As the U.S. bishops promote a Eucharistic revival, a lack of belief in the real presence of Christ in the Eucharist remains a serious, ongoing problem in the Catholic Church.
A new study has found that less than one-third of American Catholics believe Jesus Christ is truly present in the Eucharist, despite the Eucharistic revival initiative launched by the bishops more than four years ago.
The study, published in the academic journal Sociological Inquiry, found that American Catholic belief in the Real Presence has remained stagnant in recent years. Most Catholics, researchers found, continue to view the Blessed Sacrament as merely a symbol.
Researchers asked 1,049 Catholics whether they believe the Eucharist actually becomes “the Body and Blood of Christ” during consecration or whether they believe “the bread and wine are symbols of his body and blood.”
Only 28.8% answered that “the bread and wine truly become the Body and Blood of Christ” and about 58.8% expressed belief that “they are just symbols,” with approximately 12.4% saying “I’m not sure what happens.”
As one of the study’s authors Mark Regnerus pointed out in a blog post, their research found no statistically significant change from a 2019 Pew Research Center poll that found just 31% of Catholics believe in the Real Presence or from a 1992 Gallup poll that found only 30% of the faithful hold the belief.
Weekly Mass-goers were much more likely than other Catholics to believe in the Real Presence, at about 60%. Among those who attend Mass more frequently, slightly less than 70% believed in the Real Presence. Among those who self-identify as “very religious,” about 40% believed in the Real Presence.
“In a world wherein Catholics are saturated with information — and hence competitors to orthodox belief — it is incumbent on priests to remind parishioners what the Church holds to be true theologically (and socially, etc.),” Regnerus, who is Catholic, wrote in his blog post.
“Unfortunately, the study’s analyses also reveal that those who most need it aren’t likely to be present and listening,” he wrote.
The Eucharistic revival
To respond to the ongoing issue, in June 2022 the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) launched what it called a National Eucharistic Revival initiative designed to emphasize the real presence of Christ in the Eucharist.
With a goal of deepening devotion to the Eucharist, the nation’s bishops worked with priests to encourage adoration of the Blessed Sacrament and coordinated Eucharistic processions throughout the country. In 2024 a National Eucharistic Congress was held, attended by about 60,000 people.
“This study highlights that Catholic belief in the Real Presence has been a problem for many years, and it is going to take a while to correct,” David Spesia, the executive director for the USCCB’s Secretariat of Evangelization and Catechesis, told EWTN News.
“The message is clear that Catholics need to encounter Christ in the Eucharist regularly and live as though they have encountered him,” he said. “When we begin to do this, the natural next step is to prayerfully accompany friends or family members to a deeper relationship with the Lord — to ‘Walk with One’ person in our daily life, wherever they might be on their faith journey.”
Spesia said one issue the Church faces is the “secularization” of individuals and communities, and another is an “impoverished understanding of signs and symbols” and “an emptying of a sacramental worldview in favor of a materialistic worldview.”
“The Catholic faithful need to recover a deeper understanding and lived experience of what really happens when we celebrate the sacraments, and this requires lifelong formation and conversion of heart,” he said.
Spesia said the long-term goal of the revival is to reach everyone, “and there is still much work to be done.” Yet, he urged people not to dismiss “short-term fruit among those who engaged with the Eucharistic revival,” which deepened “the belief and practice of those Catholics who are actively practicing their faith so they would be better prepared to take on the mission of the Church to evangelize.”
As the revival initiative continues, Spesia said the bishops received “great feedback” from small-group studies held by parishes during the Eucharistic revival and there is an ongoing strategy “to invite people to hear and respond to the good news in conversation with fellow pilgrims on the journey.”
‘This is my body’
The Council of Trent proclaims that at the moment of consecration, the “substance” of the bread and the wine do not remain. Rather, it is transubstantiated into the true body, blood, soul, and divinity of Jesus Christ even though it maintains the outward appearance and chemical structure of bread and wine.
Affirmation of the Real Presence dates back to Christ himself at the Last Supper, declaring “this is my body” and “this is my blood.” St. Justin Martyr, a bishop and philosopher, explained in the A.D. 150s what the Eucharist meant to Christians: “The food which is blessed by the prayer of His word, and from which our blood and flesh by transmutation are nourished, is the flesh and blood of that Jesus who was made flesh.”
