By The Legislature “can leave it up to a vote of the people” if it does not want to abolish capital punishment outright, the governor said.
Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine said this week that the state should end the death penalty, with the governor arguing that he no longer believes it is a “deterrent” to murder.
“I believe Ohio should abolish the death penalty,” the Catholic Republican governor said at a June 16 press conference. “The Legislature can take this action, and I believe they should take this action.”
“But if the Legislature does not want to make that decision, they can leave it up to a vote of the people of the state of Ohio,” he said.
After DeWine was elected to the state Senate in 1980, he co-sponsored a bill that sought to reinstate the death penalty in Ohio.
DeWine supported the policy at the time believing it would lessen violent crime, he said at the press conference, but, he argued, “the moral justification I had for voting for the death penalty simply no longer exists.”
Each decade that the death penalty has been in effect, “the chances of a murderer getting executed get more and more remote,” DeWine said. Therefore, “it is today impossible to make the case that the death penalty is a deterrent.”
“For the state to take a human life, there … must be evidence that in doing so, it will help protect the public [and] that the threat of that action will deter someone from committing murder,” he said.
“I do not believe that argument today can be successfully made, nor do I believe that thereʼs any chance [of successfully making it] in the future,” he said.
The term-limited governor, whose second term will end in 2027, has repeatedly postponed scheduled executions in the state since taking office in early 2019.
He has cited issues involving “the willingness of pharmaceutical suppliers to provide drugs to the Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Correction, pursuant to DRC protocol, without endangering other Ohioans.”
“We also cannot talk about capital punishment without talking about those we task with carrying it out,” DeWine said.
“While it is true they are ‘volunteers,’ we still must be mindful of the impact preparations for and the carrying out of executions have on them. They are the forgotten people — but they are real people. They are our fellow Ohioans.”
DeWine used the example of Gary Mohr, who served as the director of the state Department of Rehabilitation and Corrections from 2011 until 2018.
“During that time, he supervised 15 executions,” DeWine said, and he “summarize[d] the toll on the staff in this one sentence: ‘The heaviness felt by the execution team and by the support staff is indescribable.’”
“Our money and our energies are much better spent focusing on keeping these repeat violent offenders out of society than focusing on the death penalty,” DeWine said.
“Throughout my career, Iʼve always stated that the most important way to protect the public is to lock up violent criminals and to keep them out of society. Keep them locked up. That is a proven way of saving lives and protecting our citizens.”
DeWine said that any “decision to officially end the death penalty in Ohio could not change the horror and the anger that we all feel in regard to these murderers, nor the deep sorrow we feel for the victims and for their families.”
“These murderers ended the life of a precious human being. These murderers have changed the lives of the surviving family members forever. Their lives will never be the same.”
During a question-and-answer session at the press conference, DeWine declined to comment when asked if he would begin commuting death sentences in the state.
Praise from Catholic anti-death penalty group
DeWine’s “call for the abolishment of capital punishment in Ohio is an encouraging sign and reflects growing recognition that the state can move toward a more just and life-affirming approach,” Krisanne Vaillancourt Murphy, the executive director of the anti-death penalty Catholic Mobilizing Network, told EWTN News.
“Gov. DeWine is a Catholic whose faith has always inspired his public service,” Vaillancourt said.
“As fellow Catholics who advocate for the dignity of every human life, we urge him to go further and grant clemency to those on Ohio’s death row. The time to act is now,” she said.
If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!
Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.
It’s a very problematic question, but in the classic understanding such as found in Aquinas and later St Alphonso Liguri, the realisation of ones death focuses the mind worthy, as Dr Johnson observe. Numerous conversations have occurred throughout history: the Venerable Jacques fesch, the murderer prayed for by St Therese whose solidarity kiss of the cross was enough in the saint eyes of God’s mercy being granted, and Claude Newman, whose time on death row was a time of miracles and conversations through Our Lady’s intercession all point to the value of execution. Yes that seems horrible but if I were in that position, I wouldn’t waste a moment but embrace the mercy given to me.
Since recent popes have made such hash of Church teaching on this matter, perhaps we shouldn’t be too harsh in our treatment of a mediocre politician like DeWine when he follows their lead. On second thought, there’s no reason to think his motives are noble. He is just looking for liberal accolades as he slouches off into the sunset after a long and thoroughly undistinguished career.
Another one of Tessa’s cheerleading puff pieces.
“Each decade that the death penalty has been in effect, “the chances of a murderer getting executed get more and more remote,” DeWine said. Therefore, “it is today impossible to make the case that the death penalty is a deterrent.””
Observations:
In other words, murderers can engage in economic calculation. Just because capital punishment exists de jure, doesn’t mean it exists de facto exists.
As the article noted, he’s failing the one failing to exercise the law. This is a little like a bus driver claiming the bus is inoperative because he’s obstructing its operation, instead of turning the key, engaging the transmission and releasing the brakes.
Since he has made us aware that the death penalty is in a state of disuse, what exactly is the need to remove it from the Ohio legal codex? Meanwhile how many thousands of unborn are summarily executed without any question and a shrug from politicians like DeWine.
“Throughout my career, Iʼve always stated that the most important way to protect the public is to lock up violent criminals and to keep them out of society. Keep them locked up. That is a proven way of saving lives and protecting our citizens.”
Career indeed. This parasite has been on the dole since 1980. A lot of people born in and since 1980 have concluded their life on earth. He is removed from reality. Now, newsflash Mike. “lock up” doesn’t solve the problem of violence, it merely isolates it. Correctional facilities have citizens that deserve protection as well. Corrections officers and other inmates don’t need the additional danger posed by the most violent predators. Incarceration will always create the risk of miseries (physical assault and sodomy) caused by other inmates, but it should be mitigated.
“For the state to take a human life, there … must be evidence that in doing so, it will help protect the public ”
Would that be the state that materially cooperates with the summary execution of tens of thousands of innocent children for the crime of being incovenient?
If this author was doing anything other than being a clapping seal, she’d be looking into DeWine’s campaign contributions and seeing if the soon to be octogenarian is looking for a corporate board seat when he leaves office next year.
The citizens of Ohio need to stop putting this sort of career Republican in office, but DeWine is just the latest version of John (crybaby Speaker of the House turned pot peddler) Boehner and John “did you know my father was a mailman” Kasich and former Senator Rob Portman. All arrogant and sanctimonious.
Gerard, I’ve noticed the extra “exists”.