Florida’s Catholic Attorney General, Bishops Face Off Over Vaccines

Attorney General James Uthmeier has questioned the Florida Conference of Catholic Bishops over their refusal to grant vaccine exemptions to Catholic school children.

(Credit: Seasontime/Shutterstock.)

Florida is a “school choice” state, allowing parents to pay for private school tuition with state-funded education savings accounts. But Catholic school children in the state are not given a choice enjoyed by their public school counterparts: the right to refuse vaccines based on religious convictions.

The policy has put the state in the spotlight in an unlikely debate about religious freedom, as Florida’s Attorney General James Uthmeier goes head-to-head with the state’s bishops over their refusal to grant vaccine exemptions.

Uthmeier is a devout Catholic with three children; he and his wife teach religious education at St. Thomas More Co-Cathedral in Tallahassee.

In an open letter to the Florida Conference of Catholic Bishops on July 31, Uthmeier noted that Catholic schools in “at least one diocese” in the state will refuse to grant religious exemptions for vaccine requirements this year, and called the policy “concerning.”

Florida law “requires public and private schools to exempt students from the vaccination requirements” if a parent has a religious objection, he continued.

“But as a Catholic,” Uthmeier added, “I am confident that the teachings of the Catholic Church do not require Catholic schools to compel students to take vaccines derived from the tissue of aborted children against the sincerely-held religious objections of their parents.”

He went on to cite the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, which stated that “vaccination is not, as a rule, a moral obligation.”

“Having no legitimate religious reason to refuse granting religious exemptions to the taking of abortion-derived vaccines, Catholic schools in Florida should comply with Florida law,” the attorney general said.

Failure to do so “could jeopardize eligibility for state educational scholarship programs,” Uthmeier stated, requesting that the bishops’ conference respond by August 7th.

Florida Bishops’ Conference responds

In a letter of response issued August 7, Michael Sheedy, the executive director of the Florida Conference of Catholic Bishops (FCCB), stated that the bishops disagree with the attorney general on the interpretation and application of Church teaching.

That interpretation is “exclusively vested, by United States and Florida constitutional law, in the bishops of Florida’s dioceses,” he added.

The letter continued by laying out the structure of the Church’s teaching authority, with the Pope as supreme authority, followed by the bishops, priests, and then the laity.

The Florida bishops’ refusal to grant religious exemptions to vaccines is “rooted in the desire to protect the common good,” Sheedy said, and to “encourage the proportional benefits of utilizing vaccines.”

The letter cited a 2017 document from the Pontifical Academy for Life stating that the use of vaccines derived from aborted fetal stem cells does not signify formal cooperation with abortion.

It stopped short of saying that parents have a moral duty to vaccinate their children, noting that “if a parents’ sincere conscience does not allow them to vaccinate their children against diseases prevented by vaccines associated with abortion-derived cell lines, then those parents are free not to vaccinate their children.”

Those parents are also “free to choose a different educational path,” including homeschooling, Sheedy stated.

He went on to cite “the Church’s constitutionally protected authority to govern its internal affairs” under the first amendment.

“Government officials may no more determine the content of Catholic teaching than Church officials may determine the content of Florida law,” he said.

The bishops “will not succumb to affronts on religious freedom,” Sheedy said.

Miami’s Archbishop responds

In an August 14 column on the archdiocesan website, Miami’s Archbishop Thomas Wenski, president of the FCCB, called the attorney general’s action “an unprecedented and unexpected ‘overreach’ by a state official that intrudes upon our religious freedom.”

“The bishops, not a state functionary, decide how to interpret and apply Catholic principles and theology,” Wenski said.

“The Church does not force or coerce parents to vaccinate their children. No one must go to a Catholic school. At the same time, we do try to accommodate those children whose physicians indicate that a medical exemption is necessary.”

“Our Catholic schools are following the law,” Wenski said, but said the bishops welcome the opportunity to dialogue.

A spokeswoman for the Miami archdiocese confirmed that the vaccine policy “is not a new policy” for the state’s Catholic schools.

Florida law

Florida state law requires that “each district school board and the governing authority of each private school shall … require each child to have on file with the immunization registry a certification of immunization,” but adds that this provision “shall not apply if the parent of the child objects in writing that the administration of immunizing agents conflicts with his or her religious tenets or practices.”

The Florida Department of Education’s website also states that it “does not have jurisdiction over private schools.”

It continues, “Legislative intent not to regulate, control, approve, or accredit private educational institutions, churches, their ministries, religious instruction, freedoms, or rites, is explicit. The owners of private elementary and secondary schools in Florida are solely responsible for all aspects of their educational programs …”

A spokesperson for the Florida Department of Education did not respond to a request for clarification by the time of publication.

Uthmeier: A ‘Religious Mission’?

“I did not realize the Catholic Church had a ‘religious mission’ to force vaccinate students over the religious, conscience, and medical objections of their families—including vaccines derived from aborted fetal cell lines,” Florida’s attorney general said in an Aug. 17 X post.