St. Ignatius of Antioch discussed this even earlier, writing in about A.D. 110, warning against the early Docetist heresy, which rejected that Christ had a physical body and also rejected the real presence of Christ in the Eucharist on that basis.
“They refrain from the Eucharist and from prayer because they do not confess that the Eucharist is the flesh of our Saviour Jesus Christ, which suffered for our sins, and which the Father of His goodness raised up,” the bishop wrote.
Tom Nash, a staff apologist at Catholic Answers, told EWTN News that understanding the real presence of Christ in the Eucharist is important because “it sacramentally re-presents Christ’s one sacrifice of Calvary and so enables us to offer anew and partake of the Real Presence of his new covenant Passover Communion sacrifice.”
“The Eucharistic sacrifice is the source of the Christian life because in re-presenting Christ’s one sacrifice of Calvary, we come in contact with the very means by which Our Lord objectively redeemed the world and enabled us to have forgiveness of our sins and the prospect of eternal life,” he said. “Thus our Lord’s words regarding his Eucharistic body and blood, namely, that those who consume it reverently will live forever.”
Jonathan Ciraulo, a theology professor at The Catholic University of America, explained to EWTN News that belief in the real presence of Christ in the Eucharist “is not a marginal concern” for the Church.
Ciraulo said the Real Presence affirms other doctrines: “Christ’s true humanity and real body; the dignity of the human body and its future resurrection; and the interior transformation whereby Christ comes to dwell in the Christian.”
“We would do well to ask ourselves how this apparent loss has reverberations far beyond polls regarding faith in the sacraments,” he observed.
In the Gospel of John, the apostle documents that Christ himself had his own dissenters from this doctrine, who wondered: “How can this man give us his flesh to eat?”
“Amen, amen, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you do not have life within you,” Christ responded. “Whoever eats my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life, and I will raise him on the last day. For my flesh is true food, and my blood is true drink. Whoever eats my flesh and drinks my blood remains in me and I in him.”
If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!
Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.

Our bishops ought to be ashamed of themselves. But who’s surprised by this?
So, in effect, these numbskulls are approaching the altar for lousy-tasting piece of unleavened bread. Now you tell me who the fools are.
Interestingly some commenters, a minority, share their views [to borrow from Erich Maria Remarque] that all is well on the Western Catholic front. Churches are packed confessional lines lengthy. Whereas statistics show there are indeed select, very few isolated pockets of lived Catholicism [experience is no longer experienced unless it’s lived say the woke].
Otherwise, if that were not true Catholics would overwhelmingly believe in Christ’s real presence in the Holy Eucharist. Therefore says the bishop “Catholic faithful need to recover a deeper understanding and lived experience”. How to recover? “Lifelong formation and conversion of heart” (Bishop Spesia). We must “walk together with fellow pilgrims on our journey” [Francis I jargon].
It sounds alright although it’s not. Bishops are required to clearly, convincingly teach the whole Gospel and its Apostolic tradition. That they haven’t done and still do not do except to offer platitudes.
If our Apostolic defenders of the faith lived their commission as successors of the Apostles their Presbyters would be believers and teachers as would the Laity.
About the “deeper understanding and lived experience”… After four decades it’s time to simply remember, in each Mass, the difference between a subjective “experience” and the real “happening”:
“Many people have felt and said that liturgy must be ‘made’ by the whole community if it is really to belong to them. Such an attitude has led to the ‘success’ of the liturgy being measured by its effect at the level of spectacle and entertainment. It is to lose sight of what is DISTINCTIVE [italics] to the liturgy, which does not come from what WE DO BUT FROM THE FACT [!] that something is TAKING PLACE here that all of us together cannot ‘make.’ In the liturgy there is a power, an energy at work which not even the Church as a whole can generate: what it manifests is the Wholly Other, coming to us through the community (which is hence not sovereign but servant, purely instrumental)” (Ratzinger, “The Ratzinger Report,” Ignatius 1985, p. 126).
“Do THIS in remembrance of Me.”
We read: “Spesia said one issue the Church faces is the ‘secularization’ of individuals and communities, and another is an ‘impoverished understanding of signs and symbols’ and ‘an emptying of a sacramental worldview in favor of a materialistic worldview’.”
Indeed, the dilution of faith means the replacement of a created and therefore sacral universe by a self-sufficient and ultimately only a digital cosmos.
