The Archdiocese of Portland asked lay people to refrain from raising their hands and holding hands during the Lord’s prayer at Mass, citing various Church documents concerning liturgical norms.
The Archdiocese of Portland, Oregon, has asked laypeople to refrain from holding hands or raising their hands during the Our Father prayer at Masses in the archdiocese.
While the Catholic liturgy is fairly uniform across Catholic parishes, some Mass attendees raise their hands in the “orans” posture of prayer or hold hands during the Our Father prayer, while others don’t. The Archdiocese of Portland through an official instruction has asked laypeople to refrain from doing either.
“Over the last few decades there has been some confusion as to whether the lay faithful should extend or raise their hands (and even holding hands with others) when the Lord’s Prayer is prayed during Mass, as the priest does,” stated the announcement in the Archdiocese of Portland’s November 2026 issue of its Divine Worship Newsletter.
“Neither the deacons assisting at Mass, nor the lay faithful, are ever instructed to use this posture,” the announcement continued. “It is a liturgical posture that is proper to the priest. When the priest uses this posture, he is praying on behalf of the people.”
In arriving at its decision, the archdiocese cited various Church documents and instructions concerning liturgical norms.
The archdiocese referred to the General Instruction of the Roman Missal (GIRM), a foundational Vatican document on liturgy.
“While the GIRM does not explicitly forbid the lay faithful from using the Orans posture during the Our Father, it gives guidance as to why the lay faithful should not use this posture,” the announcement read. “Whenever the GIRM gives the instructions for hands to be extended, it is always with reference to the priest specifically, whether it be the principal celebrant or concelebrants.”
The archdiocese also referenced instructions given in Vatican II documents.
“Further, the Second Vatican Council’s Constitution on Sacred Liturgy, Sacrosanctum Concilium, states that ‘no other person, even if he be a priest, may add, remove, or change anything in the liturgy on his own authority.’ (SC 22.3),” the archdiocese continued. “Since the GIRM is very specific that the priest is instructed by the GIRM (152) to extend his hands when he prays the Lord’s Prayer, for the deacons or the laity to extend their hands would be adding to the liturgy.”
The archdiocese also referenced the Church’s guiding legal system, the Code of Canon Law.
“The Church gives further guidance on this issue. Code of Canon Law (CIC) 907 states, ‘In the Eucharistic celebration deacons and lay persons are not permitted to offer prayers, especially the Eucharistic prayer, or to perform actions which are proper to the celebrating priest,’” the document states.
Finally, the archdiocese cited tradition prior to the New Roman Missal of 1970.
“Prior to the New Roman Missal of 1970, only the priest prayed the Lord’s Prayer as a part of the Liturgy and had his hands extended while he prayed on behalf of the people. Nothing in the Roman Missal of 1970, nor the documents of the Second Vatican Council, indicated that there would be a change in posture during the Lord’s Prayer.”
Where does the ‘orans’ posture come from?
In the Catholic liturgy, the priest takes on the “orans” posture as a sign of praying on behalf of the people.
The posture was common in most ancient religions. In Christianity, it can be seen throughout Scripture, memorably in Exodus 17 when Moses lifts his hands during the battle against Amalek. While his hands are raised, the Israelites are winning, but when his hands fall, they start to lose the battle.
This posture can also be seen throughout some of the Psalms and in the New Testament as well. The “orans” posture of prayer is also depicted in early Christian art, including in the catacombs.
If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!
Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.


Some thoughts come to mind:
By raising my hands with joy and sometimes warmly clasping hands with others, I’m openly declaring, in public witness among the assembled faithful, that The GOD & Father of our LORD Jesus Christ has, through the work of Christ, become MY GOD & Father; and is the GOD & Father of every believing Catholic.
Jesus instructed US to pray the Our Father.
He did not instruct the temple priests to pray this prayer over the people.
HE is The Way, The Truth, & The Life & must always be our first point of reference.
As in Psalms: there’d be no doubt Jesus & His Apostles raised their hands in worship.
At a very basic level, every Holy Spirit-annointed Catholic deeply desires to worship GOD with all their heart, soul, mind, & strength (Mark 12:30) and feels privileged to show that & encourage others to show it, by singing and by bodily gestures during communal worship, such as in Holy Mass.
