Dante and the glory of God in man

At any given time, Christ’s call to perfection is received by two groups of Catholics: those for whom the call to holiness is a relatively “new” teaching and those who have heard about this call already.

Dante Alighieri shown holding a copy of the "Divine Comedy" next to the entrance to Hell, the seven terraces of Mount Purgatory, and the city of Florence, with the spheres of Heaven above, in Domenico di Michelino's 1465 fresco. (Image: Jastrow/Wikipedia)

The Divine Comedy of Dante Alighieri (c 1265-1321), who died 700 years ago this year, takes the poet on an epic journey from earth to the utter depths of hell, on a long climb up Mount Purgatory (Dante envisioned Purgatory as a mountain), and finally through each successive ring of heaven, moving inward until the climactic moment when he stands before Almighty God.

I do not think I need to call this a “spoiler alert.” I mean, the poem has been around for seven centuries now. Anyone who has not yet read it probably will not mind if I give away the ending. In any case, Dante stands before Almighty God, Whom he sees, first as an infinitely brilliant light, then as a united set of three rings—signifying the Holy Trinity, and then as a single, perfect circle—symbolizing the love of God by which God’s Son came to save us and which is the first defining reality of God. As St. John tells us, “God is love” (I John 4:8). Dante finishes his poem with these words, explaining his inability to go any further in describing God’s majesty:

But mine were not the feathers for that flight,
Save that the truth I longed for came to me,
Smiting my mind like lightning flashing bright.
Here ceased the powers of my high fantasy.
Already were all my will and my desires
Turned—as a wheel in equal balance—by
The love that moves the sun and other stars. (Paradise, Canto XXXIII)

As much as any scene in literature, painting, or any other art form, the final cantos (or sections) of the Divine Comedy help us to appreciate God’s unfathomable holiness and majesty. And Dante’s poetry gives our minds a picture, inadequate as any picture wrought by man must be, of what Jesus means when he refers to the perfection of God in the Sermon on the Mount. “Be perfect, just as your heavenly Father is perfect” (Matthew 5:48).

Any sane person will find himself a bit startled the first time he realizes that Jesus juxtaposes His followers and the perfection of His heavenly Father. What have ordinary disciples to do with such holiness as God’s? Yet Jesus not only mentions His disciples in the same sentence, but does the seemingly unthinkable—He tells us to be like God in holiness: “Be perfect, just as your heavenly Father is perfect.”

We might be tempted to think this is some kind of mistake. But does not the Lord say in Leviticus 19:2, “Be holy, for I, the LORD, your God, am holy”? And is not Jesus’ command squarely in the middle of His Sermon On the Mount, which is basically an extended teaching about holiness? The kind of holiness no human could achieve on his own? The kind of holiness only possible for God? A holiness that makes a person meek, poor of spirit, able to suffer persecution, willing to make any sacrifice in order to avoid sin, loving not only to God and those who are easily loved, but also to strangers and even enemies?

At any given time, Christ’s call to perfection is received by two groups of Catholics: those for whom the call to holiness is a relatively “new” teaching and those who have heard about this call already.

Those for whom it is new have probably been present before when this text and similar texts were read at Mass, but it strikes them for the first time or in a new way. For these Catholics, the call of Jesus can seem to be too much. How could I possibly be like God? I who on the way to Sunday Mass argue with my husband or wife? I who often feel like prayer is a chore? I who am not even exactly sure what holiness would look like in the concrete circumstances of my life?

Those who have already heard about Christ’s call to perfection, perhaps under the title of the “universal call to holiness,” often have the opposite problem. They easily slip into thinking they have holiness all figured out. They may or may not think they have made much progress so far, but they at least know what they are doing. Or so they think.

It helps to meditate deeply upon the mystery of God’s holiness, no matter which of the two groups a given Catholic belongs to. For those who are intimidated by the idea that Jesus could be calling them to perfection, they are on the right track! No disciple has what it takes to become holy, left to his own devices.

Fortunately, God does not leave the faithful to their own devices. There is a gift each baptized Catholic has, a gift easily overlooked, but one that makes all the difference in the world when it comes to doing what Jesus asks of His disciples: the Gift of the Holy Spirit. A person intimidated by God’s majesty might as well go all the way and admit that God is so powerful and holy that He can even perform the miracle of making him holy. Such an admission would be a great start. As such disciples surrender their lives to Him each day, remaining docile to the indwelling and influence of the Holy Spirit, they would be poised to advance quickly on the path of holiness.

For those already familiar with the idea that all the faithful are called to holiness, the answer is really the same. All Catholics must beg for the Gift of the Holy Spirit to be renewed in them. They must pray to see the limits of their understanding. They must pray to stand in total awe of God’s holiness. In this way, they will become humble enough to allow God to do in them what they can never do by their own power: to live every word of the Sermon on the Mount.

