The Dispatch: More from CWR...

Beware of “self-pity” over church closures, warns cardinal

Speaking via livestream from an empty Westminster Cathedral in London April 23, Cardinal Vincent Nichols, who is Archbishop of Westminster and head of the Bishops’ Conference of England and Wales, paid tribute to the “quiet heroes” on the front line of the coronavirus crisis.

Cardinal Vincent Nichols of Westminster, England, is pictured in a Feb. 24, 2014, photo. (CNS photo/Max Rossi, Reuters)

CNA Staff, Apr 23, 2020 / 03:00 pm (CNA).- English Catholics must avoid “any sense of self-pity” over church closures, Cardinal Vincent Nichols said at a Mass honoring workers in hospitals and care homes.

Speaking via livestream from an empty Westminster Cathedral in London April 23, Cardinal Vincent Nichols, who is Archbishop of Westminster and head of the Bishops’ Conference of England and Wales, paid tribute to the “quiet heroes” on the front line of the coronavirus crisis.

“For most of us, our part in this effort is so different,” the cardinal said. “Yes, deprivations are placed on us, including not being able, as yet, to return to our churches and sacraments, a deprivation we feel very deeply indeed. Yet we beware of any sense of self-pity as we play our part in these life-saving disciplines.”

The cardinal told Catholics watching online that “In all of this we are comforted by the unwavering presence of our Blessed Lord.”

“We must have eyes to see Him in every place, in every moment. Our prayer must be steadfast, for there is no doubt that the power of God is both needed and moving in this epic struggle. This evening we renew that prayer for God’s strength and inspiration for these quiet heroes of today even as we get ready to applaud them.”

Public liturgies were suspended in England March 20 and churches closed a few days later. Bishops in the country have faced mounting calls from Catholics to reopen churches and allow congregations at Masses while respecting social distancing rules.

A video by lay Catholics appealing for the restoration of public Masses has been viewed more than 3,000 times since it was posted April 22. A spokesman for the English and Welsh responded to the appeal April 23, acknowledging that the absence of sacraments was a “heavy deprivation.”

“The feelings and desires that are expressed in this video are completely understandable,” the spokesman said, according to the U.K. Catholic Herald.

“However there are other factors that need to be considered: we have a moral duty to protect life; we have a duty to heed the best professional advice about the dangers of this virus which is invisible and deadly; we have to be sure that whatever steps we may take – and some are proposed in the video – are well thought through, receive formal approval and are deliverable in every situation.”

The Mass at Westminster Cathedral was the first in a series of Thursday evening Masses that will be celebrated by bishops in cathedrals across England.

The Masses are on Thursdays because that is the day when people stand outside their homes and applaud workers in the National Health Service, the U.K.’s publicly funded healthcare system. The Masses begin at 7 p.m., ending in time for the “Clap for our Carers” at 8 p.m.

In his homily, the cardinal noted that health workers are heirs to a “great and noble” tradition.

“It’s a tradition that bears the hallmark of the Christian faith,” he said. “Its characteristics of self-sacrifice and courage and its commitment to caring for all, especially for the poorest, sprang from the determination to follow the teachings of Christ who said that he is to be found, and served, especially in the poorest, the most needy and those least able to help themselves.”

The cardinal recalled the history of the Church in shaping modern attitudes to charity and love for one’s neighbor.

“Care and assistance for the poor, sick and dying was very restricted throughout the Roman world, which is the Europe and Middle East of today, until the disciples of Jesus began to provide it,” he said. “The poor were simply left to their fate. But the vision of Christianity altered that. To serve the poor and the sick was to serve the Lord himself. And slowly that conviction became expressed in institutions.”

The cardinal continued: “We know of St Basil the Great who led the way in the 4th century, building centers for the care of the poor and the sick, as did Fabiola, a noblewoman in Rome who, at that same time, made similar foundations.”

“We remember, too, the hospital of St Bartholomew which has stood on the Tiber Island in Rome for over 1,200 years and led to the followers of St Augustine of Hippo founding London’s oldest hospital, St Bartholomew’s Hospital — or Barts, as it is known — in the 12th century, followed closely by St Thomas’s.”

