In 2020, I wrote a column about wokeness, the view that group inequalities are intolerable evils, caused solely by institutionalized bigotry, that must urgently be extirpated. I said that its ambition and moralism allow no independent authorities or standards, and that made it a danger to the Church and Faith.
Since then, things appear to have moderated. The Trump administration has moved against DEI requirements. The Supreme Court has come out against a basic pillar of academic affirmative action programs, the use of race as a criterion in admissions. Even Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez now says that “Woke 1 was crazy.”
But have things really changed? The recent Jason Arday affair, which displays the continuing power of woke considerations in elite British academia—that is, among recognized custodians of the West’s highest intellectual aspirations—suggests that ultimately things have not changed much at all.
That seems right. The current understanding of justice demands that equal individuals and groups end up in equal positions. With that in mind, “wokeness” is a direct consequence of the egalitarian view that group differences do not contribute significantly to economic and social inequalities. On that view, an inequality like differences in the average pay of men and women is a systemic injustice that must be done away with.
It is very difficult to avoid that logic in today’s public life. Advancing the self-interest of each individual is what politics in a democratic consumer society claims to be about. In such a setting, how many politicians, who must offer something to everyone, are going to succeed for long by arguing that inequalities should not be addressed? Or saying the reason some groups don’t hold as many prestigious and lucrative positions is that they don’t have what it takes and don’t deserve them?
If someone in public life tries to oppose woke logic less confrontationally, and points out that statistical averages don’t imply much about individuals, or that diversity means people are different, different people pursue and excel at different things, and career success is not human worth, or if he just notes that everyone gains when the most capable and committed are allowed to succeed, he can be dismissed as an apologist for racism, sexism, white Christian nationalism, and so on. And if he calls for moderation and recognition of limits, he can be accused of criminal indifference stemming from a position of privilege.
Today, such polemical assertions have mostly given way to attacks on Donald Trump and his supporters. MAGA will end, though, and then people are likely to return to those polemics with renewed energy. Current trends in the Democratic Party certainly suggest as much. Some will once again find wokeness a source of easy moral superiority. Others will be good-hearted people who believe what recognized social authorities tell them and want to do the right thing.
And some will be politicians who draw political advantage from inflammatory woke rhetoric: in a mass democracy, ordinary people have little personal reason to care about public issues, so politicians are perpetually tempted to appeal to hatred, envy, resentment, and fear as motivators.
The most basic problem, though, is that our betters tend to be woke, at least in basic principle. The Pope himself suggests that equality is much more important than the sexual morality that has been a basic Christian concern since apostolic times. Nor is that just a one-off comment. Magnifica Humanitas, par. 79, calls for various forms of reparation in view of the continuing consequences of past exclusions and discriminations. These consequences will inevitably be held to include all present differences in outcome. So the paragraph can easily be read to support the whole woke agenda.
Such attitudes are natural under the present circumstances. The public necessity of espousing egalitarianism has caused it to take deep root in governmental and educational bureaucracies, and in the business bureaucracies that operate in the intellectual, cultural, and legal environment they create. People in responsible positions are required to speak in favor of it, and that becomes easier if they accept it as true. It also gains support from the technocratic tendency to understand people as interchangeable components in a global economic machine.
If wokeness is the natural consequence of propositions every respectable person agrees with publicly—and usually privately—what is wrong with it? Human affairs are infinitely complicated—and it may be that egalitarianism is ultimately correct. Certainly, it’s unlikely ever to be refuted to general satisfaction. So, in view of the sensitivity of the issue, most educated, intelligent, and well-intentioned people think it should be assumed true. What other view is possible in a diverse and prosperous mass democracy?
If something is viewed as an injustice, it seems something ought to be done about it. But there’s a practical problem in this case: differences in outcome are pervasive, and often large and resistant to change. What, exactly, are we supposed to do about them?
Jews, for example, are only 0.2% of the global population, but have received more than 20% of all Nobel prizes. What could—or should—be done about that? And there is the question of who gets blamed for crimes. FBI figures from 2025 attribute 88.5% of U.S. homicides to men, 55.3% to African Americans. Both percentages are grossly disproportionate. Does that mean the police should pursue Asian-American women much more than they do, since apparently they only arrest 10 or 20 of them a year for homicide?
Nor are such percentages improving from an egalitarian point of view. The proportion of Jewish Nobelists increased somewhat in this century. And during the height of the Black Lives Matter movement, the figures on black homicide became considerably worse both comparatively and absolutely.
