The Dispatch: More from CWR...

Spiraling down in Speyer

As I have noted in this space before, the root of the German crisis is apostasy: an unabashed denial of what the Catholic Church believes and teaches to be true.

Speyer Cathedral, officially the Imperial Cathedral Basilica of the Assumption and St Stephen, in Speyer, Germany. (Image: Sail over / Wikipedia)

Speyer is a charming city on the west bank of the Rhine River. Its splendid medieval core is dominated by a magnificent 11th-century cathedral, the resting place of German emperors for three hundred years and one of Europe’s greatest expressions of Romanesque architecture. (For fans of British royalty, the future King Edward VII was introduced to his future wife, Alexandra, in the Dom Speyer in 1861, the matchmaker for “Bertie” being his sister Crown Princess Victoria of Prussia [“Vicky”].)

Speyer was erected as a diocese at some point in the fourth century, a local Catholic bishop being mentioned for the first time in written records in 346.

Bear with me now for a few moments of tedious, but revealing, statistics.

According to the current edition of the Vatican yearbook, the Annuario Pontificio, there are 504,210 Catholics in the Diocese of Speyer, which I presume means that 504,210 people within the diocesan boundaries identify as Catholic when ticking the box for the Kirchensteuer, the “Church tax,” on their German tax returns. There are 239 diocesan priests and 26 priests belonging to religious orders resident in the diocese, which is also home to 65 permanent deacons, 304 members of men’s religious orders, and 312 members of women’s religious communities. There were no priestly ordinations in the diocese in 2024, and at that point, Speyer had four seminarians.

Average Sunday Mass attendance is 5.1% of registered Catholics.

In June, the diocese announced a major restructuring, with its 70 parishes being reduced by 87% to nine. These new “parishes,” which will replace the current diocesan deaneries, will be run by a “synodal council” and a “full-time executive board,” the parish finances being managed by an “administrative council.” The nine new parishes will include “community teams” as “places of pastoral closeness and lived faith.”

All of this was presaged last fall when a synodal process in the diocese published a proposal for structural reform entitled “You Shall Be a Blessing”—a curious title, given that the diocesan vicar general conceded that “a great deal of uncertainty and sometimes even resignation were palpable” during that consultative process.

Indeed. Yet what caused that uncertainty? Consider this:

Shortly before the announcement of this radical transformation—some might say, deconstruction—of a historic diocese formed a century before the pontificate of Pope St. Leo the Great, Bishop Georg Bätzing of Limburg defiantly supported the blessing of same-sex couples as couples, publicly stating that this would happen “within a responsible framework. It serves the people and, in my view, does not endanger the unity of the Church.”

The former chairman of the German bishops’ conference did this right after Pope Leo, speaking during his return flight from Equatorial Guinea, criticized such practices and said that the Church “[does] not approve of the formal blessings of same-sex couples.” Concurrently, the president of the Central Committee of German Catholics, Irme Stetter-Karp, said that she hoped that “blessing ceremonies will continue to be used in as many places as possible for blessings of same-sex couples and couples in so-called irregular situations.”

There are many intensely aggravating aspects of German Catholicism’s Gadarene rush down the cliff of ecclesiastical oblivion; among the most disturbing, because of its dishonesty, is the claim that clerical sexual abuse requires the Church to rethink its ethic of human love and its ancient commitment to clerical celibacy. There is zero empirical evidence that clerical sexual predators were somehow turned into monsters by the Sixth Commandment and the Catholic Church’s understanding of how following that commandment makes for human happiness and flourishing.

As for the notion that marriage is some sort of crime-prevention program, such that a married clergy would be less given to sexual predation, that is both a gross insult to the sacrament of Matrimony and a claim belied by the grave problems of sexual abuse in Christian denominations with married ministry.

As I have noted in this space before, the root of the German crisis is apostasy: an unabashed denial of what the Catholic Church believes and teaches to be true. The Diocese of Speyer is not dying because of “financial and staffing reasons,” despite claims from diocesan officials. German Catholicism is awash in money because of the Church tax, and 265 priests should be more than enough to serve 70 parishes. The death rattle is being caused by a failure to preach, teach, and live, with joy and compassion, the Gospel in full: “the faith which was once for all delivered to the saints” (Jude 1:3).

That is what accounts for 5.1% Sunday Mass attendance. And that is what has caused the tragedy of the Speyer death spiral.


If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!

Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.