If some clergy & some lay in the congregation feel challenged by this – maybe that indeed is GOD’s intention!
Always in the grace & mercy of King Jesus Christ; love & blessings from marty
Mmmmm. And if someone says, “By doing cartwheels and backflips down the aisle, and sometimes yelling “Yeee-hah!,” I’m openly declaring, in public witness among the assembled faithful, that The GOD & Father of our LORD Jesus Christ has, through the work of Christ, become MY GOD & Father; and is the GOD & Father of every believing Catholic,” you’ve really left yourself no argument against it.
“Jesus instructed US to pray the Our Father.
He did not instruct the temple priests to pray this prayer over the people.”
The article didn’t say he was praying this prayer over the people. It said he was praying on behalf of the people. And the people who are present *are* praying the Our Father. Andd the priest is praying on behalf of them and of the whole Church.
Superb response, Leslie. Too many people assume that if they have good intentions, then indeed cartwheels and backflips and wrongly appropriating the orans posture reserved only for the priest is a good thing, and who cares what the Church says.
This directive is going to upset a lot of well-meaning, faithful people.
IMO, it would have been better to explain that the gesture represents the priest speaking on behalf of the people and stop there.
Most people don’t know this.
I went to a cantor training 15 years ago and this was explained as the article said they’re priestly gestures. Also, holding hands during the Our Father is unnecessary because we’re striving to get to heaven but we’re not in heaven.
I’ve read this a few times and I can’t get past ‘silly’.
Or is it just me?
Godly wisdom on The Web:
Lifting hands in worship and prayer appears throughout the Old and New Testaments, tied to praise, pleading, surrender and blessing. The psalmists lifted their hands as an act of praise. Prophets and priests lifted their hands during intercession. Paul told the believers in Ephesus to pray with hands lifted (1 Timothy 2:8). The posture reaches back thousands of years, long before any modern worship movement adopted it.
What the Bible Says About Lifting Hands in Worship
Here is a sample of the texts that describe the practice, paraphrased below and linked to the full verse.
In Psalm 63:4, David commits to praising God for the rest of his life, lifting his hands in God’s name as he does.
In Psalm 28:2, the psalmist cries out for mercy while lifting his hands toward God’s holy dwelling place.
In Psalm 134:2, worshippers are told to lift their hands toward the sanctuary and praise the Lord.
In Psalm 143:6, the psalmist stretches out his hands to God, comparing his thirst for God to a parched, waterless land.
In 2 Chronicles 6:13, Solomon kneels before the entire assembly of Israel and spreads his hands toward heaven to dedicate the temple.
In Ezra 9:5, Ezra falls to his knees with his hands spread out to the Lord after learning of the people’s unfaithfulness.
In Nehemiah 8:6, the people answer Ezra’s praise with lifted hands, then bow with their faces to the ground.
In Lamentations 3:41, the prophet calls the people to lift up their hearts and hands together to God in heaven.
In 1 Timothy 2:8, Paul instructs the men of the church to pray with hands lifted, free of anger and arguing.
That range spans law, poetry, history, prophecy and New Testament instruction. A posture that shows up across that much of Scripture is a consistent pattern of worship, not a one-off image from a single writer.
Worship Engages the Whole Body
Some Christians treat worship as strictly an internal experience, something that happens only in the mind and spirit. That view has old roots. Ancient Gnostic teachers treated the body as a lesser, even corrupt, part of a person, something to suppress so the “true” spiritual self could worship freely. Church culture still carries traces of that thinking, even when nobody would call it Gnosticism by name.
Scripture teaches something different. God made physical bodies and called them good (Genesis 1:31). Paul urged believers to offer their bodies as a living sacrifice, calling that physical act of devotion “true and proper worship” (Romans 12:1). Kneeling, singing, dancing, bowing and lifting hands are all physical expressions of an internal reality.
What Lifting Your Hands in Worship Communicates
The Body Speaks Before Words Do
Hands communicate constantly, whether a person intends it or not. A clenched fist signals anger. Hidden hands can signal shame. Wringing hands show worry. Open arms welcome someone in. In worship, open, lifted hands carry meaning too, meaning words alone struggle to hold.
