Catholic World Report

Court upholds German municipality’s pro-life prayer vigil ban

Pavica Vojnović, leader of the pro-life prayer vigils in Pforzheim, Germany./ ADF International.
CNA Staff, May 14, 2021 / 08:00 am America/Denver (CNA).

A German court dismissed on Friday a challenge to a municipality’s ban on a prayer vigil in front of a pre-abortion advisory center.

CNA Deutsch, CNA’s German-language news partner, reported that the Karlsruhe Administrative Court handed down the judgment on May 14.

The challenge was spearheaded by Pavica Vojnović, who led the prayer vigils outside the Pro Familia advice center in Pforzheim, southwest Germany, organized by the group 40 Days for Life.

Pro Familia is a member association of the International Planned Parenthood Federation.

Reacting to the court’s decision, Vojnović said: “Every life is precious and deserves protection. I am saddened that we are prevented from supporting vulnerable women and their unborn children in prayer.”

“It saddens me that the court has dismissed our lawsuit, thus indirectly approving the ban on our silent prayer vigils near the abortion counseling center.”

In 2019, the local municipality in Pforzheim, in the federal state of Baden-Württemberg, denied the prayer group permission to hold vigils near the center.

Twice a year, around 20 people had gathered to pray for 40 days for women facing abortion and their unborn children. Vigil participants did not prevent anybody from entering the building or block the pavement in the surrounding area.

Pavica Vojnović takes part in a 40 Days for Life event in Pforzheim, Germany. Credit: ADF International.
Pavica Vojnović takes part in a 40 Days for Life event in Pforzheim, Germany. Credit: ADF International.

When the advisory center asked police to monitor the activists, they found no violations. But the center’s management asked that the vigil be moved some distance away or banned altogether.

The organization 40 Days for Life was founded by David Bereit in 2004 as a local pro-life advocacy group in Bryan-College Station, Texas. The group has grown into an international organization, holding Christian campaigns of prayer and activism to end abortion.

Felix Böllmann, legal counsel for ADF International, a Christian legal group that supported Vojnović’s legal challenge, said: “We regret the court’s decision, which restricts freedom of expression, assembly, and religion.”

“We are still awaiting the reasons for the verdict, but the dismissal of the case obviously fails to recognize that freedom of expression is the foundation of any free and fair democracy. What kind of society denies prayer to women and children in need?”

Pavica Vojnović, who had led pro-life vigils in Pforzheim, southwest Germany. / ADF International.
Pavica Vojnović, who had led pro-life vigils in Pforzheim, southwest Germany. / ADF International.

He continued: “The fact that the Pforzheim authorities had banned even silent prayer near the abortion counseling center is not proportionate. Having a belief is a fundamental right, as is the right to express that belief through peaceful assembly or to pray silently in public.”

“Regardless of whether one shares their views in substance or not, there should be agreement that the fundamental rights to freedom of expression, religion, and assembly enjoy the protection of the Basic Law.”

Vojnović added: “Our society needs to provide better support to mothers in difficult situations. This issue touches me deeply because I have accompanied many women through this pain.”

“This is about more than our group in Pforzheim, namely also about whether prayer-free zones are allowed to exist, or whether one is allowed to hold different opinions in public space. That’s why we want to continue.


If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!

Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.


35 Trackbacks / Pingbacks

  1. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center - White NewsPaper
  2. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center "themadagascarnews.com" The Madagascar News
  3. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center - World News Broadcast
  4. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center "Mysejahtera.com" Mysejahtera
  5. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center - Builder's Assembly
  6. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center - Buletin Utama
  7. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center "KinmenDailyNews.com" Kinmen Daily News
  8. ‘Prayer-Free Zones’: German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center – EC News
  9. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center "WorldNewsAnchors.com" World News Anchors
  10. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center "TheMozambiqueNews.com" The Niger News
  11. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center | Muhammad Aslam Rao | President MPCHS
  12. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center - The Sabah Times
  13. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center - Mustang Gold
  14. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center - The Borneo Mail
  15. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center "SuggestedArticles.com" Suggested Articles
  16. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center - Wprts
  17. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center "MalaysiaNewsLive.com" Malaysia News Live
  18. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center - HQ Markets
  19. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center "TheAngolaNews.com" The Angola News
  20. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center - China News Today
  21. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center - The Romania News
  22. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center "TheGhanaNews.com" The Ghana News
  23. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center - Singapore Daily News
  24. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center "TheYemenNews.com" The Yemen News
  25. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center "TheMozambiqueNews.com" The Mozambique News
  26. ‘Prayer-Free Zones’: German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center
  27. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center "MatsuDaily.com" Matsu Daily
  28. ‘प्रार्थना-मुक्त क्षेत्र’: जर्मन कोर्ट ने गर्भपात केंद्र के पास मूक समर्थक जीवन प्रार्थना पर
  29. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center - The Taiwan News
  30. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center "ThePeruNews.com" The Peru News
  31. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center - Akhbar Malaysia
  32. 'Prayer-Free Zones': German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center - Shopee Philippines
  33. ‘Prayer-Free Zones’: German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near – I Announce This
  34. ‘Prayer-Free Zones’: German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center – SBO AD's Network
  35. ‘Prayer-Free Zones’: German Court Upholds Ban on Silent Pro-Life Prayers Near Abortion Center – GOtravaler

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

All comments posted at Catholic World Report are moderated. While vigorous debate is welcome and encouraged, please note that in the interest of maintaining a civilized and helpful level of discussion, comments containing obscene language or personal attacks—or those that are deemed by the editors to be needlessly combative or inflammatory—will not be published. Thank you.


*