Pope Francis: ‘The Church is not a political organization that has left and right wings’

Courtney Mares   By Courtney Mares for CNA


Pope Francis meets with Vatican journalists on Nov. 13, 2021. / Vatican Media/CNA

Vatican City, Nov 13, 2021 / 11:30 am (CNA).

Pope Francis told Vatican journalists on Saturday to remember that the Catholic Church is not a political organization or a multinational company, but that “the Church exists to bring the word of Jesus to the world and to make possible today an encounter with the living Jesus.”

In a meeting with veteran Vatican journalists on Nov. 13, the pope urged the importance of on-the-ground reporting and in-person interviews to communicate the truth. He also offered an explanation of what the Church is and what it is not.

“Please, remember also that the Church is not a political organization with left and right wings, as is the case in parliaments. At times, unfortunately, our considerations are reduced to this, with some root in reality. But no, the Church is not this,” Pope Francis said.

“It is not a large multinational company headed by managers who study at the table how best to sell their product. The Church does not build itself on the basis of its own project, it does not draw from itself the strength to move forward and it does not live by marketing strategies.”

The pope described the Church as “a vehicle” to bring the mercy of Christ to the world.

“The Church, composed of men and women who are sinners like everyone else, was born and exists to reflect the light of Another, the light of Jesus, just as the moon does with the sun,” he said.

Pope Francis spoke at a ceremony in which he conferred the title of “Knight” and “Dame” of the Grand Cross of the Order of Pope Pius upon Vatican reporters Philip Pullella and Valentina Alazraki.

Vatican Media
Vatican Media

Alazraki has reported from more than 150 flights on the papal plane. The Mexican journalist for Noticieros Televisa has covered five pontificates as a Vatican correspondent. Pullella has served as a correspondent for Reuters in Rome since 1983.

Pullella has said that his approach to covering the Vatican is to cover it as an institution like the United Nations or the White House.

“My rule on covering the Vatican is to take religion out of the story whenever possible,” Pullella said in an interview with Reuters in 2018.

Vatican Media
Vatican Media

The pope described journalism as not simply a profession, but a mission “to explain the world.”

He encouraged journalists to escape “from the tyranny of always being online,” to get out from behind their computer screens, in order to encounter and communicate reality.

“We need journalists who are willing to ‘wear out the soles of their shoes,’ to get out of the newsroom, to walk around the city, to meet people, to assess the situations in which we live in our time,” Pope Francis said.

“For a journalist, listening means having the patience to meet face to face with the people to be interviewed … the sources from which to receive news. Listening always goes hand in hand with seeing, with being present: certain nuances, sensations, and well-rounded descriptions can only be conveyed to readers, listeners and spectators if the journalist has listened and seen for him – or herself,” he said.


The pope’s comments came just over two weeks after Vatican journalists protested the lack of access to report on President Joe Biden’s meeting with Francis firsthand.

After journalists were already barred from having a pool representative present for the initial handshake, the Vatican also abruptly canceled its scheduled live broadcast of the meeting without explanation.

The Associated Press reported that it had formally complained to the Vatican about the canceled live stream, along with members of the Vatican correspondents’ association. The president of the White House Correspondents’ Association declared the group’s solidarity with Vatican reporters in expressing disappointment with the lack of transparency.

“Every piece of news, every fact we talk about, every reality we describe needs to be investigated,” Pope Francis said.

“At a time when millions of pieces of information are available on the web, and when many people obtain their information and form their opinions on social media, where unfortunately the logic of simplification and opposition sometimes prevails, the most important contribution that good journalism can make is that of in-depth analysis.”

If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!

Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.

About Catholic News Agency 10594 Articles
Catholic News Agency (www.catholicnewsagency.com)


  1. “Every piece of news, every fact we talk about, every reality we describe needs to be investigated” (Pope Francis). Well, your Holiness, that’s precisely what points to your silence on President Biden’s assertion that you affirmed his Catholicism and agreed he should continue to receive the Eucharist. It certainly is not a private matter. Biden has made a public statement that you have the obligation to refute, if his claim is untrue. Your silence is divisive. Silence that is de jure agreement with President Biden’s words dividing those who follow previous papal documents, long standing Church doctrine, canon law – from those within the Church, Cardinals Tobin, Cupich Gregory, Farrell, and a host of bishops. Live up to your words and guide the Church. Dual messaging from a pontiff is duplicitous if not corrected, and certainly fosters division. A matter that touches the heart of Church belief and practice, the Eucharist must be addressed definitively and with clarity. That requires genuine clear leadership regarding the present Synod addressing Eucharistic cohesion, which is not a question of private conscientiousness, or a consensus of views. You must affirm the faith.

  2. I confess to not reading past the headline where Francis appears sans ventements. He has completely mastered the art of sandbagging, has he not?

  3. “Every piece of news, every fact we talk about, every reality we describe needs to be investigated,” Pope Francis said.

    I agree. Very of ten, we rely on columnists or blog writers to give us their opinions, but fail to check the truth for ourselves. I was once a critic of Pope Francis, but when I realized that some Catholic websites were badly conditioning my views, I amended my writings. It happened with the Pachamama, the “who am I to judge?” episode, the placing of some papal titles in footnotes in one document, in the Biden affair and so on. I, for one, do not seek clarification from the Pope regarding Biden’s boast, because the Pope made his views abundantly clear on the matter. Those who support abortion excommunicate themselves and so should not receive communion, he said.
    Hundreds of people say things about the Pope that are not true, and I do not expect him to rush to the press to contradict such people. His mission is to teach, and that he does very well.

2 Trackbacks / Pingbacks

  1. Pope Francis: ‘The Church is not a political organization that has left and right wings’ – Via Nova Media
  2. Pope Francis: ‘The Church is not a political organization that has left and right wings’ – Catholic World Report – The Old Roman

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

All comments posted at Catholic World Report are moderated. While vigorous debate is welcome and encouraged, please note that in the interest of maintaining a civilized and helpful level of discussion, comments containing obscene language or personal attacks—or those that are deemed by the editors to be needlessly combative or inflammatory—will not be published. Thank you.