White Nationalists and Black-clad Antifas

In a sane world, both the racial hatred of white supremacists and the ideological hatred of Antifa would be condemned and combatted.

Rose City Antifa activists with modified anarchist red and black flag and transgender pride flag in a protest against Patriot Prayer in 2017 in Portland, Oregon. (Old White Truck/Wikipedia)

Shortly after the El Paso massacre, a terrorism expert appeared on my TV screen claiming that white nationalist terrorists were just like Islamic jihadists. Not long after, another expert in another interview said more or less the same thing. An August 5th New York Times article opens by stating, “Many scholars of terrorism see worrying similarities between the rise of the Islamic State and that of white nationalist terrorism…”

Both subscribe to a supremacist ideology, said the experts, and both are willing to die for their beliefs.

That didn’t seem quite right to me because, in many respects, the two groups are polar opposites. The white nationalist are, well, nationalists. And jihadists are, by and large, internationalists. Jihadists fight for Islam—a universal religion that is meant for all people of all races. Moreover, they are much more likely to identify with the ummah—the worldwide community of Muslim believers—than with the particular state or nation in which they live. A radical Muslim living in England typically feels little sense of loyalty to England.

Another obvious difference between the two groups is that jihadists are motivated by religion, and white supremacists, with a few exceptions, are not. The latter may feel a loose association with Christianity, but many are agnostics, atheists, and neo-Nazis. The last words that many jihadist victims hear is “Allahu akbar.” But white nationalists are not in the habit of shouting “Jesus is Lord” when they open fire.

In addition, while white supremacists claim to be fighting for the white race and/or Western Civilization, they are rejected by the majority of whites and also by the representatives of Western Civilization (clergy, elected leaders, educators, etc.) By contrast, polls show that a significant percentage of Muslim believe that jihadists are justified. Muslim leaders may give lip service to condemnations of Islamist terrorists because they know that is what the world expects. But their condemnations often contain built-in loopholes. For example, an Islamic leader may say that “Islam condemns all attacks on innocent people,” knowing full well that in Islamic theology non-Muslim are, by definition, not innocent.

The past masters of this doublespeak are the leaders of the Palestinian Authority. On the one hand, they claim to deplore terrorism. On the other hand, they name streets, squares, parks, and schools in honor of terrorists, and provide families of terrorists with a lifetime income. Westerner’s in the know refer to it as the “pay to slay” program. In the Muslim world, the people that we call terrorists are (if they are killed in the course of jihad) referred to as “martyrs,” and they are highly honored.

Another difference between the two groups is that Islamic terrorists seem to be much better organized and funded than white supremacists. There are hundreds of well-known Islamic terrorist groups worldwide, and some of them possess armies. But in the world of white supremacists there seems to be no equivalent of ISIS, al-Qaeda, or Hezbollah.

Where does the money come from to support these armies and militias? Obviously, several wealthy and not so wealthy Muslim states fund jihadists; but so, in an indirect way, do many ordinary Muslims. Alms-giving or zakat is a religious obligation for all Muslims and is usually paid in the form of a yearly tax. Zakat is used for charitable and religious purposes, but, since one of the main Islamic religious duties is to perform jihad, zakat can be a way of contributing to the jihad without getting your hands dirty. Just as some Irish-American money once flowed to the IRA, Arab-American and Somali-American dollars are now flowing to al-Qaeda, ISIS, and al-Shabaab.

In addition, jihadists receive considerably more moral support than do white terrorists. For one thing, their families often know and approve of their activities, and may even help in the planning. Indeed there are several examples of Palestinian mothers who raise their sons to be jihadists.

What’s more, jihadists receive a form of indirect moral support from Western societies. The latter have proven to be exceedingly protective of the religious ideology that motivates the jihadists. While condemning acts of terror, the leaders of our mainstream institutions heap praise on the “peaceful” faith that inspires the terror.

On the other hand, nobody praises the peaceful nature of white supremacist ideology. There was a time in decades past when local officials and local law enforcement tacitly or even openly supported white supremacists. But that is, thankfully, no longer the case. By contrast, cultural jihad groups such as CAIR and ISNA have no trouble in finding support from government officials at all levels, and from news media, academia, and even the Catholic Church.