About cultural amnesia and disbelief in “transubstantiation,” we have from St. Augustine the more-than-molecular meaning of “substance,” and of the Logos, and of the human mystery of each personal soul with a memory, intellect and will.
Two quotes:
FIRST, “…[Augustine] was confronted with the difficulty of conceiving substance [!] as spiritual [!], but with the discovery that this was possible, the greatest of his intellectual problems was solved. For he was thus enabled to perceive that, so far from being ultimate, ‘form’ and ‘matter’ alike were merely figments of the human mind; they were the spectacles through which men saw the corporeal or object world. His subsequent emancipation from the delusions of materialism and idealism [both!] followed as a matter of course and, with this, the revolution [accepting Trinitarian Christianity] was complete” (Charles Norris Cochrane, “Christianity and Classical Culture,” 1940/Oxford University Press 1974, pp. 396-7).
SECOND, so, about reality and “signs and symbols”, the Eucharist is both a sign AND that which it symbolizes…
“To respond to this invitation [the Eucharist as the Real Presence, CCC 1374] we must ‘prepare ourselves’ for so great and so holy a moment. St. Paul urges us to examine our conscience: ‘Whoever therefore, eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord in an unworthy manner will be guilty of profaning the body and blood of the Lord. Let a man examine himself, and so eat of the bread and drink of the cup. For any one who eats and drinks without discerning the body eats and drink judgment upon himself.’ Anyone conscious of a grave sin must receive the sacrament of Reconciliation before coming to communion” (CCC 1385).
Our moral dilemma is that the very principles by which we diagram a moral proposition have been marginalized. One, the principles of the natural law were made to be different rather than uniform because of differences in behavior, rather than appreciating the universality of such reasonably acknowledged laws as universal despite poor judgment.
Mitigation theory, the supremacy of conscience rather than the revelation of God regarding good and evil. Our current heretical dilemma is an across the board dissolution of the permanence of reasoned principles that enable us to make a proper moral judgment.
This has never occurred in Church history. For example, the Aryan heresy was one principle of belief regarding the divine nature of Christ, whereas today’s heresy affects the totality of moral doctrine.
On October 22 a document was published by the DDF entitled Venite ad Me: Considerations on the Transmission of the Faith in an Epochal Change. It strongly promotes kerygma while discouraging reliance on doctrine and scholasticism in conveying the Faith. We abandoned comprehensive, coherent accurate catechesis in the late sixties and with it the nurturing of sound piety. It appears Venite ad Me confirms the deficient approach to catechesis characteristic of the last sixty years. Perceptions are reality in the secular culture
The theological disorientation widely perceived, and not inaccurately, by the broad secular culture requiring evangelization undermines the Church’s credibility. The absence of ardent and public adherence to core doctrine puts the Gospel on the gravely questionable list. What else would one expect but this disastrous news. And make no mistake, this is disastrous.
Problems with this type of survey are legion. It isn’t logical to draw the conclusion that Catholics “don’t believe in the Real Presence”.
• False Dichotomy Between “Symbol” and “Real Presence”: Many surveys force respondents to choose between the bread and wine “actually becoming the body and blood” or “being symbols”. In Catholic theology, the Eucharist is both truly Christ’s body and blood and a sacramental symbol; treating these categories as mutually exclusive confuses respondents.
• Misinterpretation of Material vs. Metaphysical Change: Phrasing questions around whether the bread and wine “actually become” flesh and blood can push respondents away from the affirmative choice, because Catholic teaching specifies a metaphysical change of “substance” (transubstantiation) rather than a crude physical or material transformation.
• Lack of Familiar Theological Language: Critics and alternative studies (such as those by Vinea Research) argue that generic pollster wording fails to use terms like “truly present” or language aligned with the Catechism of the Catholic Church, leading to wildly different statistical outcomes (e.g., Pew showing ~31% belief vs. Vinea or CARA showing nearly two-thirds or higher among active Massgoers).
• Failure to Measure Conviction or Practice: Simple binary questions often capture a snapshot of semantic confusion rather than a respondent’s depth of devotion, frequency of Mass attendance, or actual understanding of liturgy
(I used AI for help with this list)
Going Lutheran?
Im a faithful Catholic pointing out problems with a secular survey. Yeah, I’m not a doomer Catholic.