There don’t seem to be many sensible and moderate measures that can much change such disparities. During the past 40 years, for example, attempts to close gaps in educational achievement have scored few successes. But when intended remedies fail, people turn to more radical ones. So extreme and even insane measures get seriously proposed, and in many cases pursued, by people in responsible positions: abolition of academic and scholarly standards, as in the Arday case, and radical weakening of the criminal justice system, through decriminalization, failure to prosecute, and serious proposals to abolish prisons and police.
The basic problem is that wokeness requires perpetual revolution, a continuing Year Zero that insists on endlessly reconstructing all social relations to achieve the ever-receding goal of equality. That process may proceed quickly or slowly, depending on the strength of the obstacles and resistance it meets. But given the logic of public thought, it’s hard to see why it should stop.
All this is part of what I’ve called Babel, the attempt to create a universal self-contained structure that promises to satisfy all human aspirations in accordance with the modern secular understanding of social justice. The attempt will inevitably fail, since the world goes its own way—and resists and often punishes attempts to make it do what we want. But it seems impossible to give it up because in a secular society, that would mean giving up hope in the midst of a very unsatisfactory world.
We have seen in the communist countries the ultimate result of making utopian dreams the basis of politics: a regime that covers the abject failure of its ambitions through tyranny, lies, corruption, and suppression of all honest discussion. That seems worth avoiding. So what can Catholics do to help modern politics get out of the black hole into which it is falling?
What would help, I think, is to weaken the dehumanizing obsession with wealth, power, equality, and the project of intentional social reconstruction. There are more important things, like carrying on a good life ourselves and in cooperation with the people with whom we are connected. If something like extreme poverty is blocking that for some people, that’s a serious concern. But is that true of equality as such, when ensuring it requires constant top-down interference with all human relationships?
With that in mind, the Church should break her growing alliance with secular visions of utopia, which have nothing to do with her mission as historically understood. Instead, she needs to present a more realistic picture of man as flawed and limited, and of society as a multilevel, multi-centered, and extremely complex growth rather than a construction.
She also needs to present a vision of man as a being not limited to this world, and of the good life as something more complex and sustaining than a life of equal satisfaction carried on within a managed global order. If such views became widespread, politics would have a chance of becoming once again something other than an endless fight over who gets what.
Only the Church has the intellectual and spiritual resources to do that in a world that desperately needs it. If she wants to contribute to social improvement, why isn’t that the obvious way to do so?
If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!
Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.

Please, for the love of God, Father, Son and Holy Spirit, let us stop placing labels on everyone, everything so as to either support or seek to diminish every person, idea and action.
Let us love God with all of our heart, all of our soul, all of our strength and to hold that in our conscious thoughts continually.
Let us love our neighbors as ourselves or better than we love ourselves.
Let us seek to serve God by our stewardship of His creation.
Let that be our justice just as salvation through Christ, in unity with the Father and the Holy Spirit, is our hope.
Things often seem difficult enough without our seeking to make them more so.
Yours in Christ,
I’m not sure how your remarks are to be applied.
Discussing the world requires us to name various aspects of it, and politics requires us to assess the value of ideas and actions, and favor or disfavor what various persons are doing.
It’s true that few saints have been much involved in politics, but most Catholics, especially today, believe it’s a legitimate and even necessary pursuit. (FWIW, I’ve written about the difficulty of making sense of that situation.)
Exactly so…
First this: “…the Council wishes to recall first of all the permanent binding force of universal natural law and its all-embracing principles. Man’s conscience itself gives ever more emphatic voice to these principles. ..” (Gaudium et Spes, GS, n.79).
And then: “The Christian who neglects his temporal duties neglects his duties toward his neighbor and even God, and jeopardizes his eternal salvation (GS, n. 43).
And, yet: “The role and competence of the Church being what it is, she must in no way be confused with the political community, nor bound to any political system. For she is at once a sign and a safeguard of the transcendence of the human person” (GS, n. 76).
Thusly, the layman is to “exercise his apostolate in the world as a kind of leaven. The laity derive the right and duty with respect to his apostolate from their union with Christ their head. Incorporated into Christ’s Mystical Body through baptism and strengthened by the power of the Holy Spirit through confirmation, they are assigned to the apostolate by the Lord himself (decree on the Apostolate of the Laity, n. 3).
With NUMERICAL JUSTICE firmly in mind, then, might we insist that there will be no justice in the world until both brain lobes are equally represented! That is, left-handers (the intuitive right side of the brain with spatial and cross-boundary awareness, creativity) are awarded HALF of all government offices and cubicles, while right-handers (the calculating left side with logic, analytical thinking, and compartmentalization into silo offices and office cubicles!) are restricted to only half…or less!
