The Dispatch: More from CWR...

Can we love the Church?

So long as human beings run the marathon to heaven, there will be failures, sins, and scandals.


Love is an act of the will, a decision that we make to give our best to another. Love is often associated with romance and sweeping emotions, but it need not be. When we take care of a sick family member, lend an ear to a needy friend, or carry out a physically demanding task as a favor, we are performing acts of love that are born not of romantic feelings, but of self-sacrifice.

Love towards our mothers is of this kind. The exuberant love of young children for their mothers eventually ebbs as they reach adolescence; as children begin to assert their independence, they often run into conflict with their mothers’ will for them. Occasionally, these conflicts harden and strain the mother-child relationship for years to come. But, more often than not, as children enter adulthood and become parents themselves, their relationships with their mothers become affective again, as they realize that, through all the quarreling, their mothers only wanted what was best for them.

Now, as adults, though conscious of their mothers’ shortcomings, they are grateful for the love and the countless acts of self-sacrifice that they received from their mothers over so many years. This gratitude then propels them to take care of their aging mothers as they decline in health. Feelings of affection may again wane in the rigors of life’s final moments, yet the acts of love, the decisions to sacrifice for their mothers in return for all they have received from them, triumphs.

Our relationship with our holy mother the Church is similar. The excitement we might have experienced as young children when we entered a church building, received our first holy communion, or celebrated Christmas fades over time. As we age, we become aware of sins committed by our fellow Catholics and by the Church’s leaders, actions directly contrary to what they profess. We can be dragged down by this reality and overwhelmed by sin’s horrific effects. We can also come into conflict with the Church’s teachings as we assert our independence. Our conflicts can harden and prompt us to withdraw from the Church for a time.

As with our natural mothers, we can again have a strong relationship with our spiritual mother. That is, we can love the Church. This love is an act of the will, and it begins when we recall the incredible gift that the Church has given each of us: communion with Jesus Christ, our savior.

The incarnation of the Son of God was the definitive event of human history. So definitive that it had to be perpetuated through all subsequent time. The Church is Christ’s chosen instrument for keeping Him present to all people until He comes again. In the words of the third-century bishop St. Cyprian of Carthage, “No one can have God as his Father who does not have the Church as his mother.”

As our spiritual mother, the Church gives us the inestimable gift of divine life. As such, she is worthy of our love, our support, and our continued patronage. Through all life’s travails, including those we experience within her bosom, the Church remains a gift and a blessing.

Loving the Church does not mean that we ignore or discount the sins of Church members, bishops, and priests. Rather, we must work to heal the sin present within her, just as we work to take care of our natural mothers when they become ill. We achieve this, in the first place, through cultivating holiness within ourselves through prayer, frequent reception of the sacraments, acts of sacrifice, and acts of charity. Only then are we prepared to help our fellow members of the body of Christ, including our priests and bishops.

We first have to pray; only then are we spiritually prepared to call out sins, to help our fellow members acknowledge and confess them, and then to establish a firm purpose of amendment never to sin again. These are the four steps that are needed—and have always been needed—to reform the Church. Structures are important, but they are only as effective as the people who live by them. The only sure way to combat sin is with God’s grace.

This returns us to the paradoxical state of the Church that is simultaneously divine and human, the storehouse of grace and the refuge of sinners. So long as human beings run the marathon to heaven, there will be failures, sins, and scandals. Just as our natural mothers need us to remain steadfast in our commitment to them when they are ill, so must we remain for our holy mother, the Catholic Church. Though her members may fail, she herself will never fail, for Christ remains at her head, guaranteeing her as His means of salvation, even at the darkest moments of our journeys.

(Note: This essay is adapted from Staying with the Catholic Church: Trusting God’s Plan of Salvation, released in March from Scepter Publishers.)

If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!

Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.

About David G. Bonagura, Jr. 40 Articles
David G. Bonagura, Jr. is an adjunct professor at St. Joseph’s Seminary and Catholic Distance University. He is the 2023-2024 Cardinal Newman Society Fellow for Eucharistic Education. He is the author of Steadfast in Faith: Catholicism and the Challenges of Secularism. and Staying with the Catholic Church: Trusting God's Plan of Salvation, and the translator of Jerome’s Tears: Letters to Friends in Mourning.


  1. What a great reminder that the Church we expect to lead us has sinners leading Her, because we are all sinners. We can expect better from the leaders, but we must realize that the hierarchy is not less sinful than the lowerarchy. We all sin, and we all need God’s grace to admit that we sin and seek reconciliation and forgiveness to then draw strength from the reception of Jesus in the Eucharist. We will sin again, but this cyclical process should lead us to a life that seeks to be perfect in heaven, just not here. Thanks for helping us to remember that we can be disappointed by others and ourselves without giving up.

  2. Yes. If we love Jesus Christ we can love his suffering Mystical Body. Christ who suffered intensely upon the Cross the supreme act of love for us while we were sinners, winning saving grace for the repentant. The divinity entering our world the Word made flesh that he might show us the depth of his love. We are a Church of sinners presently seemingly overwhelmed with apostate error, the heinous crimes of sexual perversion and abortion creeping like serpents into its very marrow. Many feel repugnant of what the Church is in appearance, nevertheless it is Christ who is crucified again as through the centuries. Yes if we love Christ we know Christ, and as said by bishop Diadochus of Photice if we love him it’s because he loves us, infusing us with that love. This hour of Darkness is when we prove our love for our Savior by remaining steadfastly true to him, his Gospels, and his sullied torn Church, exactly as he appeared when struggling with the Cross en route to Golgotha. If we truly love him we will remain more determined to suffer with him, to prove our love within this suffering Mystical Body enduring with him the suffering that supplements what is missing in his own suffering, that is to say by our participation we become like the suffering Christ. Like Alter Christi. And as Bishop Diachus says, reminding us of the Apostle’s words experiencing the delectable reward of that glorious love.

  3. If I made add a word to my comment it is trust. Many of us find failure in the Church and seek to leave because what Christ said in the Gospels hasn’t occurred. We make a judgment on the words of Christ. Love of someone is to trust them. We trust because we acknowledge exceptional goodness in the one we love, that will not betray us, why we love them. Saint Maria Faustina was told by Christ to pray to his image, Jesus I trust you. It really means to trust him above all, including our judgment. It’s a form of complete surrender to Christ, an ultimate act of faith, an ultimate act of love.

1 Trackback / Pingback

  1. Can we love the Church? – Catholic World Report - Moje mnenje je:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

All comments posted at Catholic World Report are moderated. While vigorous debate is welcome and encouraged, please note that in the interest of maintaining a civilized and helpful level of discussion, comments containing obscene language or personal attacks—or those that are deemed by the editors to be needlessly combative or inflammatory—will not be published. Thank you.