Surrender
Lifting your hands mirrors the posture of surrender, the same posture someone takes when yielding to a higher authority. In worship it says, without a single word, that you belong to God and submit to his direction over your life.
Nevertheless, for decades liturgists have blurred the distinction between the baptized and the ordain priest—who is an extension of the bishop, who in turn is a member of the Apostolic Succession “sent[!]” by the incarnate Jesus Christ. Ours is a Eucharistic and therefore universal Church, not a collection of neighborhood congregations who happen to have the same merely self-expressive ritual.
It would not be meaningless for liturgists to restore the term “celebrant” in place of whatever a “presider” (facilitator?) is supposed to be.
While there is a continuity with the Old Testament—as in your citations—the New Testament is categorically new and unprecedented. With Lumen Gentium we find a difficult balance but also clarity: The bishops are not simply delegates of the pope, but trace their own authority back to the apostles (as he traces back to St. Peter); the Church is both a handholding/evangelical (spiritual) mystery and an institutional “hierarchical communion;” the roles of the ordained and laity “differ in kind [!] as well as degree;” and yet there is the “universal call to holiness”.
In recent experience, there really is a difference between a “synod [of bishops]” and a townhall meeting claiming the same name where the role of the bishop is reduced “primarily as a facilitator” (the Vademecum).
Thankyou, dear Peter D. Beaulieu for these insightful points.
Is it not always a problem, though, when ecclesial success is measured – not by fostering obedience to GOD’s Commandments, expressing GOD’s Kingdom come on Earth as in Heaven – but by worldly integration through enormous wealth, property, media management, and vast numbers of adherents under tight clerical administration by an extensive bureaucracy, riven by shadey allegiances, scadalous immoralities, patent untruths, & swingeing injustices?
This is the same pattern of ‘success’ followed by many diverse religions.
In contrast, Christ’s approval is expressed for the mutual servanthood of loving siblings who joyfully exemplify obedience to GOD’s Commandments (e.g. Matthew 9:35; Mark 23:8; John 14:23-24). A pattern unique to Christianity & one that’s at the heart of genuine Catholicism: the *hidden treasure* & *pearl of great value*. One that is exemplified by many excellent priests and lay leaders.
Episcopal & papal edicts that bruise this familial joy have ‘jumped the rails’ set by our LORD, and may provoke Him to question them: “Do you love Me?”
Why are our current Catholic leaders & administrators too often ‘startled by gnats’, whilst they happily ‘swallow camels’?
One surmises that majoring-on-minors provides them with Dopamine highs . . ?
A poor substitute for the Holy Spirit highs they should have been seeking.
Ah well: we carry on regardless, maybe praying as Jesus prayed:
“Father forgive them; they don’t know what they are doing!”
Personally, the only times I had observed the uplifted hands was at evangelical services I attended as a guest of others. That is, until my return to the church after many years absence. Now I see it every time I attend Mass. Sunday or daily. I have been aware of this rule for a very long time and have long wondered why the priests haven’t kindly put an end to it. If they can’t muster the spine to enforce a simple rule like this, what hope is there they will say anything about illicit sex or abortion?? Slim and none.
Oh, thank goodness for the Archdiocese of Portland! I’m pleased to see that finally someone is standing up for liturgical norms instead of doing a dreary, feeble, whiny, “Well, okayyyyyyy, since you’re already ignoring them, go ahead and ignore them.”
Using the gestures that are specific to the priest strikes me as yet another part of the modern trend of trying to eliminate any distinction between the ministerial, ordained priesthood and the common priesthood of the faithful. Which seems to me to be rooted in pride: “I’m just as important and special as the priest! I demand that I get to do everything he does!” See also: Communion in the hand.
I’ve never been to a Latin mass, that I can remember, as born during Vat II era. It just struck me this is all part of the continuing dissolution of the Latin mass, which was absolutely centered on the altar and presidor?
You nailed it again, Leslie. And you see the deeper problems involved that those who defend the practice are unable to see, blinded by their pride that also manifests itself in their continuing defense of the practice even after they have been properly catechized against its use.
It makes no sense why anyone, much less a Bishop, should choose this gesture to exert “discipline”. It is not prohibited by their own admission and is Biblical as well. Keep your hands in prayer in the way that you feel. No body’s business as they are (hopefully) praying fervently with their whole mind and sight on God.