Better make that “especially the Catholic Church”. Many Catholic leaders in the U.S. wholeheartedly support CAIR’s anti-Islamophobia campaign, proclaim their “solidarity” with Islam, and hire radical Islamic professors to teach in Catholic universities such as Georgetown. Meanwhile, Pope Francis, seemingly oblivious to the consequences, continues to welcome masses of Muslim migrants into Europe.

There are, in short, a number of problems with the claim that white nationalists and Islamic jihadists are evil twin brothers. There are some similarities between the two groups, but the differences are substantial. The chief difference is that mainstream America disavows the white supremacist agenda, but—through its support of the cultural jihadists—it acts as an enabler of much of the Islamist agenda. More importantly, the intense focus on these two supremacist groups distracts our attention from a third, highly dangerous group.

As it happens, there is a group of mostly white domestic terrorists that does fit the evil twin-brother profile. But it’s not the white nationalists. If you’re looking for a close relative of the jihadists, look no further than the black-clad Antifa.

Antifa? We don’t hear much about them—most probably because the liberal media doesn’t want to call attention to them. Yet there seem to be a great many of them. Antifa is able to mobilize large numbers of protesters, agitators, and street fighters on a moment’s notice in any part of the country. And they usually outnumber whatever group it is they wish to disrupt. But it’s not only groups that they target. In June a large Antifa gang in Portland surrounded reporter Andy Ngo, beat him up, and put him in the hospital with a brain hemorrhage.

Antifa is composed of militant far left groups who believe in taking “direct action” against their opponents. The name “Antifa” is short for “anti-fascist,” but they don’t mind using fascist tactics. They disrupt peaceful meetings and marches, throw punches, bottles, bricks, and even Molotov cocktails.

Although television “experts” tell us that white nationalist resemble jihadists, Antifa is actually much closer to the jihad model. Like jihadists, the Anifa are not nationalists, but internationalist. Although some are anarchists, the majority are socialists and communists, and like socialists everywhere they want to convert the world to their way of thinking. As Karl Marx declared in his Communist Manifesto, “You have a world to win.” Consequently, Antifa pops up all over the world wherever there are racists, sexists, capitalists or anti-immigrationists to be combatted.

Unlike the jihadists, the Antifas aren’t motivated by a religious ideology, but they are motivated by a religious-like ideology. As numerous ex-communists have testified, communism inspires a religious zeal in its adherents. Recruits to communism are told that they can transform the world and, if they die in the process, they will be dying for the sake of oppressed humanity all over the world. Antifas are cast in the same mold. Judging by the statements of Antifa organizers such as Mark Bray and Scott Crow, the Antifa are true believers who are convinced of the righteousness of their cause.

Apparently, many of the representatives of mainstream society also believe in the righteousness of Antifa’s cause. After all, the Antifa want to put a stop to racism, fascism, and hate speech. What could be wrong with that? Consequently, mainstream society turns a blind eye to their tactics of intimidation and violence. The media helps by keeping quiet about Antifa. If you get all your information from the mainstream media, you would hardly know they exist. Politicians, likewise, are happy to pretend that white supremacists are the only domestic terror group around.

Local officials and police also play their part—or, more accurately, decline to play their part. As Mark Steyn puts it, “Antifa. . . perpetrate violence with the support and connivance of powerful Democratic politicians and their hideously politicized police departments.” In reference to the beating of Andy Ngo while the police looked the other way, Steyn writes:

In Democrats’ northern fiefdoms the cops increasingly behave as they did in the party’s old southern fiefdoms—they‘re there not to keep the peace but to ensure that their buddies in the Klan–whoops, sorry, I mean Klantifa–get to give the designated “troublemakers” a bloody good hiding.

In Europe, where Antifa operates with even more impunity than in America, the bias in their favor is more glaring. Take the numerous Antifa attacks on PEGIDA—an anti-mass immigration group that became known initially for their candlelight “evening strolls” in Dresden, Germany. Police in Germany and elsewhere not only failed to intervene to protect the peaceful marchers, they occasionally informed Antifa of the marchers’ route. This despite the fact, that many of the PEGIDA participants were families with children.