Uthmeier called his exchange with the state’s bishops “healthy and essential,” but expressed doubt about whether “a private school that doesn’t follow state laws protecting parental rights and deeply held beliefs” should receive state funding.

Uthmeier told EWTN news this week that many Catholic families in his state have come to him, noting the irony that their convictions on immunizations are protected in public schools but not in Catholic ones.

Abortion and the vaccine industry

Much of the focus on vaccine hesitation today centers on health reasons. But some Catholic parents refuse certain vaccines because they were derived from aborted fetal cell lines.

Fetal cell lines are obtained by dissecting various organs and tissues of an aborted child. They are then cultured and multiplied in a lab for use. They’re used to grow the viruses needed to develop and/or manufacture vaccines, including measles-mumps-rubella, shingles, smallpox, chickenpox, and most COVID-19 vaccines.

While the Vatican has made it clear that taking those vaccines doesn’t equal formal cooperation with abortion, it’s also clear that abortion played a big part in creating them.

In just one example, at least 99 elective abortions were reported in the research and production of the rubella vaccine: 32 from fetal cell lines that failed, and 67 from attempts to isolate the rubella virus.

Ethicists frequently state that the abortions that allowed scientists to create our vaccines happened long ago, and no new abortions will be needed. That’s not necessarily true.

Cell lines are created by culturing cells in such a way that they continue growing and multiplying in laboratory dishes, sometimes for long periods of time. But a little publicized reality of the vaccine industry is that cell lines don’t last forever. That’s true even for so-called “immortalized” cell lines like HEK293, the cell line that is used in the production of some COVID-19 vaccines.

Eventually, scientists will no longer be able to sub-culture the cell line and will need another cell line. And at that point, they will most likely turn to the abortion industry yet again.

Even today, there is a continued demand for human fetal cell lines. A new fetal cell line, Walvax-2, was created in China in 2015 because of the age and diminishing supply of the MRC-5 cell line, which is used in the chickenpox and MMR vaccines, among others. Walvax-2 involved nine abortions. Ultimately, a baby girl of three months’ gestation supplied the cells for the cell line.

Because of abortion’s role in the development and production of vaccines, many parents who refuse abortion-derived vaccines do so not only to distance themselves from the horror of abortion, but to prompt the development of morally acceptable alternatives.

Advocating for meaningful change

Yvonne Bontkowski told EWTN news that while Florida’s bishops have framed the discussion as one about religious freedom, “This is the first time I have ever seen where the state isnʼt asking the Church to violate its teaching, itʼs asking the Church to honor it.”

Bontkowski heads Children of God for Life, which has been advocating for ethical vaccine alternatives and supporting and educating parents for over 30 years. Among the many resources on the organization’s website is detailed information on which vaccines were derived from aborted fetal cell lines.

Although the Church has determined it can be morally permissible to receive such vaccines under certain conditions, it says Catholics still have a moral duty to resist the use of aborted fetal tissue in vaccine research and production, and to advocate for ethical alternatives, Bontkowski said.

And it has affirmed that Catholics may exercise conscientious objection to those vaccines, she said, citing a 2005 document from the Pontifical Academy for Life.

“It is up to the faithful and citizens of upright conscience (fathers of families, doctors, etc.) to oppose, even by making an objection of conscience, the ever more widespread attacks against life and the ‘culture of death’ which underlies them,” the document states.

“The pharmaceutical industry understands the significant influence of the Catholic market, both in the United States and worldwide,” Bontkowski told Catholic World Report.

“For that influence to translate into meaningful change, it must be supported by a clear, united statement of support and action from Church leadership.”

When existing vaccines are seen as morally acceptable and permissible by the Catholic Church, “manufacturers have little incentive to act,” Bontkowski added. “A stronger, more explicit position would help create the urgency needed to encourage the development and availability of alternatives that better align with Catholic moral concerns.”

It’s true that schools must protect the health of their students. But “while vaccines are widely used as a public health measure, no medical intervention is without limitations or risk,” Bontkowski said.

“For that reason, individuals and families should be able to form and follow a well-informed conscience when making decisions about medical products, interventions, or procedures, consistent with the ethical principles reflected in the U.S. Catholic Conference of Bishops’ Ethical and Religious Directives.”


If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. Your contribution will help us continue to make CWR available to all readers worldwide for free, without a subscription. Thank you for your generosity!

Click here for more information on donating to CWR. Click here to sign up for our newsletter.


About Monica Seeley 28 Articles
Monica Seeley writes from Ventura, California.

140 Comments

  1. “Having no legitimate religious reason to refuse granting religious exemptions to the taking of abortion-derived vaccines, Catholic schools in Florida should comply with Florida law,” the attorney general said.”

    It is never necessary or proper to destroy an innocent Human Life in order to save a Human Life, thus mandating such abortion derived vaccines would be a violation of both Divine Law and a violation of The Constitution.

    • ND:has it ever been established that women are aborting their children in order to save life? This seems to be a convoluted argument without any proof.;And has little to do with the morality of the question at hand.

      • I think he’s referring to treating a human baby as sort of a sacrificial lamb for these fetal cell purposes which may benefit society.

