The Dispatch: More from CWR...

Why have Mass with no one there?

By Christine Rousselle for CNA


Washington D.C., Mar 18, 2020 / 07:00 am (CNA).- With public Masses suspended in over 100 dioceses across the United States, many Catholics have been told to stay home, make a spiritual communion, and maintain a prayer routine until the coronavirus pandemic passes.

Masses are still being celebrated privately, but what does that mean? What is the significance and power of Mass without the laity present? CNA spoke to experts to get a better understanding of why Masses celebrated in private are spiritually beneficial to all Catholics.

The Mass “is not something we do,” Fr. James Bradley, a professor of canon lawyer at the Catholic University of America, told CNA.

“We participate in the Mass when we come to the Mass, either as priest or as people, but it’s first and foremost the action of Christ. The Catechism says that Christ is the principal actor in the liturgy, so this is something that the Lord does and in which we participate, because we participate in His life through baptism.”

Catholics participate in God’s communion with the Church whenever Mass is celebrated, whether they are physically present for it or not, explained Bradley.

Mass is “not something that the priest does as a private individual. He does it as a minister of the Church, involving the whole of the Church. Every Mass that is celebrated, anywhere at any time, is for everyone who is part of the Church.”

Bradley said the language of the Mass as illustrates that it is never never a solo activity for the celebrant.

“We talk about the angels and saints and they all are always present in every celebration of the Mass, the whole of the Church is present on earth, present in heaven,” he said. “So, in a sense, the priest is never alone when he stands at the altar. He’s always surrounded by the clouds of witnesses.”

Fr. Thomas Petri, a theologian and the vice president and academic dean of the Dominican House of Studies, trains Dominicans preparing for ordination to properly celebrate Mass. He said that Mass is about God, not the people.

“The Mass is never, should never, be seen as something that’s about me as the priest or something that’s about the parishioner or something that’s about the community,” Petri told CNA.

“It’s about the adoration and the worship of God and giving him the glory and in that, because that’s what we were made to be, to do. That’s how we are fulfilled and that’s how we become happy and holy and more fully alive as human beings.”

“It may seem to many that the Mass is purely a sort of performance of worship of God and for one’s own spiritual benefit for the benefit of parishioners,” Petri said. And while the spiritual value aspect is certainly part of it, “it’s not the only thing, and I would say it’s not even the primary thing.”

“The primary thing that the Mass does or is, is that it’s the sacramental representation of the sacrifice of Jesus Christ on the cross,” Petri told CNA. “It’s the way Christ has deigned or willed that the effects of His sacrifice between the graces of His sacrifice, His suffering and death, but then also His resurrection would be made manifest.”

Every time Mass is celebrated, explained Petri, “you are present sacramental at the cross of Jesus Christ and the outpouring of graces of the paschal mystery are flooding into the world.”

This is true regardless of the number of people who are physically present for the Mass, he said.

“Every Mass has an infinite, spiritual value to it, because it’s the exact same value of the cross of Jesus Christ, which it represents.”

Fr. Bradley characterized the Mass as something very different from Protestant worship services, because Mass is “our participation in the offering of God the Son to God the Father in God, the Holy Spirit,” not just “a kind of horizontal relationship where we stand before God and we offer worship or we offer sorrow for our sins.”

While there are aspects of worship and contrition in the Eucharistic liturgy, Bradley said the Church’s sacramental participation in the life of Christ is the key differing factor.

“So, for Catholics, not being able to participate in the Mass, it’s serious,” Bradley said, “because they can’t just simply sit at home and do what they would otherwise do in church, the way Protestants would see that worship in church as being something which is them presenting something to God, either sorrow or joy or thanksgiving.”

Those things, said Bradley, “can be offered anywhere at any time,” but “in the Mass, we do something greater than that.”

Petri agreed, telling CNA that Catholics should never consider Mass a performance, as it is not about them.