The police are not the only enablers of Antifa. European media plays its part by describing PEGIDA as “extreme right-wing,” and by portraying the Antifa attacks as “clashes” between the two parties—just as the world media has long described Boko Haram attacks on Christians in Nigeria as “clashes.”

PEGIDA, by the way, stands for “Patriotic Europeans against the Islamization of the West.” Which brings us to a central point: Antifa not only resembles Islamists, it has taken it upon itself to protect Islamic interests. The Antifa animus against PEGIDA stems mainly from the fact that PEGIDA opposes Islamization. Likewise, as one Antifa supporter helpfully explained, Andy Ngo was not attacked because of his race but because he’s a “Muslim hating fascist.” Unknown to most Americans there has long been a tacit alliance between the left and radical Islam. Numerous examples of the “red-green” alliance can be found in Jamie Glazov’s well-documented exposé United in Hate. Among the most consequential of these “alliances” was the left-leaning Obama administration’s love affair with various radical Islamist states and organizations such as Iran and the Muslim Brotherhood.

One last observation. The media silence about Antifa combined with its condemnation of white nationalists suggests that a certain strategy is now in play which conservatives Americans might not understand until it is too late.

In a sane world, both the racial hatred of white supremacists and the ideological hatred of Antifa would be condemned and combatted. But the media, along with liberal politicians and academics, have no interest in combatting Antifa. Like Antifa, they too lean to the left. Consequently, they sympathize with Antifa’s objectives, and overlook it extremist measures.

One of the main Antifa objectives is to deplatform and silence people they disagree with—the “haters” as they call them. But Antifa’s definition of a “hater” is quite broad. And so also is the definition employed by liberals and leftists in general. About half of the Democrat presidential candidates have already declared that Donald Trump is a “white supremacist.” And from there, it’s just a short leap to the conclusion that all the people who support Trump are haters.

If conservative-minded people rashly sign-on to the left’s silence-all-haters campaign, they will soon discover that they are on the list. They will also find that there is no corresponding call to silence the voices of radical leftists or radical Islamists. The net result is that the hands of the Antifas and the jihadists will be strengthened, while the voices of those who have doubts about mass immigration and Islamization will be silenced.

What about Catholics? What are they to think? Unfortunately, Catholics can’t often rely on Catholic leaders to help them make the necessary distinctions. Bishops are quick on the draw when there is the slightest hint of racism or nationalism, but they have relatively little to say about the thousands of African Christians who are killed in “clashes” with Muslim militia. And, of course, they have no patience with Christians who are critical of immigrants who won’t assimilate. Nationalists are on the bishops’ radar, but Antifa is not. After one of PEGIDA’s peaceful marches, Ludwig Schick ,the Archbishop of Bamberg, said that “Christians must not take part in PEGIDA.” Why? Because:

PEGIDA activists spread racial hatred and stir up irrational anxieties against the people; they are a reservoir of diffuse aggression against people of other cultures and religions.

It’s likely, of course, that the thing about PEGIDA that really annoys Schick is that word “Patriotic.” It’s not just white nationalists but all nationalists that are considered suspect by many bishops—and this despite the Church’s clear teaching about the legitimacy of patriotism.

By contrast, the bishops seem to have great respect for international organizations. It’s telling that Archbishop Schick has also called for “blasphemy laws”—laws which are intended to silence any criticism of Islam. Silencing critics of Islam is also, coincidentally, one of the goals of Antifa.

The left-liberal establishment has basically given cover to Antifa and other similar groups. In the end that may prove to be a greater danger to our society than the threat posed by white supremacists. You have undoubtedly heard of the El-Paso shooter’s “conservative” leanings. It’s less likely that you’ve heard all the details about Connor Betts, the self-described leftist who killed nine people and injured dozens of others in Dayton Ohio a mere fifteen hours after the El-Paso massacre. One “minor” detail is that Betts expressed support for Antifa and was known to wear Antifa masks during on-stage performances with his death metal band.

A good many people who come across that item may well wonder what Antifa is. Given the scanty coverage that the media has provided, it might just as well be some other death metal band.