      • Mr Connor, if you go to the Children of God for Life’s website you can read about the history of some of these vaccines. It’s very dark.
        I actually first learned about the history of the rubella component in the MMR through CWR 30 or more years ago. That’s when I asked our health department for separate vaccines for measles and mumps. They not only were very obliging but they provided me with a print out about the fetal connection in the rubella component.
        Not every vaccine has that kind of history but some do. And even though an ethically manufactured rubella vaccine is available in other nations, we don’t have it here. Nor do we have the ability today to receive separate vaccinations for measles and mumps. Merck only has the MMR to offer . I hope that changes.

  2. See also how the CC bishops are endangering us, our wives, children, families and country and are complicit in the fraud and crimes by illegals:
    A woman in Florida was bludgeoned to death by an illegal Haitian alien who was in the U.S. with the CC bishops support for the Democrat Administration immigration policies.
    —Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier says the horrific murder of A WOMAN WHO WAS BLUDGEONED TO DEATH AT A FORT MYERS GAS STATION ON APRIL 3 WAS TOTALLY PREVENTABLE, pointing to the fact that the suspect is a Haitian national in the U.S. illegally who benefited from the Democrat Administration open border policies.
    https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2026/04/08/florida-attorney-general-james-uthmeier-another-horrific-illegal-alien-murder-this-was-preventable/

    • Oscar:it’s possible that your data about the murder by an undocumented immigrant does not necessarily point to undocumented people being more dangerous than either documented or, for that matter ,naturally born citizens. Check out AI. It’s easy to take one (very unfortunate and tragic event) and make generalizations. This tends to create unfounded bias and prejudice towards groups of people. These tactics are now being employed by both extreme ends of both political parties and we as Christians must become aware and avoid falling into their traps. Take care old chap and God bless. Jim

      • Once again, you are defending the indefensible. There is clear and substantial data supporting the conclusion that illegals are criminally dangerous. Minimizing or dismissing the clear, obvious, and consistent patterns of illegal criminal behavior is a grave moral evil. Maybe a few hours in confession might help you to see this.

      • Cut the “undocumented immigrant” equivocation. It’s a blatant attempt to represent a lack of authorization as a paperwork deficiency.

        People who enter illegally, or stay beyond the limits are non “undocumented”, any more than if I drive without an operators license, I’m an “undocumented driver” or if I fail to file a tax return I’m an undocumented filer.

        It doesn’t matter whether the illegal invaders are more likely or less likely to commit crimes, it matters whether they commit any. We have enough native born criminals.

  3. The World has fully integrated into what used to be the Roman Catholic Church.
    That’s from decisions that have been made by the Church.
    Guess if I was an accessory after the fact of a murder I’d want the Church defending me.

  4. I suppose this will all be a moot point soon when the inevitable measles outbreak forces the closure of schools in Florida.

      • Red spots if I remember. And your eyes are sensitive to light.
        When I had measles the school had a quarantine period before you could return to class. Measles wasn’t thought to be a big deal back then. Pretty much everyone caught it at some point in childhood. Ditto for chicken pox.
        We know today that measles can erase a child’s immune system memory which can set them up for other, possibly more serious infections.

        • That measles can erase a child’s (an adult’s too?) immune system memory is quite interesting. I have never heard that.

          Public Health Reports Journal, 2019, Vol. 134(2),118-125 (sagepub.com/journals), has an article by Dr. E. Conis (UCLA, Berkeley and San Francisco) entitled “Measles and the Modern History of Vaccination.” The story is fascinating.

          In 1962, a new measles vaccine was ready for use. Specialists from the Office of the Surgeon General met with CBS news who developed and apparently aired a program called, “The Taming of a Virus.” The broadcast reported the childhood measles mortality rate at 1/5 in West African children under the age of 6. In the United States, the 1960 childhood morality rate from measles was much lower, reported at less than 1/500,000.

          In the 1960s, in the U.S., measles was seen as a ‘disease of childhood’ which, when caught, rendered lifetime immunity. I actually remember my mother saying that most people had considered it best that children caught the disease because it caused more problems in adults who didn’t suffer it in childhood.

          The article goes on to describe how the Public Health Service had to ‘sell’ a new attitude to the American public so they would come to accept childhood vaccination.

          The story hasn’t ended yet. Attitudes die hard. Science is as scientists say.