“No body’s business”…well, shucks, since we’re talking about body language, when will we dispense with the 1969 Woodstock split-finger hand wave as the Eucharistic “sign of peace”?
Dear Peter,
The “peace” sign originated before Vatican II which should please you! Another great alternative hand sign is the Vulcan greeting, actually having roots in the Jewish Tradition.
The famous Vulcan salute (“live long and prosper”) from Star Trek is directly adapted from the traditional Jewish Birkat Kohanim (Priestly Blessing) performed in the synagogue, which has roots in the Torah and Talmudic tradition. So many cool things in the world, huh? Pax Christi
The divine liturgy is a communal act. We don’t each get to decide how we will worship communally. The Church determines this.
I wonder how many “please notice how holy I am Catholics” raise their hands when they pray the Our Father when alone.
Dear ‘Nonsense’ – it’s a shame that your prejudice is also found in too many. Please think deeper, dear brother or sister –
Lifting your hands mirrors the posture of surrender, the same posture someone takes when yielding to a higher authority. In worship it says, without a single word, that you belong to God and submit to His direction over your life.
Of course we raise our hands in our private prayers; far more energetically and frequently than in Holy Mass.
We sing & dance before The Holy Trinity of Love.
And The LORD is not slow to respond.
Of course we are not trying to advertise our own but *GOD’s Holiness*.
Even sacrificially (in regard to your sort of sour attacks) – as a way of encouraging moribund congregants to ENTER IN & be amazed at how Jesus will touch their hearts.
Surely Michal’s punishment in 2 Samuel 6:20-23 provides a salutary warning to us all (clerics as well as lay) NEVER to mock at others’ bodily expressions of loving devotion & complete surrender to The Glory of GOD.
This example of holy worship, in Franciscan Mission of San Juan de Capistrano, may give you an idea of the depths of worship available to all of us; if we have faith enough to enter in:
‘The Praise Is Yours’ Matt Redman YouTube
GOD wants to change our hearts & wholehearted worship is His powerful method.
Are you from CA?
Dear annonymous ‘Knowall’.
No. I’m from Brisbane, Australia. Home of the *2032 Olympic Games!*
Come and visit with us; guarantee you’ll have a great time here.
To be fair, I hear people assume similar intentions for folks like me who wear mantillas inside church. Or who choose to kneel to receive Holy Communion.
We should spend more time working on what’s inside our own hearts I think. And first assume the best intentions in others.
Agreed. Which is exactly why holding hands is so appropriate 😉
Personally, I’d rather not hold hands with a stranger. Of course, I’m one of these males who recoil at the thought of hugging another male in business or social situations that seems have caught on in the last couple decades – a firm handshake is sufficient.
Dear annonymous ‘Knowall’.
How could any informed Catholic think of their brothers & sisters in Christ as ‘a stranger’ – a sort of untouchable leper?
Let’s use this life to grow more & more sociable, for one day we will be cheek-by-jowl together with them all in The Body of Christ in Heaven.
In the Gospels: it’s the Pharisees who hated the thought of contact with strangers. Jesus set us the opposite example.
Think of the song: “Little by little every day; little by little in every way, Jesus is changing me. Since I made that turnabout face, I’ve been growing in Christ’s grace. Yes! Jesus is changing me.”
It could be a distraction for some; have you ever noticed people looking at others during critical parts of the mass?
Susanne,
Archbishops have the authority to set the liturgical postures in their diocese. It’s not an exertion of discipline. It’s an act of prudence.
I believe that part of Archbishop Sample’s decision is possibly because the raising of hands is known as the Orans posture, which is reserved for only priests or bishops, and not the laity. During the Mass (or Divine Liturgy if you will) it is the priest who leads the congregation in prayer, a dialogue between Heaven (the priest “In Persona Christi” at the altar table, and Earth, which is us in the pews.
The raising of hands in prayer is Biblical and not reserved to the clergy by the rubrics. Prudence would say don’t die on a hill that isn’t necessary to die on.
No Susanne. The raising of hands, known as the Orans Posture, is reserved for clergy alone, and not the congregation. This is especially true during the Eucharistic Prayer (also known as the Anaphora) and the Our Father. Unfortunately, this erroneous practice has been ingrained into people for decades to the point where it’s become normal, even though it does indeed go against the rubrics in the Roman Rite.
