The Dispatch: More from CWR...

Rumors and conclaves: Expect the unexpected

It is apparent that Roman hands are preparing for the interregnum and eventual conclave for the election of Pope Francis’s successor. That’s par for the course in the Eternal City.

Cardinals concelebrate Mass for the election of the Roman pontiff in St. Peter's Basilica at the Vatican March 12. Attending the service were some 170 cardinals

There’s been a lot of chatter about Pope Francis getting ready to resign, but I’m not buying it — not yet — nor am I convinced either he or his pontificate is running on empty. In fact, most of the evidence, such as it is, adduced in support of such conjectures, may very well point to the opposite conclusion.

It is apparent that Roman hands are preparing for the interregnum and eventual conclave for the election of Pope Francis’s successor. That’s par for the course in the Eternal City, where the maxim is: Morto un papa, se ne fa ‘n’artro (literally, “When one pope dies, another is made.”). The fact is, popes get old and popes get sick. They never get any younger and sometimes they stay sick for a long time.

Though Pope Francis is not the picture of health, there’s really no telling how sick he is. He could recover from any or all of the things known to be ailing him, or at least rally. He has a pretty full dance card, too, even apart from the maxi-consistory planned for late August. One of the trips on the schedule is to L’Aquila, the central Italian town devastated by an earthquake in 2009 and still struggling to recover. L’Aquila is also famous for being the resting place of Pietro Angelerio — Pope St. Celestine V, also styled St. Peter Celestine — who reigned only five months before resigning the office in hope of returning to his previous life as a hermit.

Pope Benedict XVI left his pallium on St. Peter Celestine’s sarcophagos when he visited the quake-stricken community in 2009, a gesture subsequently interpreted as an indication Benedict was already then considering resignation as an option. (The pallium is the white woolen garment worn like a scarf around the shoulders of a metropolitan archbishop to signify his office.) Pope Francis’s plan to visit the place on August 28th — the day after he creates a score of new cardinals — is the kind of thing as is bound to gin up the rumor mill.

What if he just goes and greets the people of L’Aquila to offer them moral and spiritual support and bring their ongoing trials into the light of the cameras that are bound to follow him? Will that be a “gesture” indicating he doesn’t intend to resign? It would be just like him — “[H]im all over!” as Bolt’s Everyman-Matthew the Manservant, says of Thomas More at one point in A Man for All Seasons — to let the excitement and speculation build, even to give several indications in one direction, and then to do the other thing.

That doesn’t mean there aren’t preparations underway — at least ufficiosi, as the Romans say — in the form of informal conversations about what the Church needs and doesn’t from the next guy, what sort of profile he ought to have and what sort he needs not to have, and even who might be the plausible candidates. All of that is normale amministrazione truth be told, though it is pretty much universally recognized that the next interregnum and conclave — whenever they come — will be complicated and likely messy affairs. The electors don’t really know each other.

Francis’s pontificate has been turbulent. The Church is wrestling — perhaps less assiduously than anyone would like — with multiple and converging crises. The Vatican’s finances are in shambles. The ecclesiastical leadership culture is broken.

Picking a successor will not be easy, nor will it be the work of a day.

When I was a kid, I watched the British sci-fi show, Terrahawks (a creation of Gerry Anderson and Christopher Burr, the guys who brought the world Thunderbirds, which in turn inspired the immortal 2004 masterpiece, Team America: World Police). The premise of the mid-’80s animated puppet show is that, in the year 2020, an elite team of heroes defend Earth from alien invaders. In the very first episode of the series, the Terrahawks’ team leader responds to a query regarding what he expects from the imminent encounter with the alien flagship with the words, “I expect the unexpected.”

That’s sound advice whenever one is tempted to prognostication regarding the next moves of a man who preaches the “God of surprises” and exercises his role as God’s vicar by being the “pope of surprises” as well. It is also practically a given that there are no clear front-runners for the succession, much less any heir apparent. The Romans have another saying: Chi entra ner conclave papa, ne risorte cardinale (Roman dialect for “He, who goes into the conclave a pope, comes out a cardinal.”). Only, no one is going in pope this time. Expect the unexpected, indeed.

If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!

Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.

About Christopher R. Altieri 195 Articles
Christopher R. Altieri is a journalist, editor and author of three books, including Reading the News Without Losing Your Faith (Catholic Truth Society, 2021). He is contributing editor to Catholic World Report.


  1. Expect the unexpected? Really? How can that be plausible while the remnants and successors of the St. Gallen mafia and the 100+ new cardinals Bergoglio has thus far appointed (63%+ of the total) will control the conclave with the likelihood of still another catastrophic papacy impossible to ignore.

  2. Boyhood lover of fantastical heroic drama now becomes discretionary journalist of rumors of Church wars Altieri sort of reminds [some] of Vietnam Marine Lt Philip Caputo’s A Rumor of War and the battle for Danang. Who won? Who will win? What will it all come to?
    Surely this concerns us. “Roman hands are preparing” for mortal combat fought behind doors, in front of doors, in cafe’s, in the streets [somewhat like 2013?]. How many popes will leave the conclave cardinals? Altieri doesn’t consider Francis war weary, ready for pleasant grazing, another pontiff emeritus. Not at all. There’s Roman acquired wisdom in this Altieri perception. Never consider a dead duck dead. A canard perhaps. Master of guile, virtual deity of surprises His Holiness considers duping the cognoscenti child’s play [in this writer’s opinion].
    Altieri’s du Maurierian references to August 28 Aquila, the pallium, the maxi-consistory planned for late August reveals the art of making something intriguing out of the nonsensical nothing. I think he’s right.

  3. Surprised too , to an extent at the words of the Holy Father – ‘remain faithful in times of dependance , of leave taking..’ it could just as well be a general exhortation to many in more less similar shoes ..
    or is it more mysterious – having offered or renewed the offering to be a victim soul – to help free those who have fallen for powers of darkness and its cruel , greedy destructive claims over bodies and lives and nations ..instead of being loving enough to wait in patience His Holy Will , to bring forth needed changes in hearts to resolve issues focusing primarily on dignity and worth of human lives .


    Hoping that there are enough places that look for natural remedies too , to help the Holy Father , in turn to be a blessings for others too .

  4. His Holiness Pope Francis is doing fine. There is lot more creative and constructive work the Holy Spirit will demand from the tireless Holy Father. Long live Francis. God bless.

2 Trackbacks / Pingbacks

  1. THVRSDAY EDITION – Big Pulpit
  2. A Mysterious Visitor Brings Last Meal, Beautiful Mexican Madonna Associated with Cures, and More Great Links! - JP2 Catholic Radio

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

All comments posted at Catholic World Report are moderated. While vigorous debate is welcome and encouraged, please note that in the interest of maintaining a civilized and helpful level of discussion, comments containing obscene language or personal attacks—or those that are deemed by the editors to be needlessly combative or inflammatory—will not be published. Thank you.