          • I was born in the mid 60s, and Mrs. Crackers Barrels story reminded me I still have my vaccine card:

            Exactly 7 months old I received the following:
            polio, whooping cough, Diphtheria, tetanus under dose it says 1cc

            about 6 weeks later – repeat 1cc

            about 5 months later – repeat 1cc

            about 3 1/2 yrs later I tested negative for TB

            about 4 years later 1cc measles

            about 5 weeks later “3 -1 +? oral” – dose: “B” Everything is checked off except measles again. I remember they lined us up by the drinking fountain and we took a sugar cube which they placed on our tongue with a little tongs, but don’t remember if there was another shot or not that day. this was at a Catholic grade school run by some very capable Dominicans

            all these shots may be why I was a cry baby, I don’t know

            I also had another tetanus when I was in my 20s after I accidentally stabbed my knee instead of the binder twine on the hay bale laying on the ground – so I should be set on that

            then also in my 20s I did get the chicken pox again, along with bronchitis at the same time – the ER doc said those pox parties didn’t always work if you were still nursing

          • I don’t know how long we’ve known about the effects of measles on the immune system memory meiron, but I’m guessing that back in the dark ages when I was a child, deaths from subsequent infections following measles probably weren’t counted in those mortality statistics.
            I fell seriously ill myself sometime after recovering from a so-so case of measles. The measles was a nothing burger. The pneumonia was a whole different critter. Minus modern medical care I could have been one of those statistics. “Modern” being relative. We had the doctor come to our house back then.
            🙂

          • I missed smallpox was also included on the last day.

            Then the screen goes blank and I don’t remember anymore through high school. This date would have been the 1st grade.

    • Back in the dark ages when I was growing up our school didn’t close when there was a case of measles. They just sent a note to parents informing them of that and also that any child diagnosed with measles would need to remain home for a certain time.

      • mrscracker,
        There are guidelines but the declaring physician has leeway or maybe limited knowledge as to cause of death. Remember the claims made in the time of COVID? An elderly man with heart disease and diabetes got COVID in 2020 and died of myocarditis. Did his death certificate report his death as due to COVID or due to heart disease?

        I did find one report in a 1975 JAMA-Pediatrics, authored by a Roger Barkin, M.D., MPH, CDC epidemiologist. Examining some 35% of death certificates for children who suffered and succumbed to death from measles and pneumonia as sequelae from 1964-1971, he claimed that 90% of the death certificates reported measles alone or measles and pneumonia as primary causes of death.

        • there was more reimbursement if covid was involved; can’t really blame them for getting more money to cover the overnight surge in health care wages – which has caused some smaller and espc rural hospitals to close or be swallowed up by health care system. the traveling RN that was on my covid team told me he was hoping to retire in his 50s, and had his investment counselor working on it. he had that fancy mask on while the others usually wore 2 cloth masks. the respiratory therapist was impressed by EWTN’s music and remarked that was some of the most beautiful she had ever heard

        • Thank you for sharing that meiron.
          I understand that things like pneumonia and encephalitis can accompany measles. But I was thinking of deaths a little further down the line after a child recovers from measles and returns to school and then gets exposed to other germs in the community.
          Measles can set you up for later infections.

  5. Is the Lisa Domski case precedent?

    There are other groups such as the Amish who don’t do much vaccinating.

    There’s bonuses from ins companies if kids have a certain number of vaccines by a certain age.

      • Br. – I’m not sure. the only reason I know about it is that the Epoch Times had an article on it. If you type “Do Doctors make money off vaccine – a look at incentives and bonuses.” It looks like you can log in an review it if you give them your email address.

        they also just had an article on dandelion extracts/tea appear to be able to fight cancer – but more research is needed

  6. Are these the same biship1s who shut down churches and prevented Catholics from attending Holy Mass during COVID? They seemed to have little angst over that episcopal act. What a disgrace!

      • So all of the Catholic martyrs in Henry VIII England should have obeyed all of the bishops, excluding Thomas Fischer, and accepted Henry as head of the church?

      • James Connor: I’ll provide you with a “for instance” which might contradict your “boomer Derangement”. If Uncle Teddy McCarrick were my archbishop, would I follow him with no exercise of prudential judgement on my part? I know you would but, then again, that’s your very problem. Christ didn’t call us to stupidity. Christ didn’t call us to woke nonsense. Christ called us to live in the Truth – His Truth. But I don’t expect that you’d understand any of it.

        • In all candor, from all the accounts of what McCarrick did, and I see no evidence that he was a particularly big or strong man-even when he was young, I often wonder how not one of his victims didn’t put him in the hospital or the morgue. He deserved a “sound thrashing”, at the very least.

          Oh well, to borrow Bill Gates’ quote about Epstein: “well, he’s dead now”.

      • You’re kidding right? A better question is why you are blindly and naively supporting the hierarchy like a lemming? Why are you defending the indefensible?

      • Because vowing to obey doesnt include a vow to be blind, mute or stupid.

        The Bishops were glad to help secular authorities do what the Romans couldn’t: shut down the church. Many of us will always remember that.

      • Because the Catholic hierarchy has gone off the rails on so many issues which are outside their spiritual ecclesiastical perview. Because so many of our bishops are clearly false shepherd egomaniacs.

        • If it is all that bad, I think it’s time for you to jump ship and join all the other Protestants who are already in the water.

          • If I were in a boat that was sinking with a Protestant of good will, and a Cupich, Marx or McElroy, and could only save myself and another-there’d be a be submerged Cardinal.

          • Remember that the Church has two aspects—one human, one divine. The divine aspect renders the Church holy. People, with sins and flaws and imperfections, what people bring/put into the church, give it its human aspect. One cannot deny that there is much sin within many members of the Church, including and most apparent in her upper hierarchy, likely because of their visibility. Consider your or my actions or words examined under public scrutiny. I would hope that I’d become more holy, but I cannot honestly predict with 100% certainty that I would always do so. [Even Jesus fell…] Would you? Or would you sometimes take refuge or solace in some less honorable way than Jesus and the saints?