Here’s the link to back up what I just posted.
https://www.google.com/url?sa=i&source=web&rct=j&url=https://www.catholic.com/qa/orans-posture-at-mass&ved=2ahUKEwiP5uC1gIaYAxUqDDQIHTHIDMMQms4VegYIAggeEDw&opi=89978449&cd&psig=AOvVaw2AlfCE29zdKW_WXPKOMfeu&ust=1794695647723000
Prudence would also say that dying on a hill, even if it were an unnecessary one, is noble if the reasons were out of sincere respect for the office of priesthood.
The priesthood of the baptized prays to Our Father in the ancient way as taught by Christ Himself. This takes nothing from the Priest and is not forbidden by the rubrics which merely say the congregation are not to imitate the Priest. The Bishop of Portland may well be a good and holy man but this seems as much a pointless fight as telling people not to kneel for communion. Losing a fight you didn’t need to have entered is not noble.
My point is simple. The laity is not to imitate the Orans posture, which is reserved for the priest.
Archbishop Sample is a very good bishop too, a true shepherd in the hellhole city of Portland.
I think we see where we differ, but either way, in hindsight, I think you’re right in saying it’s not a hill worth dying on.
I will say though that one can die on a hill and still win. Christ did.
Christ, high priest and unique mediator, has made of the Church “a kingdom, priests for his God and Father” (Revelation 1:6, see 5:9–10; 1 Peter 2:5,9). … The faithful exercise their baptismal priesthood through their participation, each according to their own vocation, in Christ’s mission as priest, prophet, and king (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1546).
Well said, Marty.
It seems cluttered when some are moving their arms and some aren’t
There is a difference between the common priesthood of the faithful and the ordained, ministerial priesthood.
Yes. Some people support unity among Catholics and see multiple forms of the Mass as breaking that unity. At the same time, some want to do what they want to do during Mass, no matter what the Rubrics or their bishops authorize.
So far as doing what Jesus did, Jesus died and rose, physically as well as spiritually, from the dead. I don’t see many clamoring for that course of action. We do not have to do what Jesus did to follow him. We should begin by taking up the cross and sometimes doing what we do not want to do.
Finally, some modern shakers want no distinction between the ordained and the common priesthood. Any little action which blurs the difference is applauded.
In our private personal life of prayer outside the liturgy, we can pray in all sorts of ways with any posture we wish. Because our Church is traditionally, historically, and structurally founded by Christ as a hierarchy and considered in apostolic succession, the laity is under some authority not their own to do what they may not will.
Honestly I’m just glad to see people in the pews these days. I don’t pay much attention to how others pray the Lord’s Prayer.
Bad liturgical music is a major distraction though. That’s more difficult to not notice.
the music needs to get back to worshipping Almighty God, and leave church policy out of it.
You and I are similar in that, Mrs. Cracker. I try to maintain “custody of my eyes” as my dear catechists insisted back in the day. Like any muscle, it requires continuous working out to stay strong. 😉
We agree on that Miss Susanne.
Now I have to work on keeping custody of my ears during Mass…
🙂
Get an indoor church hat with ear flaps and hidden ear plugs sewn in; simply pull the flaps down unnoticed and the inconspicuous ear plugs will drown out the sound you need to
To repeat – People don’t know that the raising of hands is a priestly gesture. Start by teaching this. Most people will figure out the rest themselves.
Dear Cleo: to help us ‘figure out the rest’, here’s some snippetts of good Catholic Christian doctrine:
“The Catechism of the Catholic Church is clear about the priestly office:
Baptism makes us members of the Body of Christ. … “to be a holy priesthood” (1 Peter 2:5). By Baptism we share in the priesthood of Christ, in his prophetic and royal mission. We are “a chosen race, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, God’s own people …” (1 Peter 2:9). Baptism gives us a share in the common priesthood of all believers (Chatechism of the Catholic Church, 1267, 1268).
(Note: The Catechism also references our common priesthood in paragraphs 1141, 1143, 1268, 1305, 1535, 1547, 1591, and 1592.)