If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!

Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.


About William Kilpatrick 58 Articles
William Kilpatrick taught for many years at Boston College. He is the author of several books about cultural and religious issues, including Psychological Seduction, Why Johnny Can’t Tell Right from Wrong and, most recently, Christianity, Islam, and Atheism: The Struggle for the Soul of the West. Professor Kilpatrick’s articles on cultural and educational topics have appeared in First Things, Policy Review, American Enterprise, American Educator, The Los Angeles Times, and various scholarly journals. His articles on Islam have appeared in Aleteia, National Catholic Register, Investor’s Business Daily, FrontPage Magazine, and other publications. Professor Kilpatrick’s work is supported in part by the Shillman Foundation. For more on his work and writings, visit his website, turningpointproject.com.

24 Comments

  1. To me the single most overused word these days is the word ‘expert’. IMO it is overused to the extent that it simply has no meaning anymore, and when I see it used, especially so early in this piece, it tells me that the writer is a bit desperate. What are the qualifications for such a designation?

    One more thing – The ‘Rose City Antifa Activists” (sounds like a band name) appear to be well-dressed which in turn means well-funded. Who pays for those snazzy outfits and flags and for their travels from point a to point b? Names and proof please – let’s give them the credit they deserve.

  2. The NY Times now acknowledges ISIS to be a bad thing? Would the tune be different if it had taken over Syria? This is the only surprising development to me.

    While the article does much to counter the dominant cultural Marxist narrative, why promote the claim that white nationalists are guilty of racial hatred? Do we make the same accusation of Chinese or African nationalists?

  3. Antifa reminds me, more than anything, of the Brown Shirts (SA or Sturmabteilung) in pre-WWII Germany. They provided racist violence and fomented social chaos for the National Socialist Party until after if came to power, after which Hitler killed its leaders and essentially disbanded it.

    • really?, i’d say they are the exact opposite to that. Anti fascist protestors do not do “racist” violence. the whole point of being anti fascist is to abhor racism of any kind.
      ah and scroll down one and you get Soros mentioned. like Right Wing/Neo con bingo.

      • “…being anti fascist is to abhor racism of any kind,” so you buy into their propaganda? And their violence doesn’t disturb you because…?

      • Fiona,
        I don’t know whether George Soros has any connection with Antifa but he has donated 18-19 billion US dollars to fund other movements. Assuming Mr. Soros is involved with any particular leftwing organization may be incorrect but you probably have better odds of winning that argument than in Bingo.
        🙂

  4. Follow the money,and it will take one back to Soros,The Clintons,and Barrack H.Obama/Joe Biden.Vale Jarrett also has role in funding Antifa as the Iranians bag woman.White Nationalism is a MSM/NETs created fear to give Antifa legitimacy in the public eye.Rules for Radicals has never been set aside as the liberal vehicle to attain power again.Lucifer won’t allow it!

  5. All these extremists seem like 2 sides of the same coin to me. Just as totalitarian govts closely resemble each other no matter what sort of philosophy they espouse. It’s all the same thing to the poor folks living under those regimes.

  6. Reading a piece about the Charlottesville Va riot in a RC publication (NCR I think) obtained off a Church bulletin shelf, it said describing events there, that the ANTFA’s were peacemakers coming in to supposedly save the day.

    • Reading a piece about the Charlottesville Va riot in a RC publication (NCR I think) obtained off a Church bulletin shelf, it said describing events there, that the ANTFA’s were peacemakers coming in to supposedly save the day”
      *********
      They were hardly that of course. Local law enforcement had begged everyone to stay away from the demonstrations. Three people died because the public ignored that advice. And beyond ignoring the advice to stay home, they ratcheted it up.