  7. The Irony, saddens, and sickens me. “You take state funds, therefore you must adhere to the state rules.” Haven’t we been fighting that for so long?!? MAGA and Catholicism have a reckoning coming.

    • If I understand this correctly, the bishops are saying you MUST administer these vaccines, some of which are directly or indirectly related to elective abortions, even if you think using the vaccine is wrong, as it’s complicit with these abortions. (if you want your child to be part of a faith based education)

  8. But why does an exemption here have to be on religious grounds? Can’t I be against it for other reasons and be exempt?

      • Good luck trying to get those funds though, knowall. One of my children has been disabled for almost a year following a vaccination that their doctor should have realized was not in their best interest.
        From what I understand the fund only reimburses for pain and suffering and lost wages. Then you have to retain a disability attorney, etc. It’s a nightmare.

        Vaccines can be life saving. I’m not anti vax but some vaccines aren’t appropriate for everyone. And some have manufacturing histories that are problematic.

        • Yes, I heard of a doctor who had a reaction to the coviv mRNA. He took it under high pressure from his colleagues and now apparently is on disability. Wife and 4 rugrats.

          • I’m very sorry to hear that, knowall. I hope and pray he overcomes that reaction one day.
            It’s been a year for my own child. Drugs can help them function day to day but I worry about the long term effects of those, too.

          • Thank you for that, knowall. It’s a difficult thing to do all that & deal with disability issues, future employment concerns, caring for very young children, etc.
            I think my child actually has reached out to someone in the govt. but I don’t have a current update on that.

          • “I’m from the government and I’m here to help!”

            File with “the check is in the mail” and “I’ll still respect you in the morning”.

  9. You would think that the Church’s complicity in closing churches and encouraging the dangerous covid vaccines would give the bishops pause about trying to force vaccines on their populations who are now rightfully wary of the big pharma vaccine industry.

    Also—Have they not heard their own Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, which stated that “vaccination is not, as a rule, a moral obligation!?”

    The Florida bishops ought to choose a more worthy moral mountain to die on!

  10. The Bishops of Florida have executed their “paradigm shift” and assume the role of public health bureaucrats, for which they and their confederated “diocesan church bureaucracies” congratulate themselves for their “prophetic” posture.

    Another inspiring chapter in their sojourn.

  11. Do the bishops not follow the news at all? Are they totally unaware of what is now public knowledge about the Covid vaccine?
    After shutting down churches, requiring vaccination of diocese employees and not allowing seminarians to return if not vaccinated I would think the bishops would be so embarrassed they would not get into this argument.
    But, they seem to have no embarrassment over requiring vaccination with a “vaccine” created using aborted baby cells. And vaccines shown to have significant adverse medical effects.

    They should stick to their areas of expertise, like their current appeal to the Supreme Court to not allow juries of less than 12 members (sarc).

  12. The medical decisions are prudential for myself and my family are between ourselves and God with no coercion from either the state of the Church neither of which have had the best interests of the people, laity or citizens at heart. The bishops further compromised their moral authority catering to the world during Covid.

  13. The Bishops should make a copy of this and distribute this to the illegal aliens they help here in the U.S.:

    UK Gov’t Publishes Pamphlet to Inform Migrants That Rape is Wrong, Sex With Children Is a Crime

    The British government has issued a guide to alleged asylum seekers to teach them the customs of the United Kingdom, such as not raping women or engaging in sexual acts with children.
    https://www.breitbart.com/europe/2026/08/20/uk-govt-publishes-pamphlet-to-inform-migrants-that-rape-is-wrong-sex-with-children-is-a-crime/

    • No doubt if they had mentioned this sooner they would not be having this problem.

      Also, did they print this in all languages, or was only one language necessary?

  14. ““But as a Catholic,” Uthmeier added, “I am confident that the teachings of the Catholic Church do not require Catholic schools to compel students to take vaccines derived from the tissue of aborted children against the sincerely-held religious objections of their parents.”

    I’m not sure what I think about this one. Honestly speaking, how many parents are making this decision on these grounds? Might they be objecting to vaccines for other reasons that might be questionable or not legitimate? Opposing vaccines is all well and good on paper until diseases that have previously been under control break out again in the broader population. Is that a risk we are willing to take?

