Hungarian bishops urge against ‘hasty opinions’ amid clergy names in Soviet secret police files

Daniel Payne By Daniel Payne for EWTN News

Prime Minister Péter Magyar officially opened the government’s secret police archives on Nov. 4, describing the release as “long-overdue.”

The dome of St. Stephen’s Basilica towers on the skyline of Budapest, Hungary, in an undated photograph. | Credit: ungvar/Shutterstock
The dome of St. Stephen’s Basilica towers on the skyline of Budapest, Hungary, in an undated photograph. | Credit: ungvar/Shutterstock

Hungary’s Catholic bishops are urging the faithful to not rush to judgment after the publication of files showing that some of the country’s Catholic leaders collaborated with secret police during the Soviet era.

The country existed as a satellite state of the Soviet Union after World War II and was controlled by communists as the Hungarian People’s Republic from 1949 to 1989. As was common with communist states, the government utilized a secret police service to spy on and control citizens there.

Current Prime Minister Péter Magyar officially opened the government’s secret police archives on Nov. 4, describing the release as “long overdue.” The files contain about 60,000 names of secret police informants.

In a statement after the release of the files, the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of Hungary acknowledged that the list included names of “individuals affiliated with the Church.” Among the names are those of Cardinal László Paskai and Archbishop István Seregély.

The Hungarian bishops urged the faithful to “not … lose sight of the bigger picture.” They noted that the Church in communist-controlled Hungary was subject to severe persecution, including the murder of dozens of priests and monks and the imprisonment of around 2,000 more, while “approximately 11,500 monks and nuns were forced onto the street” and overall Church activity was suppressed.

Some of the named leaders in the secret police files “did indeed collaborate with the one-party state and passed on confidential information about members of the community and others to the authorities,” the bishops said. “On their behalf, we ask for forgiveness from the victims and their families.”

Yet “there were also those who were tortured or blackmailed,” the bishops continued. “There were those who wrote meaningless reports. And among the names on the list are also those whom the authorities merely attempted to recruit” and who ultimately refused to participate.

The “principal perpetrators” of the communist regime were not the “recruited individuals” listed in such files but the communist leaders themselves, the bishops said.

“Social reconciliation and the healing of the wounds of the past can only be achieved through the truth. We should not form hasty opinions about anyone’s actions until we know every detail of their story,” they said.

They urged the faithful to reject “contempt, revenge, or hatred” and opt for “confession, forgiveness, and mercy” instead.

The Hungarian government transitioned to a democratically controlled state in 1989 amid the political turmoil and upheaval sweeping Eastern Europe at the time. The Soviet Union would ultimately dissolve on Dec. 26, 1991.

The Catholic Church played a pivotal role in helping bring about the end of the communist multinational government, in large part from efforts by then-Pope John Paul II.

The British historian Timothy Garton Ash, for instance, wrote that there was a direct link between John Paul II’s papacy and the revolutions of 1989 that helped bring about an end to Eastern European Marxist-Leninist governments.


If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!

Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.


1 Comment

  1. For broader context, innacurate narratives will find precedents in how Pope Pius XII was framed by a communist inspired stage play, and in how another framing of Pope John Paul II backfired.

    Critics allege that as PIUS PIUS XII failed to sufficiently confront Hitler. Beginning in the early 1960s, this campaign might well have been triggered by a 1960 Kremlin “super-secret plan for destroying the Vatican’s moral authority” (retired KGB general Ion Mihai Pacepa, cited in “National Review Online” (Jan. 25, 2007) and quoted in “National Catholic Register,” Feb. 18, 2007). In 1963 Hochhuth’s play, The Deputy (1963), repeated the Soviet slander. Pacepa reports that Hochhuth drew from an earlier play produced by Erwin Piscator, a fervent communist, based on tampered documents stolen from the Vatican archives. The pope’s anonymous role in rescuing 860,000 Jews finds new documentation in the work of Gary Krupp (“Examining the Papacy of Pius XII” [2009], or Pave the Way Foundation at ptwf.org.)

    About the later POPE JOHN PAUL II, a Polish Communist Party group schemed (February 1983) to discredit the earlier Bishop Wojtyla by fabricating the diary of a dead widow (named Irina Kinaszewska) wherein compromising entries coincided with travel dates in the bishop’s records. The diary was to be found in a police raid. The short story is that the forgery was almost immediately exposed when the lead operative (Captain Grzegorz Piotrowski) “…got roaring drunk. Driving away from [a] bar, he crashed his car and was arrested by the police. Unable to control himself or perhaps trying to get himself out of an embarrassing scrape, he bragged about being a member of [the so-called] Independent Group D and revealed what he had been up to prior to his alcoholic binge [….]” (George Weigel, “The End of the Beginning: Pope John Paul II—The Victory of Freedom, the Last Years, the legacy” Doubleday, 2010, pp. 152-3).

    (It has been noticed that the Pope’s personal memory of this typical frame-up could account for John Paul II’s possibly delayed understanding of later sexual abuse accusations in the West.)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

All comments posted at Catholic World Report are moderated. While vigorous debate is welcome and encouraged, please note that in the interest of maintaining a civilized and helpful level of discussion, comments containing obscene language or personal attacks—or those that are deemed by the editors to be needlessly combative or inflammatory—will not be published. Thank you.


*