It surprises some to learn that the common priesthood is not a reference to the clergy. Ordained priests, by Holy Orders, become members of the ministerial priesthood. Yet the common priesthood designates all the baptized. Sharing in the priesthood of Christ begins at our Baptism.
The common priesthood and the ministerial priesthood worship together at Mass. We are a priestly community. The lay faithful worship alongside the ordained priest(s). Both make offerings to God. The priest is specifically ordained to confect the Eucharist — to offer and consecrate the bread and wine — on behalf of those gathered. The laity, too, actively participate by offering themselves and their gifts and sacrifices to God.
Christ, high priest and unique mediator, has made of the Church “a kingdom, priests for his God and Father” (Revelation 1:6, see 5:9–10; 1 Peter 2:5,9). … The faithful exercise their baptismal priesthood through their participation, each according to their own vocation, in Christ’s mission as priest, prophet, and king (CCC, 1546).”
This informative extract seems to settle the legitimacy of raised hands.
Some in our congregations know who they are; some disgruntled know not yet.
A clear call for good sermons explaining the fullness of our lives in Christ.
Ever seeking to hear & lovingly obey King Jesus Christ; blessings to all from marty
The use of the orans posture by the laity began to pick up more frequency arising out of the problematic charismatic movement as it gained ground in the 1970s, and it coincides with more and more people claiming to have special gifts without proof, and also that they are “special” to the extent that they frequently hold themselves out to be “assistant” or “virtual priests.”
Also, people using it often do so out of too much pride, not limiting their thoughts to being a member of the common priesthood, but also seeing themselves as part of the ministerial priesthood.
It is indeed the ministerial priest who uses the orans posture on behalf of all of the people. In loving and more Christ-Focused humility, the laity should never hold or extend their hands, or imitate the gestures or speak aloud any words reserved only for the celebrating priest during Mass, even if they have good intentions in doing so.
For more wisdom on the humility of NOT imitating the celebrating priest at Mass, but humbly accepting your own role as supporting laity, see the following very insightful article that also contains relevant references:
“The Faithful Are NOT To Use the Orans Posture During the Our Father” at https://www.catholic365.com/article/5408/the-faithful-are-not-to-use-the-orans-posture-during-the-our-father.html
Pride will still sadly motivate many to ignore the wisdom of the Church in this regard (no matter how much they may claim otherwise), and they will continue to purposely conflate the roles of the ministerial priesthood with the common priesthood so they can continue to imitate the Priest in a manner that should be left for him alone. As always, humility is the anecdote, and in this case, even out of simple respect, the laity should not adopt the actions of the celebrating priest.
“the problematic charismatic movement as it gained ground in the 1970s, and it coincides with more and more people claiming to have special gifts”
The Catholic Charismatic Renewal International Service is established by the Vatican. It is not “problematic” in any way. Catholic Charismatics are orthodox and faithful though frequently looked down upon by “trads”.
Your limited reference misses my point that brings up some of the history and problems of the movement.
For instance, some three years ago at a local Church I visited, it was noted that it had for a few years provided special opportunities for a particular charismatic group to hold meetings and prayer services, etc., but these were eventually cancelled because they soon enough got more and more bizarre, and they started to manifest way too much pride in themselves, with many of their events becoming nothing more than outlandish parties wherein each of the participants got up one at a time and told the others about their great gifts that made them special, and how such “gifts” were signs from God on just how special they were. The pastor tolerated them for a while but finally had enough of the problematic BS and rightly cancelled them as he saw the damage being done to some of his parishioners who decided to get involved with the group.
Some years before that I investigated another charismatic group wherein the people, all ostensibly Catholic, who attended a particular meeting, came out of the meeting claiming special gifts, with one participant telling me that now she had the power to heal. I mentioned to her that I had recently suffered a mild stomach muscle strain whereupon she told me she could take care of it by placing her hands on my stomach. I indulged her by letting her place her hands on my stomach in a prudent manner for about 20 seconds, but of course no healing occurred…and it did not require any special faith I did not have, even though some charismatics will also make such a proud claim whenever their demonstrations of their “powers” turn out flatter than a pancake.
Cult-like indeed, as is much of the charismatic movement despite some good people in some parts of it as well that do not get swept up in the cult-like atmosphere of many individual groups that permeate it.