    • “Honestly speaking, how many parents are making this decision on these grounds?”
      .
      I most certainly did. At one point I wanted my faith to actually mean something to me. (These days I’m not so sure I care as it is clear the clergy don’t.)
      .
      Maybe if the powers that be didn’t insist on using tainted cell lines to make vaccines, and if the Church clergy had not have gone, ” well, just take it but write a letter to the pharma company asking for something different next time”, we might not be having this conversation. Maybe if the clergy said “Heck no. This is immoral,” we’d have other options.
      .
      Maybe if the powers that be didn’t mandate a highly questionable mRNA platform for a virus that really wasn’t any worse than the flu for the overwhelming majority of people–and then treated those who did get seriously ill with something other than a ventilator, we might not be having this discussion.
      .
      Maybe if the US gov’t didn’t demand a vaccination schedule that is clearly out of whack with other Western nations, we might not be here either.
      .
      If you want your child or grandchild to have this or that vaccines, go get it. It’s legal. The clergy certainly appear fully supportive. If your neighbors do not and their child gets sick, not your problem because your child is vaccinated and won’t get sick. But if for some reason your child does get sick, why were you demanding everyone get a vaccine that clearly didn’t work?

      • The vaccines work. Not all people can be vaccinated. Catholics who are truly prolife don’t want to see other people dying from preventable disease.

        • Clearly you are cold-bloodedly indifferent to the slaughter of millions of innocent lives and the principalities of evil that promote it.

          There is little evidence that the vaccines have worked, and it was impossible to know they would work at the time they were criminally mandated, including the mandate of the anti-Catholic Pope Francis who fired those at the Vatican who refused.

          Catholics who are Catholic are quite willing to accept death before accepting rescue from death based on the slaughter of the innocent.

          • IIRC the COVID vaccines were released under the emergency use authorization that blocked legal remedies for anyone damaged by the vaccines. All the while these same vaccines were touted as being safe and effective and were administered under conditions that were often highly coercive towards those receiving the vaccines. A so-called safe and effective vaccine that put the entire burden of use on the person being given the vaccine.
            *
            I wonder if the illegal immigrants had to provide proof of vaccination before entering the country?

        • yet if the vaccine or mRNA is working then why would it matter? I may have asked you this on another thread

          Is the Bishop saying it’s more important for the sincere Catholic to get vaccinated then to get their faith based education?

        • So it’s ok to take hundreds of innocent children’s lives by murder to protect your own children from dying? Isn’t that what the Nazis did?

          • A scientist before I was born used the otherwise unused fetal cells from a single baby whose demise he/she had nothing to do with to develop a vaccine that has saved literally millions of babies. Yes. I will avail myself of that miracle. Without apology.

        • Athanasius:

          Here is another thing to think about: if “you” (or someone else) can force me (or my children) to take a vaccine so that “you” are less likely to get sick, why am I not allowed to force “you” (and “your children”) to eat apples, bananas, quality protein, Vit D supplements, go to the gym, shun processed foods and soda pop/alcohol?
          .
          The people most at risk for disease (be it flu, covid, heart disease, or even some cancers) are those who do not eat properly, exercise, or maintain a balanced height/weight/muscle/fat ratio. Much of what ails us is directly related to our lifestyle choices.
          .
          Metabolic diseases (a spectrum of diseases from diabetes, heart, stroke, etc) cost the US health system upwards of 75% of our medical dollars–well into the billions. And people with metabolic diseases (I’m excluding the aged who were hardest hit) get sick with contagious diseases easier and are hit harder.
          .
          So…since metabolic issues respond very favorably to better nutrition and exercise, and since healthier people are less likely to spread disease, why is this not mandated?

          • many good points. why is drinking alcohol and tobacco still legal while you can’t drink raw milk without the legal hoop of “herd shares?’

          • Infectious disease does not care how “virtuous” you are. If you refuse to protect the vulnerable you cannot call yourself pro-life.

          • For Covid specifically, the “superspreaders” were people who were obese and/or diabetic.

            One person’s poor eating habits are traceably detrimental to the good of many other people. The only ways to prevent this are to require people to get healthy, or require the unhealthy to stay away from other people.

            One of the very obvious aspects of living in a community is that you have to accept some suffering to do so. Other peoples’ sins, faults, and foibles WILL cause harm to you and yours. Yours WILL cause harm to other people. Laws and punishments that seek to limit this WILL cause harm to you and others.

            This is what generally makes the “common good” a matter of prudential discernment, not something allows for certain opinions to be used to claim moral superiority. Such claims are often merely rash judgement in disguise.

    • “Might they be objecting to vaccines for other reasons that might be questionable or not legitimate?”

      So, we’ll pierce the veil of parental authority on a suspicion of improper motivation? What’s the criteria of “questionable” or legitimate. Where do you get the angels with the Solomonic wisdom to examine and rule on people.

      If we do, then we need to examine the motivations of those who use their office or authority to impose mandates “reasons that might be questionable or not legitimate..”

  15. Thank you for an informative article – had not realized that the industry is still using the tainted cell lines. The merciful approach from Vatican about the issue , good for the multitudes who are one way or other connected – as much as many of the institutions too are also under powers that have unholy memberships and ties .
    Florida – AFIK – have many who are aware and supportive of the Divine Will truths and sanctity given us through Luisa , how even our thoughts can impact at wide levels- the truth of a statement of Pope Leo too , that each person is an entire world – reflecting how our Lord has made reparation for all of humanity to bring us to the glory destined for us in His mercy that each of us is to grow into.
    The mystery of connection of vaccines to autism -persons can thus ? claim it as a legitimate medical concern linked to PTSD . Some children / families are more prone to same from mysterious reasons & ? to be granted exemptions as an act of mercy .

    https://bookofheaven.com/reflections-from-the-writings/rosaria-bucci-pray-for-unborn/

    https://bookofheaven.com/2015-conference/day-of-prayer-for-legal-protection-of-unborn-children/
    May the prayers of many on behalf of all dealing with these issues bring much light and good !