About George Weigel 516 Articles
George Weigel is Distinguished Senior Fellow of Washington's Ethics and Public Policy Center, where he holds the William E. Simon Chair in Catholic Studies. He is the author of over twenty books, including Witness to Hope: The Biography of Pope John Paul II (1999), The End and the Beginning: Pope John Paul II—The Victory of Freedom, the Last Years, the Legacy (2010), and The Irony of Modern Catholic History: How the Church Rediscovered Itself and Challenged the Modern World to Reform. His most recent books are The Next Pope: The Office of Peter and a Church in Mission (2020), Not Forgotten: Elegies for, and Reminiscences of, a Diverse Cast of Characters, Most of Them Admirable (Ignatius, 2021), and To Sanctify the World: The Vital Legacy of Vatican II (Basic Books, 2022).

28 Comments

  1. My observation is that the Catholic Church is vanishing in the west overall, and Germany in particular, because the self-titled “excellencies” and “eminences” and “holinesses,” (etc etc) do not believe that Jesus rose from the dead.

    Exhibit A:

    1974: A German priest theologian publishes a book denying the resurrection of Jesus. He asserts his belief that Jesus “obtruded in the spirit.” He labels the miracle accounts in the Gospels as mythology. He is not brought to justice by the Church.

    1989: The same priest is made a bishop, and given “teaching authority,” rewarding him for denying the faith.

    2001: The same man is made a Cardinal.

    No doubt, the same “convictions” are rampant in “the Church establishment,” as observed by Fr. Robert Imbelli, in his essay “No Decapitated Body.”

    I conclude that the root of the problem is not a denial of what the Catholic Church teaches.

    THE ROOT of the problem is that the “excellencies” and “eminences” and “holinesses” of The Catholic Church don’t think that believing in the Gospels and the Creed (etc etc) is important, and “the faithful” picked up on this, and concluded that The Catholic Church isn’t really serious.

    Surprise! It turns out that belief that Jesus rose from the dead actually matters.

      • A good guess would be the same cardinal (Kasper) who early defended the German Synodal Way by famously retorting to still-Catholic prelates in Africa, “who are they to tell us what to do?” But who am I to judge?

    • The Catholic Church in Europe is doomed unless something very drastic changes. The first order of business would be replacing many of the heterodox bishops in Europe. But what do we learn is the first priority of the Vatican? Persecuting those who prefer to worship using the Extraordinary Form. We’ll see how Catholics fare in Europe under Muslim rule.

  2. And the cascade of apostasy has essentially met with no consequence from the Vatican. No one can make sense of this criminal negligence exhibited by the Vatican. One is left to believe that the denial of the Faith is of far less consequence than an urgent desire to adhere to it. Lip service to the Vatican will buy you a long leash, your honest objections to the Vatican’s pastoral malpractice will find you labeled a schismatic and find you erroneously excommunicated.
    Do make sense of this, Pope Leo, after you explain your retention of bureaucrats at the DDF and the Secretary of State who malign the Blessed Virgin Mary and craft secret deals with genocidal Communists in China.
    But off to France and South America in the months to come.
    What nonsense.
    We witness the abandonment not only of the Faith, but of common sense, and a complete disregard for the value of credence.
    There is no accountability for the episcopate. The sole surviving immutable truth in Roman Catholicism is a bishop gets off free; the groundlings can starve.
    Is there a deliberate campaign underway to eradicate the Roman Catholic Church from the inside? A discerning citizen of the United States can’t help but see what has long been afoot in the Church has an amazing resemblance to what presently transpires in the Democrat party. Social justice on the lips, Marxism in the mind, Communism in the heart.
    Origin of the disease? The academy. The only crew being catered to in this ecclesial operation are atheists. That’s the street cred that counts to the mitered class.
    Theology is an occupation of the knees, not the seat of the pants.

    • One possible explanation might be that the infestation is so ingrained as to render useless and self-defeating any scattered game of whack-a-mole.

      Instead, start a new conversation altogether while the old guard slowly rots itself into an open grave. A new conversation possibly rooted in the existential dangers from AI algorithms erasing the nature and responsibility of Man altogether.

      Three litmus tests for this coming year, I propose, are: yes, future replacements and appointments; more on the promised Wednesday Audience focus on the Vatican II Documents (Lumen Gentium) versus the detached and so-called spirit of the Council; and the pecking order between Cardinal Grech’s rebranded “ecclesial assembly” in 2027 and 2028 versus the restored and annual Consistory of Cardinals (or is the Apostolic Succession just another seat around the doormat Synodal roundtable?).

