Irony of Modern Catholic History: How the Church Rediscovered Itself and Challenged the Modern World to Reform. His most recent books are The Next Pope: The Office of Peter and a Church in Mission (2020), and Not Forgotten: Elegies for, and Reminiscences of, a Diverse Cast of Characters, Most of Them Admirable (Ignatius, 2021).


  1. A Jewish author can write an “intensely Jewish” book and gain a large audience. Can a Catholic author write an intensely Catholic book and make in a best-seller? Has that ever happened?

    • Were it not for well-placed amnesiacs in our culture and even in our Church, a best-read, if not a “best-seller” would be Pope St. John Paul II’s “Memory and Identity” (Rizolli, 2005).

      And then there’s the earlier “Crossing the Threshold of Hope: by His Holiness John Paul II,” Knopf, 1994). Yes, this is a best-seller: “By 1998, the book had sold several million copies and was published in forty languages. Over one million copies were sold in Italy alone” (Wikipedia).

      Gotta be careful, though, about JP II’s books…the interested reader might then discover his entire output of 25 years and more, including his less-read encyclicals such as “Veritatis Splendor” (1993) dealing coherently with such “rigidities” as, you know, moral absolutes–reflecting the transcendent dignity of the human person.

      • Weigel questions whether an American author has ever written about Catholicism in America. Neither JPII nor Tolkien was American, and JPII didn’t write novels, although I believe he did write one play.

        Americans may be proud of Flannery O’Connor. Although her novels do not portray conflicts between Catholicism and secularism per se, they nevertheless convey a cosmological Catholic vision. That vision breaks through the ‘everyday,’ with startling and unsettling power. For that we owe her thanks and commendation.

  2. George asks: “How do we gratefully receive and honor ancient rituals and forms of worship while avoiding their fossilization…?”

    No form of worship becomes a fossil when life forms within said Church rock remain alive. Until and unless all worshippers and until and unless Christ Our Lord and Savior, God Himself, die, there can essentially be no such thing as a fossilized form of worship.

    Next question?

  3. Mr. Weigel, previous novels I’ve read based on your recommendations were “A Gentleman in Moscow” and “A Distant Trumpet” and both were wonderful, edifying experiences. So these two books are now on my reading list. Thank you.

  4. the ceremony of beatification of Cardinal Stefan Wyszyński and Sister Maria Czacka will take place on September 12, 2021 in Warsaw, at 12.00.

  5. Thank you for introducing these beautiful and powerful books to a potentially new audience. I can’t read The Chosen without thinking, “I want to be more like David Malter.” I would only add that My Name is Asher Lev and, even more, The Gift of Asher Lev are just as beautiful and just as powerful. And then there’s I am the Clay, with its moving meditation on a hymn from my youth. Once you get started on Chaim Potok you won’t want to stop.

  6. “How do we gratefully receive and honor ancient rituals and forms of worship while avoiding their fossilization and allowing for their development?”

    A good and difficult question, but one thing is absolutely certain: we don’t do it by putting everything on the work table, and cutting and pasting a new liturgy into being. That’s not development but manufacturing, as Ratzinger so poignantly said. Besides, nothing that lives in the devout hearts of the faithful can ever be called “fossilized” without insult.

1 Trackback / Pingback

  1. Wanted: A Catholic Chaim Potok - JP2 Catholic Radio

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

All comments posted at Catholic World Report are moderated. While vigorous debate is welcome and encouraged, please note that in the interest of maintaining a civilized and helpful level of discussion, comments containing obscene language or personal attacks—or those that are deemed by the editors to be needlessly combative or inflammatory—will not be published. Thank you.