The Catholic Mutual Relief Society of America says it is not required to cover abuse claims in several Louisiana dioceses.
A national Catholic aid society told a federal judge this week that it is not required to cover current sexual abuse payouts in several Louisiana dioceses, with the company asking the judge to establish its lack of liability in the contested disputes.
Filed by the Nebraska-based Catholic Mutual Relief Society of America in U.S. district court, the suit was lodged against several dioceses in Louisiana, including Baton Rouge and Lafayette.
Catholic Mutual Relief Society of America suit
The dioceses in the suit have sought “indemnification” by the aid group regarding abuse claims, the suit says, but prior coverage issued by the company has allegedly been “exhausted” by the dioceses or by contract terms.
The organization said it ended contracts with dioceses in Louisiana in 2024 and that the federal lawsuit is meant to address any “ongoing rights and obligations” it might have related to earlier coverage.
The company is not a traditional insurance provider but rather a “church-based mutual benefit organization” that “does not enter into insurance contracts with the public.” The aid society thus argued that it is not subject to the Louisiana Insurance Code, which governs insurance policies.
The company said in the suit that it has “no coverage obligations toward the [dioceses], in connection with existing lawsuits or claims, or any future lawsuits or claims,” because “the small amount of limited aggregate coverage” related to abuse allegations “has been exhausted.”
The Diocese of Alexandria was excluded from the lawsuit, the company noted, as it recently filed for bankruptcy and cannot be sued due to an automatic stay as its own bankruptcy litigation plays out.
Roughly a year ago, the Archdiocese of New Orleans secured approval for a $230 million bankruptcy settlement, extending payouts to 650 victims after five years of contentious litigation.
The settlement included $130 million cash from the archdiocese and affiliates, $20 million in promissory notes, $30 million from insurers, and up to $50 million more from property sales.
If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!
Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.

Leave a Reply