  3. Whilst agreeing with most of what he says,I find it interesting that no mention is made That Archbishop Moth the highest ranking bishop in the UK did the same thing when he was Bishop of Arundel & Brighton Diocese! He made all the Deanaries into Parishes!

  4. Silence is tolerance if not outright support. Both Pope Francis and Pope Leo sit in the chair of Peter and remain silent. They both were quite capable of addressing their perspective of the world’s problems as far as climate and war go, but as far as base apostasy – it is crickets in the dead of night.

  5. Said Bishop George Batzing about blessing homosexual couples as “couples”: “It serves the people and, in my view, does not endanger the unity of the Church.”

    This act of disunity even after the enabling “Fiducia Supplicans” was publicly rejected by national conferences of bishops in all of continental Africa, Hungary, Poland, the Netherlands, Ukraine, Kazakhstan and Peru, and by parts of France, Spain, and Argentina, and by others. Also the Copts and the patriarch of Budapest who was “shocked.”

    About the real Council and the Barque of Peter, Batzing barks from the second-generation illiterati. Already this from the late 1960s:

    “The last council outlined the program for …renewal. Everyone claims (or claimed) to uphold it, but in different ways. In reality, it is little known, little followed. Some of those who claimed to be the only ones to take it seriously today disdain it. From the very first hour, a distorted interpretation of it began to be widespread. Those who were closely involved in producing the texts knew this”(Henri de Lubac, “The Church: Paradox and Mystery,” French 1967; Appendix: Conference at St. Louis University, May 29, 1969 included by Ignatius 2021).

  6. George Weigel’s account of Speyer’s downward spiral “The death rattle is being caused by a failure to preach, teach, and live, with joy and compassion, the Gospel in full: the faith which was once for all delivered to the saints”, whether intended or not, mirrors the entire Church.
    James articulates the details of the demise. What is needed? What will save us if not strong, Apostolic, papal leadership. Although one would wish to be fair to Leo XIV, that brand of leadership is absent in the diminutive, frequently contradictory steps toward his avowed goal of unity.

  7. I find it very interesting that it appears the Catholic Church in Germany is trying to become more like the EKD (Evangleische Kirche Deutschland) which is the Protestant Church.
    The EKD essentially does everything “right”. They allow married ministers, female, ministers, they allow divorce and remarriages, they allow same sex marriages, they have no problem with artificial birth control. All the things that many Catholics want.
    But when you look at Kirchenaustritt.de one finds something very interesting. In the 36 years from 1990 to 2025 there is a higher percent of the Protestants living the EKD in 33 of the those 36 years. Only years 2010, 2022 and 2023 does the Catholic Church have a higher percent leaving. If the EKD is doing everthing “right’ and what Catholics want, why is that? I would like to understand this.

  8. “There were no priestly ordinations in 2024.”
    Who needs priests? Anyone can give out Communion. Confession is obsolete. Apparently in Germany, laity can give the homily. Mass attendance is optional since VII.
    As in Germany, so in Belgium and northern Europe generally.

  9. “As for the notion that marriage is some sort of crime-prevention program, such that a married clergy would be less given to sexual predation, that is both a gross insult to the sacrament of Matrimony and a claim belied by the grave problems of sexual abuse in Christian denominations with married ministry.”
    ********

    Exactly. Marriage isn’t a cure for deviancy.

  10. Why the reference these days is always to the “Latin” mass? It is the TRIDENTINE MASS. The Tridentine Council 1545-1563. We should be talking about the TRIDENTINE MASS NOT “THE LATIN MASS”. The council standardization of the mass included:
    Language: “The Council reaffirmed the use of Latin as the universal language of the liturgy to preserve unity and orthodoxy, explicitly rejecting the vernacular innovations of the Reformers.”

  11. This is beyond tragic. I can’t imagine how even the 5% that still attend Mass manage. It’s like reading how one’s mother was defiled, murdered and ultimately dumped in a field (metaphorically, don’t @ me). The reasons are irrelevant to the abandoned sheep, lost, cold, unprotected and hungry. I pray some other good shepherd will adopt this tiny flock soon before they all die of neglect.

    • “Susanne Lee wrote above: “This is beyond tragic. I can’t imagine how even the 5% that still attend Mass manage…..I pray some other good shepherd will adopt this tiny flock soon before they all die of neglect”.