  16. Attorney General James Uthmeier in cohesion with Catholic policy is correct that the principle of free will and right to decide nullifies coercion and outweighs the possible risks.

  17. The solution is simple: If the Catholic schools refuse to allow parents the freedom to determine their own children’s health needs, simply exclude the Catholic schools from the school choice programs. Once again, the Catholic bishops are squarely on the wrong side of a moral, political, and public policy issue.

    • Unless parents are medically qualified I fail to see how they can have a safe view on vacines qualified medical staff advisc are administered.The safety of our children transcend Trumpist or MAGA propoganda and well done schools and the Bishops for trying to protect our young people.

        • You learn that when you think you are under a physician’s care for serious, bit slow acting and unfortunately permanent condition, but he’s more concerned about a presenting symptom rather than a disease and as a result, you have the good fortune of being unable to take Ibuprofen or any NSAID due to a prescription for the presenting symptom (DVT) forces you to the ER, where they inform you, due to disease progression, you’ll be staying.

          Then the next day, December 14, you are visited by another physician who opens the door and says “Hi, I’m [REDACTED] and you need to be treated right now”, and then proceeds at one point to say “Good thing you decided to come to the ER yesterday, or you’d have been dead by Christmas”.

          • I enjoyed, I guess you’d say, of having the availability of a MD who opened a modern office building in our rural area, basically as an urgent care. This was back in the 90s. His wife handled the office part and they grew steadily, he told me later, once the 1st 4th of July rolled around and people, many of them tourists, discovered them for burns and boating incidents etc… You could walk in, or make an appt, and talk with a physician, who looked you in the eye while talking with you. He added on additional physicians who were equally qualified. Eventually, time and consolidation trends caught up with them near retirement age and they sold out to a larger health system. About 5 yrs ago, not long after the transfer, I was going to be working out of state the week after Thanksgiving, and needed my BP medicine refilled the Wedns before Thanksgiving, as the clinic was closed on Friday. After explaining this to the new receptionist she stared at me and declared, “You don’t have a PCP!” I kept looking at her and repeated, “Okay, I just need to get my blood pressure medicine refilled as I’m out of state next week.” “You don’t have a PCP!” and she just stood there. Then they didn’t know who I was and I explained gosh, I was one of their first customers when the Doc told me they almost went bankrupt for lack of business. I said well usually such and such takes my BP real quick and then fills out the script. “Well, they moved her over to the main building now (across town).” She then again stated I needed a “PCP” of which I had no idea what she was talking about, and she was offering no instructions on how to remedy the situation. The rest of the story is eventually, at my insistence and one other senior employee’s involvement, they got me back in a room and someone took my BP, and the script was filled; but it was like a culture change shock. (the frustrating part was I was getting the impression they were going to let my BP flap in the wind over a technicality)

          • I’m not sure if you’re maybe neurodivergent and genuinely don’t understand or if you’re being deliberately obtuse.

            Fauci’s behavior has been disgraceful. Ethics are part of being qualified medical staff. I wouldn’t trust him if he suggested an aspirin for a headache, much less on issues involving morality.

      • Please stop identifying yourself as an MBA.

        1.) Here, the use of it is irrelevant credentialism.

        2.) Your childish partisan rant lacks any analytical rigor or insight.

        Some of us worked to obtain the degree in order to develop or refine our skills and we’d rather not have its value debased by people who exhibit none of the tools it was supposed to convey. Of course if you had learned anything, perhaps your linked in profile wouldn’t show you as career Labour Party politician, “open to work”.

      • They live close/near to each other but they’re not really isolated from the population at large. They have on farm stores and bakeries as well.

      • The Amish don’t live in isolation though. They have plenty of interaction with their communities & in local businesses where they’re employed or that they own. Ditto for Old Order & conservative Mennonites.

          • actually there would be some overlap, like the many homeschooled kids who don’t get a vaccine regimen thrust upon them by the state or local health department?

          • Actually, the rural county we used to live in had become largely unpopulated until the Amish & Mennonites began moving in a couple decades ago, buying abandoned farms & opening country stores. The entire area is becoming a sort of extended Amish community. So far they only represent about 20% of the county population but since they double in number each generation it won’t be long before they’re the majority.
            They bought a public school closed down for lack of children & use it now as a church. The county had consolidated all the elementary schools & the highschool into one building. There were so few children left in the county.
            Now public school officials are trying to interest the Amish & Mennonites into taking advantage of some public school electives & 4-H. I don’t know how much luck they’ve had with that but who knows?
            The Amish & Mennonites do welding for farm equipment repairs & whatever else in the community & they have plenty of interaction with those outside their church.

