The Dispatch: More from CWR...

Vatican Secretary of State knew of investment now under investigation

By Andrea Gagliarducci for CNA

Cardinal Pietro Parolin, Vatican secretary of state, leaves the morning session of the Synod of Bishops for the Amazon at the Vatican Oct. 8, 2019. (CNS photo/Paul Haring)

Vatican City, Jan 12, 2021 / 11:57 am (CNA).- A letter by Cardinal Pietro Parolin leaked to an Italian outlet shows that the Secretariat of State was aware, and approved at its highest ranks, of the disgraced purchase of a luxury real estate in London now at the center of a Vatican investigation.

The Italian newspaper Domani published on Jan. 10 a “confidential and urgent” letter addressed by Cardinal Parolin, Vatican secretary of State, to Jean-Baptiste de Franssu, President of the Institute for Religious Works (IOR) also known as “the Vatican bank.”

In the letter, Cardinal Parolin asked the IOR to loan 150 million € (approximately $182.3 million) to the Vatican Secretariat of State. The Secretariat of State needed the money to pay off the loan contracted with Cheney Capital four months before. The Secretariat of State took the loan to buy out the shares of the real estate in London.

Cardinal Parolin described the investment as “a valid one,” said that the investment had to be safeguarded, and asked the IOR for the loan. He also wrote that the loan was needed because the financial situation at that moment suggested the Secretariat of State not to use its reserve to “carry out operations for hedge investments,” but instead to “acquire additional liquidity.”

The Secretary of State also detailed that the loan would have a “two-year maturity” and that the IOR would be remunerated “in line with the international market” for the loan.

According to Domani, the IOR immediately move to fulfill the request and informed the Financial Intelligence Authority. The Financial Intelligence Authority has oversight power over the IOR, but not over the Secretariat of State.

In April, the Vatican FIA labeled the operation as “feasible,” considering that the IOR had enough money to carry it out. At the same time, the FIA asked for adequate due diligence to comply with existing anti-money laundering laws.

In May, Mr. Gianfranco Mammì, IOR general director, asked Archbishop Edgar Peña, Sostituto of the Secretariat of State, to write down the request in a letter signed by him. According to Mammì, the Sostituto has “executive power,” and for this reason, Cardinal Parolin’s letter was not enough for the IOR to carry out the operation as requested.

Archbishop Peña Parra met the Mammì requests and signed a letter on June 4 and another one on June 19 to explain the request for the loan.

On June 27, the IOR experts gave their green light to the financial operation. On June 29, the IOR presented the economic plan for the loan to the officials of the Secretariat of State.

But on July 2, Mammì changed his mind and reported to the Vatican prosecutor that Archbishop Peña Parra was not clear and would not disclose who would be the real beneficiary of the requested loan.

One Vatican source confirmed with CNA that Cardinal Parolin’s letter is authentic and that the story penned by the newspaper Domani is accurate.

After Mammì’s report to the public prosecutor, the Vatican police searched and seized the FIA and Secretariat of State’s office on Oct. 1, 2019.

Two days later, the news broke that the Vatican had suspended five officials: Msgr. Maurizio Carlino, Mr. Fabrizio Tirabassi, Mr. Vincenzo Mauriello and Mrs. Caterina Sansone of the Secretariat of State; and Mr. Tommaso Di Ruzza, FIA director.

Later on, the Vatican also suspended Msgr. Alberto Perlasca, who led the Secretariat of State’s administrative office from 2009 to 2019.

Despite no criminal charges were filed against any of them, all of these officials, except for Caterina Sansone, no longer work at the Vatican. Di Ruzza was not renewed as the FIA’s director, Tirabassi and Mauriello agreed on an early retirement and both Carlino and Perlasca were sent to their dioceses of origin.

Although Cardinal Parolin’s leaked letter has no relevance for the investigation, it does provide important context.

One of them is that the Secretariat of State was aware that there were financial and ethical concerns regarding the 2011-2012 investment in the luxury real estate property at 60 Sloane Avenue in London, managed by 60 SA Company.

The Vatican Secretariat of State signed its purchase for $160 million with the Luxembourg-based Athena fund, owned and managed by Italian financier Raffaele Mincione, who acted as an intermediary.

When the Athena fund was liquidated, the investment was not returned to the Holy See. The Holy See risked losing all the money if it did not buy the building.

The Vatican FIA examined the deal and then proposed restructuring the investment, excluding intermediaries and thus making the Holy See save some money.

At that time, the Secretariat of State asked the IOR for resources sufficient to close the old mortgage and allow a new one to conclude the purchase.

Since the investment was initially considered “good” by the IOR, it is still a mystery what led Mammì to change his mind and report the financial operation to the public prosecutor; especially when in September 2020, the Administration of the Patrimony of the Apostolic See (APSA) reportedly paid out the loan with Cheney Capital and contracted a new loan to safeguard the investment. This was the same operation suggested by Cardinal Parolin’s letter.

So, why did the IOR not carry out the operation, as initially planned?

As more details of the operation come to light, the reason seems to be a power struggle in the inner circle of Pope Francis, with no clear winner. Currently, one year and three months after the search and seizures in the Secretariat of State, the Vatican investigation led to no indictments but also to no decisions not to prosecute. As long as the investigation leads to no clear conclusions, the scenario will continue to be confusing regarding the direction to which the Vatican finances are going.

If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!

Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.

About Catholic News Agency 10594 Articles
Catholic News Agency (


  1. Parolin is a criminal who belongs in prison. He is probably the man most responsible for the financial corruption in the Vatican.

    • Mr du Toit, I believe that an accusation such as yours is misplaced. It is very easy to throw mud when one is not able to substantiate their claim and worse when its accused is not able to defend oneself.

      With respect keep your comment for the anti Catholic cabal at the FT.

  2. What is the story on the US deemed Catholic agency that sent millions to Syria?
    When we recognize the US over threw the government of Syria government in 1949, replacing the democratic government with dictators, for oil, a pipeline.
    When its recognized the “christians” run the country, and the people going to the streets to protest the corruption of the “christian” leaders are exterminated, assinated, murder. Many reports in past years point to dead humans stacked as cord wood in building in Syria, with refuges, fleeing from Syria for their very lives.
    The US over threw Syria, 1949. Iran 1953, instilling the Sha of Iran, who was ranked the most murderous and torturous leader in the 1970’s. He was ousted by the Islamic in 1979, fled to the USA..
    The US also over threw the democratic government of Guatemala in he was working for the people to give the land, back to the people. He was removed by the US in 1954, and today, Guatemala suffers from major food shortages, with starvation and social/economic upheaval brings mass starvation.
    Yet today, these crimes inflicted around the world on people, are now coming to be a fact of United States own agriculture food production industry..
    What we inflicted on other nations, destroying democracy, now haunts the USA..
    And Catholic leaders can only plead ignorance…or

    • Lyle, perhaps at least some readers would take more seriously the oft-repeated burr under your saddle if there were some minimal effort on your part to explain the relevance, if any, to the topic at hand, in this instance details about Vatican finance.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

All comments posted at Catholic World Report are moderated. While vigorous debate is welcome and encouraged, please note that in the interest of maintaining a civilized and helpful level of discussion, comments containing obscene language or personal attacks—or those that are deemed by the editors to be needlessly combative or inflammatory—will not be published. Thank you.