There is another step on the path of holiness and divine perfection. One of the lessons of the Divine Comedy, rooted in the Sermon on the Mount and the other teachings of the Lord Jesus, is that holiness always has to do with others. In his depictions of the punishment of sinners and the glories of heaven, Dante treats with utmost seriousness the social dimension of holiness or its lack. Holiness is never merely a program of self-improvement. Christ commands His disciples to love their neighbors and pray for their enemies.

And while there are lots of ways to show Christ’s love or to pray for one’s enemies, what more could be done for other people than to help them to hear Christ’s call and to respond with all their hearts? What greater act of holy charity could Catholics perform than to let people know of the love God has for them—each of them—and to invite them to surrender their lives to that love as members of His Church? What greater goal of prayer and work could there be than such acts of loving surrender to Christ?

The holiness of Christ’s disciples does not lie dormant inside of them. It will come out, in word and action. Catholics have the tremendous blessing of bringing people closer to God and God closer to them.

In the final canto of the Divine Comedy, Dante offers a brief but incisive prayer:

Grant then to my tongue sufficient power
to leave the palest flicker of your glory
to readers of a later day and hour,
For should something return to memory
and sound but faintly in my verses here,
the clearer will they see your victory.

Dante knew that the transformation he experienced in his journey to God was not for him alone. He knew that to share his vision with others could transform their lives as well. May the God Who gives Himself in the Holy Eucharist make His disciples more and more like Him, that they might offer a despairing world at least the “palest flicker of (His) glory” and help defeated souls more clearly to “see (His) victory.”


If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!

Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.


About Fr. Charles Fox 57 Articles
Rev. Charles Fox is an assistant professor of theology at Sacred Heart Major Seminary, Detroit. He holds an S.T.D. in dogmatic theology from the Pontifical University of St. Thomas Aquinas (Angelicum), Rome. He is also chaplain and a board member of St. Paul Evangelization Institute, headquartered in Warren, MI.

3 Comments

  1. “…the man who cleanses his [own] heart of every created thing and every evil desire will see the image of the divine nature in the beauty of his own soul” (homily by St. Gregory of Nyssa, 335-395 A.D.).

    On this Solemnity of Mary, and recalling the Magnificat, we note the perfect beauty of Mary’s unencumbered “fiat”……If we can just DO that, that’s the thing.

  2. You must be perfect as your heavenly Father is perfect. Bastardized in liturgical reform as, You must be perfect[ed] as your heavenly Father is perfect. A Modernist shirk. Fr Fox’s, and indeed our challenge is we must be as perfect. “Any sane person will find himself a bit startled” . Fr Fox rightly focuses on perfecting the virtues. An insight into Dante’s poetic vision began earlier. Dante was a crusader. Third Crusade led by Richard the Lionhearted to reconquer the Holy Land. And recovery of the true cross. With his brother Francesco he slaughtered Muslim prisoners attempting to elicit its whereabouts. King Richard condemned the killings, Francesco apparently taking the fall and hanged. Atonement for his sins colors his masterpiece. “Dante’s crusading polemic is the Latin West, and his crusader attitudes have more in common with Franciscan traditions than with papally sponsored crusades. Dante’s prophetic poem, like many crusade narratives, becomes the means to call his place of origin to account for its transgressions” (Brenda Deen Schildgen Dante and the Crusades). Dante’s lover Beatrice gave him a portend, a cross before he left for the Crusades. “The heaven of Mars feels very different, right from the start. It is ruddy in color, the color of blood; the language is colored as well, with a kind of military zeal; and the pilgrim is overwhelmed by the sight of a celestial cross in which Christ is flashing”: ’n quella croce lampeggiava Cristo” (Paradiso 14.104 Columbia U). In that protean vein Dante poses the key to the reader, that if he were to understand what the poet has experienced and written. “Ma chi prende sua croce e segue Cristo. But he who takes his cross and follows Christ” (Paradiso 14.106 Commento Baroliniano MMXIV-MMXX Columbia University). Finally, decades later Aquinas in agreement with Dante targets the heart of our challenge to be perfect, “If you seek the example of love: Such a man was Christ on the Cross. Whoever wishes to live perfectly should do nothing but disdain what Christ disdained on the cross and desire what he desired, for the cross exemplifies every virtue” (Lecture 6).

  3. Dante Alighieri was not in fact a crusader, rather as depicted by author Brenda Schildgen wrote a crusade narrative. His ancestor Elisei Cacciaguida fought in the second crusade and is referenced in the Divine Comedy. The Third Crusade 1189-1192 was before Dante’s time. The image of Dante the crusader is a fantasy, a foil used in a video game called Infernopedia Fandom. Although fantasy it is a platform for acquaintance with Dante’s art otherwise out of reach for many.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

All comments posted at Catholic World Report are moderated. While vigorous debate is welcome and encouraged, please note that in the interest of maintaining a civilized and helpful level of discussion, comments containing obscene language or personal attacks—or those that are deemed by the editors to be needlessly combative or inflammatory—will not be published. Thank you.


*