The current ratio probably mirrors the general population at 85 to 15 in the left-lobe direction! The injustice of it all! Cain was surely right-handed!
“Please, for the love of God, Father, Son and Holy Spirit, let us stop placing labels on everyone, everything so as to either support or seek to diminish every person, idea and action.”
Right after the left stops labelling.
We just need AI to incorporate these terms a revised version of Julie Andrews singing about “favorite things”.
Supremacist
Nazi
Fascist
Billionaire
MAGA (as a pejorative)
Progressive (as a euphemism for unimpeded and unlimited state power)
Mansplainer
Islamophobe
Transphobe
Misogynist
Religious Fanatic
Affirmative Action can get rather silly. Perhaps we need more Left handed lesbians of color to be country music stars? Maybe more Asians in the NBA? Maybe more Asian women who commit homicides?
Never thought I’d see the day of unequivocal agreement with you. The constant search to identity imagined inequalities is most often a means to adopt causes dishonestly, to avoid finding real fault in ourselves while feeling superior for doing so.
The University of California Berkeley and UCLA have discriminated against Asians in admissions because they are so strong academically. The administration say that they have to do this because if they didn’t, the classes would be mostly Asian. So what?
This reminds me of when my son graduated from law school, much of the class was Jewish, even though Jews are perhaps 2% of the population. Again, so what?
Social engineering is silly, unfair and doomed to failure.
Wokeness can be understood as a form of Christian heresy. Like many heresies, it takes a genuine Christian truth and overemphasizes it at the expense of other truths and realities. In this case, wokeness rightly emphasizes compassion for the oppressed, but does so at the expense of other virtues, particularly justice. Christian virtue requires balance: one virtue should never be pursued in isolation from the others. Most importantly, wokeness ignores the source of all truth and justice, namely God.
Rather than the Church having a “growing alliance with secular visions of utopia,” maybe what we have is simply a hangover from an overdose of the neo-Kantian theologian Karl Rahner?
The dolled-up ancient heresy of MONISM (the lost difference between the Creator and His distinct creation)? This charade, followed by a gaggle of pseudo-theologians who can’t tell the difference between the living memory of the Church (the Magisterium) and themselves. And, who therefore insinuate strategic and gradualist word games to more fully obscure what’s left of reality? (Do “Fiducia Supplicans” and then Synodal Study Group #9 come to mind, if there still is a mind?)
A real theologian, Ratzinger/Benedict, made this observation about Rahner:
“Rahner … says that ‘salvation history is coexistent with the totality of human history [….] For Rahner, man is, in fact, self-transcendent being; hence the God-man can be deduced as the true Savior of mankind in terms of man’s own being: the Incarnation of God is the highest instance of the ontological fulfillment of human reality, the successful, perfect instance of transcendence [….] Ultimately, then, a synthesis that combines being and history in a single, compelling logic of the understanding becomes, by the universality of its claim, a philosophy of necessity, even though this necessity is then explained as a process of freedom [….]
“[….] This means, in turn, that man does not find salvation in a reflective finding of himself but in the being-taken-out-of-himself that goes beyond reflection—not in continuing to be himself, but in going out from himself”[….] Such a philosophy of freedom and love is, at the same time, a philosophy of conversion, of going out from oneself, of transformation [….which] has its foundation in the mystery of God, which is freedom and which, therefore, calls each individual [!] by name that is known to no other” (“Faith and History,” in “Principles of Catholic Theology”, Ignatius, 1987).
“Monism” instead of derived secular utopias? Yours truly isn’t any kind of theologian, so who am I to judge?
Logical fallacy is the root of Woke. That justice prevails when everyone shares the same wealth, opportunities, advancement. Illogical because not everyone shares the same capabilities. Let us say native intelligence, competency.
Jews I dare to say, that minute .02 of world populace are, due to historical, yes divine intervention cultured to think, to reason the mysteries of life, of good in comparison to evil. For thousands of years since Abram.
Wokeness will disappear when the woke realize there are innate differences. But the problem is at this stage of history they’re too dim.
As for me and mine we will stay woke.
1 Thessalonians 4:6, “So then let us not sleep, as others do, but let us keep awake and be sober.”
Once again the non-reader, the non-comprehensive reader, ranks himself at or below the sixth-grade level in reading proficiency.
In typing, took, the sixth grader errs.
The failure to understand scripture and the lack of gifts of the Holy Spirit reveals both a simple and great deficiency.
Some woke persons ought to hide their ignorance, especially when the light does clearly shine.
What on earth are you banging on about now?
Once again you show your ignorance and inability to comprehend the written word.
I play the piano, not the drum. The banging sounds you hear are those of your brainwaves.