Nichols urged those following online to pray to St. George, patron of England, whose feast is celebrated April 23, as well as St. Luke, patron of doctors, Sts. Cosmas and Damian, patron saints of pharmacy and medicine, and St. Agatha and St. John of God, patron saints of nurses.

He petitioned the saints to “pray for us now in our hour of need and with us beg of the Lord a time of healing and new strength.”

More than 139,000 people have contracted the coronavirus in the U.K. and more than 18,700 have died, according to Johns Hopkins University Coronavirus Resource Center.

If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!

Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.

About Catholic News Agency 5967 Articles
Catholic News Agency (


  1. Bishop has banned all confessions in my diocese (even with social distancing…which I support).

    Strange – I can get a burrito at a Taco Bell drive-thru, but I can’t get a sacrament. Sad when Taco Bell is more committed to its people than the bishops.

    • Anon,
      Yup. Seems like a serious lack of resourcefulness.
      We have drive thru Confessions at our church several days a week. It’s hard to believe if we can figure that out in a tiny rural parish that others can’t.

      • It’s not that we can’t figure it out, it’s that we are not allowed to do anything by decree of our bishop. Everything is completely banned. I don’t blame parish priests. My priest was visibly upset when he told me he was not allowed to hear my confession because of the bishop’s order. Imagine putting priests in the position of saying “no” when their people ask for forgiveness and reconciliation with God?!

        The bishops should be ashamed of themselves. Most of them hide in their well appointed houses whilst their flock (many of whom make minimum wage) go to work dutifully to keep grocery stores/pharmacies etc open. It’s a shame that the bishops don’t have the same courage or sense of duty as your local grocery store worker.

        The bishops better watch themselves; if they keep telling the faithful the sacraments aren’t essential we just might conclude that the bishops aren’t either.

        PS: I fully support social distancing and believe confession can be offered in such a way as to protect both priest and penitent (i.e. outside, 6 feet apart, masks etc).

  2. I don’t think I’d choose “self pity” as a way to describe our loss of the sacraments. That does seem an odd way to express it.

  3. H.E. the Cardinal is not a virologist or an epidemiologist he is a priest with priestly duties and obligations, shutting down the Catholic Church at government behest and engaging in its coercive and demeaning propaganda is definitely not his brief.
    Online liturgies might well be classed as government agitprop for all the use they are.
    The Church prostrates before the blessed state?

  4. Let us pray His Eminence will appreciate the laity’s exercise of will to keep rage at bay, that just as to much dismay & confusion a previous Sanhedrin even more energetically sought to keep Christ from the faithful, so does this current one seek to keep us from Him Sacramentally. Yet while we too are dismayed & confused by this contemptible effort, we know the previous Sanhedrin’s hopes in the end went unrealized, as, may God forgive them, will the pathetic attempts of their spiritual successors’.

  5. The jargon of Cardinal Nichols, pre-emptively scolding the faithful by arrogantly demeaning and dismissing their concerns as “self-pity,” is “bureaucrat-speak,” a talent long-practiced by “His Emiinence” and in reportedly (by Damian Thompson of the U.K. Spectator) already in full flower when he was a Msgr, and a spokesman for the Catholic Bishops Conference of England and Wales.

    There is a big scandal brewing in the Catholic Church in England because it has been discovered that it was NOT the government that asked the Catholic Church to close, but rather, it was the Catholic Church that petitioned the government to order that the Churches be closed. And then the Bishops Conference lied, stating that the government had required them to close.

    I will post Thompson’s pod-cast story next.

  6. And all the while we in America thought our USCCB topped the list of the world’s deplorable [excluding of course Germany now an independent church with quasi moral features secondary to prev chronic Catholicism]. Once again GB manages to best us.

1 Trackback / Pingback

  1. Beware of “self-pity” over church closures, warns cardinal - Catholic Mass Search

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

All comments posted at Catholic World Report are moderated. While vigorous debate is welcome and encouraged, please note that in the interest of maintaining a civilized and helpful level of discussion, comments containing obscene language or personal attacks—or those that are deemed by the editors to be needlessly combative or inflammatory—will not be published. Thank you.