So who cares about the larger group you mention? It is irrelevant to the larger point and reality of the problems on the local level. Check out local groups in your vicinity, and also check out the history of such and their specific practices and kinds of self-flattering events they frequently feature, and then perhaps you will see problems you choose not to see while also taking a shot at those you refer to as trads who are at least not nearly so gullible and confused about the Faith and serving with humility instead of with pride like many in the highly problematic charismatic movement are afflicted with. Instead of praising them, pray for them and ask Holy Angels to protect them and help deliver them from the malevolent spirit that has a real hold on too many of them.
“Susanne Lee
November 13, 2026 at 7:06 pm
I am sad that your limited experience with your fellow Catholics in the Charismatic movement has only served to reinforce your negative stereotypes.”
Sorry, kiddo. My experience is actually quite broad (I had a hunch you would not understand the nature of my examples and wrongly conclude that my experience was limited to the two I provided, but I hoped you wouldn’t be so shallow.), and it involves investigations plus study of the history. My conclusions are not stereotypes, so once again you jump to a false conclusion to defend the indefensible. Very sad indeed, but once again, my suggestion for you to see for yourself remains. Then you will be able to avoid your own stereotypes while wrongly accusing others of doing the same. Go for it, but be careful if you do.
Correction to last sentence above in my post: Humility is the antidote, not anecdote. That’s what I get for dictating words and not paying full attention.
I am sad that your limited experience with your fellow Catholics in the Charismatic movement has only served to reinforce your negative stereotypes.
Well spoken, Cleo.
Add in they should step to the side and face forward towards the altar to ingest the host as well, if taken on the hand. This was how we were taught.
I was taught to consume the host in front of the Priest before moving away.
Interesting.
For what it’s worth, in the Anglican Church children were taught to kneel at the altar rail and put their hands together to resemble a little altar to receive Communion.
That’s how it still works in an historic Anglican parish I visited in Jamaica a few years ago.
The problem is with the rubrics, not the Faithful.
There are 28 times in the NO when the priest uses the Orans posture, indicating he is praying on behalf of the people. That’s a pretty clear symbolic meaning. This posture doesn’t indicate this outside the Mass (we can pray outside the Mass with this posture all we like) but IN the Mass, it indicates the priestly function of praying on our behalf and should not be done by anyone who is not a priest.
But the rubrics mandate that *everyone* pray the Our Father, and also that the priest use the Orans posture, and this is a contradiction in the symbolism of the Mass. That is why some people read the symbolism to say we can stand like the priest because he isn’t doing anything specifically priestly, and others say that he is, and we must not.
To be clear, the confusion is not the fault of the laity on either side of the question. The rubrics are wrong, and should be modified, either for the people to stop praying the Our Father aloud, or for the priest to stop using the Orans posture for it.
Yes, the rubrics should be changed. The Celebrant at the Novus Ordo should not use the organs gesture, since he is not explicitly praying the Pater Noster on behalf of the people, but joins them in a communal recitation. Either that, or the people should be told to remain silent–as at the Traditional Latin Mass –so the Celebrant may pray on their behalf with his outstretched arms.
Whether the rest of the Church shall decide on uniformity by following The Portland Archdiocese or whether confusing diversity (e.g., Philippines) will continue, one thing seems clear to me: the rubrics should be changed to eliminate the Celebrant’s use of the Orans during the Our Father at the Novus Ordo, since he does not pray the Pater Noster “on behalf of the Faithful” but joins the Faithful in the communal recitation of the prayer. This point was made a long time ago by Canonist Ed Peters. https://catholicexchange.com/another-look-at-the-orans-issue/
Dr Peter Kwasniewski has made it as well.
The rubrics do not require change. In the Ordinary form of the Mass the priest and the whole congregation pray the Our Father together as one body as Jesus Himself instructed. Therefore it is reasonable that they all raise their hands in the ancient Biblical gesture of prayer.
Wow! talk about confussion. It is very simple, Mary said,” Let be done to me according to your word”. It seems that Dr. Martin and few others are saying, ” Lord, I do it my way not yours”.
Should we tell Jesus how to run His Church? Better yet, let us follow His Teachings. Obedience is the path to heaven. Disobedience leads us where?