As an avid reader of scripture I can assure you that when Jesus asks us to stay awake, He means maintaining spiritual alertness and readiness. I will therefore stay woke – alert and ready despite the devil using others to bully me into slumber. Pax Christi
Oh, Gerard, you’re so morally superior to everyone now aren’t you. Thanks for letting us know youre an avid reader of scripture. But one thing’s for certain – you really are woke (and vapid as well)
There’s millions of people that are avid readers of Scripture and are fine exemplars of the Bard’s injunction about the devil quoting Scripture to suit his own ends.
So yoo’ve never encountered an ironic abuse of language and never given any thought as to why people thump their chest over virtues that do not exist?
If you’re serious about scripture, you might consider the hundreds of condemnations of pride it contains.
I’ve encountered it and counter it by reclaiming words for good. To be awake and aware is to be woke. You can be dull and lulled to sleep in an echo chamber of imagined persecution if you wish.
Returning words for good? When do your alignments condemn “woke” ideology for promoting its crimes against humanity? It’s Orwellian abuses of language to call evil good and good evil? It’s promotion of such things as genital mutilation of children as a right of children. It’s promotion of baby slaughter as health care. It’s promotion of terrorism as freedom fighting? The list is endless, since the sins of the self-important are endless.
Returning words for good? When do your expressed alignments condemn “woke” ideology for promoting its crimes against humanity? Or condemn its Orwellian abuses of language to call evil good and good evil? Or its promotion of such things as genital mutilation of children as a right of children? Or its promotion of baby slaughter as health care? Or its promotion of terrorism as freedom fighting? The list is endless, since the sins of the self-important without self-awareness are endless.
“The Pope himself suggests that equality is much more important than the sexual morality that has been a basic Christian concern since apostolic times”.
J.M.J.
No doubt, a “woke” statement that denies God’s Divine Will and thus God’s Divine Law, that we respect the Sanctity and Dignity of the marital act within The Sacrament of Holy Matrimony, and thus respect God’s Divine Will and thus God’s Divine Law that we respect The Sanctity and Dignity of every beloved son or daughter from the moment of conception.
We, The Faithful, can know through both Faith and Reason, that the sole purpose of this woke statement is to exchange The Truth Of God’s Divine Will and thus God’s Divine Law, with a lie, in order to make it appear that God Wills the equality of sexual acts and sexual relationships, and thus God denies the equality of the Sanctity and Dignity of all human life, which, in denying The Essence Of Perfect Divine Eternal Infinite Trinitarian Love, denies God’s Divine Will, And God’s Divine Law, and is thus, in essence, an act of Apostasy.
How , then, is it possible for a man, who, in essence, denies The Divinity of The Most Holy Blessed Trinity, God, The Father, His Only Begotten Son, And The Holy Ghost, The Spirit Of Perfect Divine Eternal Infinite Complementary Love Between The Father And His Only Begotten Son, Jesus The Christ, Who Proceeds From Both The Father And His Only Begotten Son, Jesus The Christ, to have both the ability and desire to accept The “forever” Office of the MUNUS, and thus The Ministerial Office if that man has, in fact, defected from Christ’s Church , by denying The Divine Essence Of The Ordered Communion Of The Perfect Divine Eternal Infinite Love Of The Most Holy Blessed Trinity?
We, The Faithful, who no longer are sleeping in Gethsemane, know through both Faith and reason, grounded in The Deposit of Faith, “The Holy Spirit was not promised to the successors of Peter that by His revelation they might make known new doctrine, but that by His assistance they might inviolably keep and faithfully expound the Revelation, the Deposit of Faith, delivered through the Apostles. ”
A troublesome one-liner, but even Aquinas regarded lust as less grievous than other capital sins in that it’s at the level that humans share with animals, and therefore less serious than spiritual sins.
SPIRITUAL SINS might include intellectual self-deceptions and stylish theological abuses, say, those dished out by many prominent clerics. Those who would market Liberation Theology—or maybe the broader “principle of gradualism” to legitimize exemptions from the binding force of universal natural law and moral absolutes, e.g., by obscuring Catechism and Veritatis Splendor with the plasticity of “experience” (synodal Study Group #9).
ON THE OTHER HAND, do we not recall from the seers at Fatima that most souls who find their way into the abyss of hell do so through sexual sins? Possibly because lust seems to be the gateway sin (!) into the other capital sins (lust: but then pride, greed, anger, gluttony, envy, sloth).
“Everything [!] is connected” as we learn even in Laudato Si!