  7. http://www.ncregister.com/daily-news/pope-francis-gives-thousands-of-rosaries-to-christians-in-syria Good news of this day , as we celebrate the Feast of
    Assumption , the Holy Father , sharing the care of a Father’s Heart , through that of our Mother , in both saying and advocating the Rosary prayers ,sharing same, also raising up many souls who are caught up in the thick shroud of egos , spending long days / years , in purgatory , waiting for that light and love of The Father , to get through – as mentioned in this book –
    https://store.spiritdaily.com/product-p/gi-798.htm
    May the prayers of the holy souls too help us all and our families , every news such as in the article to also help us to bring up similar souls in purgatory , unto Him , helping us thus to hate the evil, yet be loving of both the neighbor and ourselves , as the priesthood so mercifully and generously given us all in The Lord , in our baptism , empowers and invites us to do .

    Immaculate Heart of Mary, pray for us all .

  8. We’ve had Napoleon the Anti-Christ. We’ve had aristocrats and politicians instead of Apostles. We’ve heard of Jesuit love of ‘Christian’ communism. We’ve survived Judas-priests for 50 years, including drunks, the lavender mafia, and pederasts, pedophiles and predatory homosexuals. We may even survive the anti-pope. But the Church will not survive. The Deceiver’s false prophets have destroyed the credibility of all but the Saints, and muzzled apostles are too cowardly to be saints.

    This spiritual dictatorship is the single justification for suppressing the deification of the being of human beings that Jesus began. You Sadducees rejected the Word of God then, and you are rejecting Him now.

    The Christ will not approve, and neither do I. Purify yourselves now, or else.
    The Judge of the living and the dead will be bringing fire and wrathful love.

  9. What utter false equivilent nonsense
    According to the FBI, white supremacist terrorism has killed as many Americans as islamic terrorism in the last 15 years, and now they are starting to outpace the islamists since the Tree Of Life massacre and more recently El Paso
    Meanwhile, in the same time how many people killed by Antifa?
    Try zero
    The reason Antifa is out there is due to the reluctence of the US Government, controlled by Trump and the republican right, to monitor and co-opt rightwing terrorist activity.
    Antifa for the most part works to successfully expose neo-nazis to their families, schools and employers.
    Trump’s minions have been making deadly threats, one recently just got 20 years in prison for sending pipe bombs in the mail to democrats, including President Obama.
    The true terrorist threat in America comes from the right

    • Except they aren’t exposing anything but their own Left oriented fascism! Andy Ngo is not a neo-nazi you ingrate, neither were some of the other victims of Anqueeefa…

  10. What nonsense, wait till we are fully diverse and you will see why you should have listened to the so called white supremacists. Whites will slaughtered like everywhere else Brown’s invade. Try looking up statistics and South Africa…people like you are the reason I am no longer Christian but pagan.

  11. Nationalists, white, black, asian, etc etc. are not white supremacists obviously and using the terms interchangeably is ridiculous. Antifa is supported by the Left, even though they are domestic terrorists. Trump supporters ARE NOT domestic terrorists, nor fascists, nor white supremacists in general. Nothing wrong with loving your country, white, black, asian, hispanic, native.

  12. The young man sentenced to life in prison for erratic motor-car driving resulting from excessive stirred up emotions from the crowd in Charlotteville needs our prayers, and a full pardon soon. If ANTIFA obeyed the police there and stayed away, there would be no riot or death.

  13. All it takes is for Kilpatrick to start ranting about the homogeneous ‘antifa’ and ‘the left’ and ‘Islam” (they all take orders from the same people I guess) and with great leaps and bounds decides that anyone to his left, politically or culturally, is a) an Islamic plant determined to destroy the west, b) a Marxist radical with a hate-boner for all religion, and c) a well-funded, well-endowed NGO operative funded by a cabal of the world’s wealthiest business elites, who are also Islamic atheistic Communists.

    Is it any wonder that we see the article’s comment section lined up with white supremacist sympathizers (“erratic driving resulting from stirred-up emotions” is one of the better euphemisms for murder I’ve heard), nazi larpers, and conspiracy theorists? You give fertile ground for idiots to grow, and they will start to take root. What fruit will be borne on this site with seeds like that, hmm??

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

All comments posted at Catholic World Report are moderated. While vigorous debate is welcome and encouraged, please note that in the interest of maintaining a civilized and helpful level of discussion, comments containing obscene language or personal attacks—or those that are deemed by the editors to be needlessly combative or inflammatory—will not be published. Thank you.


*