“The Mass is efficacious and powerful,” he said. “If you celebrate it according to the ritual that the Church has laid down, the Mass isn’t a show because it’s not something we have invented. It’s not meant to be entertainment. Even though in the 21st century we all like to be entertained.”

Instead, Mass should be viewed as worshipping God “the very way he wants to be worshipped, the way he wants to be adored; which is to say through the suffering, death, and resurrection–the sacrifice–of His Son, Jesus Christ.”

“We do not have a right to expect to be entertained at Mass,” said Petri. “You don’t have a right to in fact worship God the way we want to worship God. In the Bible and in tradition, God always tells us how we are to worship Him. And the Mass is how he wants to be worshiped.”

Both Petri and Bradley expressed sorrow and dismay at the widespread suspension of Masses, but both priests said they understood why the actions were taken, even if they are upsetting for many Catholics.

“First of all, the Church always wants to take care of her flock. And that means that sometimes she has to do things which she wouldn’t want to do, but which are necessary,” Bradley told CNA. He characterized the suspension of publicly celebrated Mass as “ultimately an act of solicitude” and “a kindness of the bishop.”

“He’s trying to protect his flock, and it’s an extraordinary circumstance,” he said. “It’s not a giving in, it’s not a concession to civil society. It’s the bishop acting responsibly on the advice of civil society when it’s offered, when it presents a reasonable law.”

If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!

Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.

About Catholic News Agency 5986 Articles
Catholic News Agency (


  1. “Every time Mass is celebrated you are present sacrament [sacramentally?] at the cross of Jesus Christ and the outpouring of graces of the paschal mystery are flooding into the world” (Fr Petri). A sacrament is described as a rite of passage through which grace is imparted. We whether present or not as members of the Mystical Body are sacramentally present united with Christ. Although I agree with Fathers Bradley and Petri I would add the priest as alter Christus is himself also offering himself to the Father. Christ’s act in the sacrament infinitely surpasses anything the priest may add. Nonetheless the reverence of the priest, the willingness to offer himself as victim on behalf of the people, laying his life down for them is a rich source of invoking further blessings upon the people. So Mass offered even alone has immense value.

    • Agreed. For 1000 years Carthusian priests have offered mass alone ad orientum. I like to reflect on that whenever the cult of personality creeps into the theatre in the round celebrations of the last 50 years.
      Paradoxically the mass seems less about entertainment in the silence and solitude of hermit’s mass and God is indeed worshipped.

  2. Yes, very profound truths in this article. However, I am still glad that in our diocese, our Bishop is welcoming us every morning to his private chapel via Live Streaming, as he celebrates the mass. And my former and dearly loved parish is also going to start live streaming it next week. Yes, I long for the day when I can physically receive Jesus again; but I am so grateful that I can still be “present” at mass each day performing all the actions that the laity perform, and I really can sense that I am not alone, that others are watching and sharing in the prayers and actions and listening to the brief homily.

  3. After reading this article that expresses the learned and scholarly views of catholic priests I felt, as a layman, something was missing. Words mean things and I find that the word “Mass” is lacking a reality that in the past few generations of catholic have lost. I wonder how the article would be more meaningful if the word “Sacrifice” was used instead of “Mass”. This is all presented by a saintly priest when he was known as Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger in his book –Feast of Faith — Ignatius Press –copyright 1986, page 94.

  4. Excellent commentary by Fathers Petri and Bradley. Reminds one of the old joke:
    Catholic priest and Protestant minister are chatting:
    Minister: “I worship God my way.”
    Priest: “I worship God His way.”

1 Trackback / Pingback

  1. Why have Mass with no one there? - Catholic Mass Search

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

All comments posted at Catholic World Report are moderated. While vigorous debate is welcome and encouraged, please note that in the interest of maintaining a civilized and helpful level of discussion, comments containing obscene language or personal attacks—or those that are deemed by the editors to be needlessly combative or inflammatory—will not be published. Thank you.