      God, for sure, works in mysterious ways. I don’t know, but I am probably the only one on this platform, who is located in Germany. So I have felt compelled to write something in response. I was awaiting my turn at the practice of an MD this morning (14/08/2026) when I opened my cell phone and incidentally found George Weigel’s article to read. The building in which I found myself is actually about five blocks away from the Speyer Cathedral! I am West African by origin and came to study in Germany in 1970. Circumstances dictated my continuous stay in the country, which is now more than 50 years. I live in a small town exactly eight miles from the city centre of Speyer. Like many others in my region, the neo-Gothic Catholic parish Church in my town stems from the 14th Century and is considered to be among the finest. Until about two decades ago it used to have very vibrant and active parishioners. However, old age and deaths, in the interim, have robbed the parish of that vibrancy. And youngsters do not sense any reason to participate in church life anymore. I think the German educational system is partly responsible for the decline in Christian religious sensitivities. I know this from the background developmental progression of my own two children who started off as mass servers and ceased being religious completely at some point. I am now past age 70; but I have never fully felt at home with the Novus Ordo liturgy. So I am used to commute 15 minutes every Saturday morning since 2010 to attend the old Latin Mass of my childhood at a Church designated for the extraordinary rite by our Speyer diocese. Attendees amount to an average of 50 to 70 devotees of the Tridentine Mass on each given occasion. Most of us routinely attend the Novus Ordo mass at our home parishes also. Beginning from last June, rumours have been circulating to the effect that the Church hosting the old liturgy might face profanation and abandonment by the diocese sometime soon. For this reason, an initiative opposing the likelihood of that event has been launched to collect signatures to present to the diocese.

      Regarding the parish restructuring (combined with the shortage of priests) alluded to above in George Weigel’s article, the problem that has emerged out of that relates to the distribution and allotment of priests to cater for the vastness of the new parish districts. Masses can no longer be celebrated in every parish all the time and on all feast days as it used to be in the past. The traditional pastoral residences which were attached to the churches are now mostly idle, unoccupied or sold off. There are now only pools of traveling priests who are constantly under stress and time constraints. The relatively younger priests are more likely to be deployed to serve multiple parishes. The need to fuse and centralize parish offices to manage and coordinate the itinerary of priests and deacons for services, baptisms, funerals, etc. is a creative response to the ongoing transformations. But such offices are mostly understaffed, or manned by volunteers in certain instances. I am myself a volunteer in the service of my local parish. I am responsible for preparing the altar, assisting the mass servers, readying the communion vessels and displaying the vestments and items needed by the officiating priest prior to his arrival to start a mass. Priests are usually able to arrive only about 10 to 15 minutes before the beginning of mass. Out of sheer curiosity, I have been counting mass attendees since the pandemic broke out in 2020. The largest number was for Easter Vigil 2025, namely 230: the church can hold at least 550. The smallest number (23) was on the Second Day of Christmas 2023.

  12. As usual the blessed Weigel does his Leosplaining and won’t point out that what’s happening in germany is so clearly being tolerated by rome. Weigel repeats the pathetic narrative that leo cracked down on them over same-sex blessings when he embraced fiducia supplicans in the same breath but gave us a new goalpost of “formal blessings” and the neo-cons fell for it. As the latest confirmation of all this, one of those spear-heading germany’s efforts, cardinal marx, was just reappointed head of office for economic affairs. Not only do the german bishops ever face any discipline, but they are rewarded.

  13. From the article: These new “parishes,” which will replace the current diocesan deaneries, will be run by a “synodal council” and a “full-time executive board,” the parish finances being managed by an “administrative council.” The nine new parishes will include “community teams” as “places of pastoral closeness and lived faith.”

    What a total nightmare! I’d rather meet in the catacombs.

  14. Is this a mere coincidence?
    Exactly one week after the posting of George Weigel’s article, the Bishop of Speyer Dr. Karl-Heinz Wiesemann resigns, citing ill health as reason on 19 August, 2026. The 66 year-old was in office since 2008. For most of the faithful or observers in the diocese, the Bishop’s decision is not really surprising: For a period of seven months in 2021, he took a leave of absence from his flock and entered a clinical therapy facility where he was diagnosed with depression. He remained there to receive support in order to recover his physical strength and to reduce emotional distress.

1 Trackback / Pingback

  1. Spiraling down in Speyer – seamasodalaigh

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

All comments posted at Catholic World Report are moderated. While vigorous debate is welcome and encouraged, please note that in the interest of maintaining a civilized and helpful level of discussion, comments containing obscene language or personal attacks—or those that are deemed by the editors to be needlessly combative or inflammatory—will not be published. Thank you.


*