The Dispatch: More from CWR...

Pro-life leaders sound alarm about Health Secretary nominee

By Matt Hadro for CNA

California Attorney General Xavier Becerra speaks after receiving the Leadership Ally Award from Equality California for his support of the LGBTQ community. (Credit: Chris Allen/Shutterstock)

Washington D.C., Feb 19, 2021 / 08:30 am (CNA).- Pro-life leaders and scholars are warning against the nomination of California’s attorney general to lead the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS).

In December, then-President-elect Joe Biden tapped Xavier Becerra—former congressman and current attorney general of California—to be the next HHS Secretary. Next week, Becerra will appear before two U.S. Senate committees at his confirmation hearings. The committees will then either vote to send his confirmation to the entire Senate favorably, unfavorably, or without its recommendation, or may not take action on his confirmation.

Pro-life groups and former administration officials point to Becerra’s record on abortion as “radical,” saying that in California he aggressively prosecuted pro-life activists, pushed to liberalize state and federal abortion regulations, and defended state laws that forced Catholic nuns and pregnancy centers to provide coverage for, and refer for, abortions.

Scholar Ryan Anderson, president of the Ethics and Public Policy Center (EPPC), said that Becerra is an “ideological culture warrior” who would only serve to heighten current political polarization.

Roger Severino, former head of the HHS Office for Civil Rights and senior fellow at EPPC, said that Becerra’s confirmation to lead the agency would be an “astounding conflict of interest”—given that Severino’s office twice found Becerra’s in violation of federal conscience laws.

In Jan., 2020, Severino’s office determined that California had violated federal law in forcing Catholic and pro-life groups to cover abortions in their health plans. After the office gave Becerra 30 days to comply with federal conscience protections, Becerra refused.

In December, the Trump administration announced that HHS would withhold $200 million in Medicaid funds to California, for refusing to comply with the law. Severino’s office in 2019 also found that Becerra previously had violated the law in forcing California pregnancy centers to advertise for abortions.

Becerra “wants to impose California’s COVID-19 failures and abortion extremism on the rest of the nation,” Severino said on Thursday.

A coalition of conservative groups—including CatholicVote and the pro-life Susan B. Anthony List—are launching a media and grassroots campaign against Becerra’s confirmation as well as Vanita Gupta’s confirmation as associate attorney general.

“The choice of Becerra for HHS was a total 180 from the talk of ‘unity’ surrounding the inauguration,” stated Marjorie Dannenfelser, president of the Susan B. Anthony List. “He’s as extreme as they come on abortion.”

On Wednesday, the chair of the Senate Pro-Life Caucus said Becerra was “radical” in using the power of the state to prosecute pro-life groups.

Throughout his career in California, Becerra has been “attacking” pro-life nuns and pro-life crisis pregnancy clinics “with radical, radical efforts,” Sen. Steve Daines (R-Mont.) said at an online panel opposing Becerra’s confirmation.

Becerra’s previous opposition to laws protecting infant survivors of abortion—while he was a congressman—“is just chilling for all of us,” Daines said, “but that is who will lead the HHS Department.”

As attorney general of California, Becerra repeatedly defended the state’s pro-abortion laws while also prosecuting pro-life activists. He also led other state attorneys general in fighting state abortion restrictions in court.

Becerra defended the state’s Reproductive FACT Act, a law passed in 2015 before his tenure that forced crisis pregnancy centers to advertise where clients could get abortions. The court battles over the law reached the Supreme Court, which ruled in 2018 that the law violated the free speech rights of pregnancy centers.

He also continued the state’s prosecution of pro-life activist David Daleiden, for his 2015 undercover videos claiming that Planned Parenthood unlawfully profited from the fetal tissue of aborted babies. The previous attorney general, current Vice President Kamala Harris, initiated the prosecution of Daleiden.

Becerra defended the state’s 2014 mandate which forced even Catholic religious— the Missionary Guadalupanas of the Holy Spirit—to provide abortion coverage in employee health plans. For this action—as well as for the state’s previous enforcement of the Reproductive FACT Act—the HHS Office for Civil Rights issued notices of violation to the state.

Earlier in the pandemic, Becerra advocated that the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) allow the abortion pill regimen to be prescribed remotely during the coronavirus pandemic.

In 2017, he sued the Trump administration for giving broad religious and moral exemptions from the HHS mandate, including to the Little Sisters of the Poor.

Becerra’s “only healthcare qualifications seem to be his attacks on pro-life medicine, his persecution of the Little Sisters of the Poor, and his defense of an unlawful California abortion mandate,” Anderson noted.

While a congressman, Becerra voted against a partial-birth abortion ban and also opposed a bill that criminalized the killing of an unborn child resulting from an assault on the mother.

“His positions on life and religious liberty make him an outlier,” Bill Donohue, president of the Catholic League, stated of Becerra.

Sen. Daines said that the adage of “personnel is policy” rings true with Becerra’s nomination.

“When President Joe Biden nominates somebody like Xavier Becerra, it tells you exactly where Joe Biden’s center of gravity is on this issue of abortion, and protecting the most vulnerable in our society,” Daines said.

If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!

Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.

About Catholic News Agency 6491 Articles
Catholic News Agency (


  1. We can all thank our courageous Cardinals Cupich, Gregory and Tobin, as well as Bishop McElroy, for the nominee. San Diego Bishop McElroy must be particularly proud of fellow-Californian Becerra. Now all those crazy pro-lifers – single issue voters – need to shut up, and let Biden do what he promised long before the election. Let’s focus on the real threat to human life … climate change. And the folks at USCCB headquarters must still be giggling with delight that Biden “won” the election.

    • John P: While your comment is rich with sarcasm, the scary thing for me is that the point you are making may be correct. I just don’t know what is in the hearts of Bishops and wonder how it got to the point where the too many Bishops motives can be questioned.

  2. If I’m not mistaken, it was Becerra who once said that people over 70 years should be denied life-saving medical treatment, including antibiotics. This man is toxic!

  3. I have a couple of theories how we got here. #!) Bishops are horrified that they will be ruthlessly “cancelled” in the media unless they follow the progressive line, and they’re easily cancelled by association with one Theodore McCarrick. They all know it. #2) Money. Bishops of large metro areas need financial support from the wealthy, and the wealthy these days tend to be self-loathing progressives and democrats. Bishops from large metro areas wield enormous power at USCCB. #3) USCCB headquarters in DC is almost entirely and fanatically democrat, and as fanatically anti-conservative. The people who advise, direct, do the background work and execute policies are die-hard SJW’s. Washington born and raised almost entirely, they are quintessential bubble creatures. A retired, lay USCCB kingpin (who will remain nameless) made sure that headquarters would be securely liberal democrat. He watches over it to this day, and he has his inside minions. He was a former White House democrat operative who has never given up being a democrat operative.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

All comments posted at Catholic World Report are moderated. While vigorous debate is welcome and encouraged, please note that in the interest of maintaining a civilized and helpful level of discussion, comments containing obscene language or personal attacks—or those that are deemed by the editors to be needlessly combative or inflammatory—will not be published. Thank you.