MIGHT IT BE that Pope Leo XIV’s accurate sense of “equality” refers to equality of personal dignity rather than conflated with equality of economic outcomes? The verbose “Magnifica Humanitas” (42,604 words) is from the hand of the Argentinian Cardinal Fernandez and might also be criticized for conflating human dignity with the infinite dignity of God.
Red hats would better serve the new pope by reading the American non-theologian Mark Twain: “The difference between the almost right word and the right word is really a large matter—’tis the difference between the lightning bug and the lightning.”
For clarity, my reference to Cardinal Fernandez’s “conflating human dignity with the infinite dignity of God” applies to his “Dignitas Infinita” (April 2024).
“The durability of wokeness”
I think we should cease with the euphemisms. We need to see the current (and all past) struggles as fundamentally Good (Virtue) v. Evil (Sin). Once we stop sugar-coating what we face, the sooner we can employ strategies to encourage one and eliminate the other.
I used to think that “wokness” was the problem. It’s not that I think otherwise now but realize that we have a more fundamental struggle at hand which is Good (Virtue) vs Evil (Sin).
We Catholics need to stop pussy-footing around what ails us. Name things for what they are. Call out evil when you see it and name those engaged in it. In similar manner, call out Virtue where you see it as well.
Has the Liturgy ‘gone woke’ of late? Today, the Feast of Our Lady of Victory, now ignominiously called Our Lady of the Rosary. Is it due to fear of upsetting Turkish sensibilities? Would Erdoğan protest?
Wokeness is apparently infectious. Fundamentally it’s the reluctance to be honest about ourselves and the world.
The name was changed over 100 years ago. Stop being so paranoid.
Not so fast. Wokeism’s roots are far more ancient than a hundred years or so. In 1573, Pope Gregory XIII changed the original title, the Feast of Our Lady of Victory instituted by his faithful predecessor Saint Pope Pius V in 1571, to Feast of the Holy Rosary. A testament to Wokeism’s durability.
If it’s not too late please omit my response to Gerard.
Too funny, father.
People are equal only in the following:
They belong to the same species, man: rational animal.
They are called to the same end/good, eternal union with God: infinite goodness.
In all other respects: physical size/strength, beauty, temperament, intelligence, etc. they are *unequal.*
And of course, they are also unequal in the order of actual accomplishment. Some people actualize and exercise their talents better than others.
This is true in the case of individuals, and it is also true in the case of groups. No two groups have ever been perfectly equal in the order of actual performance.
This is so in the history of the nations.
The Greek people excelled the peoples from the West coast of africa.
The Greeks built a flourishing civilization. The West Africans did not.
In this sense, the Greeks are better than the West Africans.
Human Inequality is OK. It is just, it is part of the flow of life, of activity and history.
Honor should be accorded to those individuals and nations who perform acts of virtue/excellence.
Honor should not be accorded to those individuals and nations who do not perform acts of virtue/excellence.
The inability/unwillingness of authorities in Church and State to recognize this and speak well on this issue is one of the reasons for the endurance of the emotional/sentimental false identification of injustice with those normal and appropriate inequalities which flow from the inequality of talents and the application of those talents.
A fine article from Mr. Kalb.
Jesus preferred the weak and “less” excellent. So there is that.
An interesting issue.
He compared himself to a physician whose mission was to the sick rather than the healthy. So it seems he wanted to heal and make strong. And his call to leave everything and follow him demanded the heroism eventually displayed by the apostles.
The usual view is that grace perfects nature and that natural goods are true goods. So it seems that Christianity would favor all forms of human excellence. How practically you combine that with concern for the weak isn’t always obvious.
Jesus loves the humble.
Humility is a virtue, an *excellence.*
In this sense, a humble person *really is better* than a proud person
In this sense also, a group of humble people, like repentant tax collectors, are really better than a group of proud people, like the scribes and pharisees.
Wokeism inverts Christian doctrine by celebrating/valorizing *vices* (e.g., pride, laziness, poor diction, anger, lust, rudeness, incompetence, etc.), especially if they are found within certain groups favored by the American progressive elite.
My inclination is to say that humility is acceptance that you are not the standard, that God is the standard, and that others are just as real as you are. So it is plainly a strength because it is acceptance of reality.
Wokeness I think gets rid of God and wants to make each person an absolute standard. That’s unworkable as a practical and thus political matter, so it emphasizes the divinity of the people who seem least to be standards (and of the people who tell us how to be woke).
The result is scapegoating of the people who have generally set the standard. They’re the source of all the problems. So it’s a sort of Nazism of anti-Nazism. Master and subhuman remain in a nihilistic world in which there is only power, but their places are reversed.
Such anyway seems the tendency.