  18. I live near the Amish. They don’t live in “isolation”. They interact with each other and the non-Amish (who are often referred to as English) in a myriad of ways, offering agricultural products, traditional goods, public buggy rides (one purveyor asked my then twelve year old niece if she wanted to try the reins, and he gave her both the necessary guidance to guide the team, as well the thrill of her vacation); they are involving in roofing and the building trades and many run sandwich shops at local farmers markets. Invariably, they produce good products and services, at fair priced and conditions of sale.

    Perhaps you should let your preconceived notions have some contact with reality, so you don’t betray your foolishness with such clarity, vigor and persistence. I suspect that you live in a condition that could more accurately be described as isolation based on your various phantasms.

    • The Amish live in isolated communities and do not send their children to doctors or schools with the rest of the public at large. If they choose not to immunize I don’t have the same concerns as I do about little Jimmy on the soccer field or birthday spreading disease to the wider pubic. You should stop posting things of which you are obviously ignorant and drop the smug superiority of own who always claims to know literally everything better than any one else. It’s ugly, unchristian and proves you are just yet another troll.

      • “You should stop posting things of which you are obviously ignorant and drop the smug superiority of own who always claims to know literally everything better than any one else.It’s ugly, unchristian and proves you are just yet another troll.”

        Says the bitter, projecting troll! You can’t make this stuff up 🙄.

      • Instructing the ignorant is a work of mercy. When the ignorant are obstinate it’s insufferable and their no vaccine for the obstinate stupidity you display on a regular basis. Project much, troll? It’s amusing, you showed up as soon as “Gerard” and “William” stopped their incessant barrages.

        Listen, you dolt. I no only live near Amish, I’ve spoken to them. I asked one fellow once, who was sponsoring an attraction called “Dinner with the Amish” which featured both traditional Amish fare and an opportunity to ask them about how they maintain their way of life. They were candid about the challenges, such as machine made counterfeit crafts from China, the price of real estate and farming without mechanization. One question that came up was medicine-to which the entire group was told-we see “English” doctors. But you live in a fantasy world, rather than actual interaction with the people about who you make these grand declarations from the closed space that is your “mind”.

        Sierra Tango Hotel Uniform.

          • Bless your heart. Does your Amish “friend” know the two poor folks who died of measles in Lancaster yesterday because they didn’t go see a doctor? Maybe go visit him to check on him.
            Bravo India Tango Echo Mike Echo

        • Do you pray to Our Lady with that foul mouth? I wonder if your Amish “friend” knows the folks that died in Lancaster yesterday of measles? Died BTW because they did not see a doctor until too late. Maybe go up and see him in person. Send us photos.
          Bravo India Tango Echo
          Mike Echo.

          • Your hypocrisy aside, I didn’t use a single unmerited word, and now I’ll add another- liar. I never described him as a friend, but paying accurate cognition and retention doesn’t seem to be your strengths.

            The fact is, you’ve been corrected by multiple other posters and now unable to pursue your inane claim of “isolation”, you cry foul when somebody describes you accurately.

          • Interestingly, many of the English in our area go to the Amish for a chiropractic adjustment not allowed, apparently, for regular Chiros to perform.

            May the souls of the faithful departed, through the mercy of God, rest in peace, Amen!

            FYI, there are many English who also don’t go until it’s too late.

          • Interesting pull quote, although given the source, I imagine you won’t accept it.

            Any death from a communicable disease is required by law to be reported to the Lancaster County Coroner’s Office. Parsons spoke at length with senior staff and with Coroner Dr. Stephen Diamantoni. Their answer: zero measles deaths in Lancaster County. They have one death of a person who died WITH measles, but not FROM measles. They know nothing about a second death.

            https://www.thegatewaypundit.com/2026/08/pa-gov-josh-shapiro-state-health-officials-caught/

      • I have Mennonite friends and have known Amish people. They do go to doctors like everyone else. If they can, they’ll use midwives or home remedies but they know when a licensed physician or dentist is required.

        • About 30 yrs ago, I responded to an ad for a farm cultipacker for sale, which wasn’t too far away. It was a no phone but with an address so I wasn’t surprised when it was an Amish farm. In speaking with him, he told me he had to get his hip replaced, which he explained the church pd for from their tithes. He also was complaining about his eldest son who was getting married, moving away and going out on his own and all this work he would now have to do. I said gosh I work all week and try to farm on the weekends but if you really get in a jam let me know. He replied, Oh, I’ve got 6 more sons.

      • “You should stop posting things of which you are obviously ignorant and drop the smug superiority of own who always claims to know literally everything better than any one else. It’s ugly, unchristian and proves you are just yet another troll.”

        Project much? Talk about the pot troll calling the kettle black! You can’t make this stuff up 🙄.

      • they interact in the community at regular times, the grocery stores, dollar and other retail stores etc… they wouldn’t accidentally be spewing saliva onto another kid during a tackle or other hit on the football or soccer field, but they are “in close proximity,” on a regular basis.

        they utilize our local health care doctors and providers when needed, but use other methods, like homemade salve and burdock leaves for cuts, burns and lacerations if they can. they don’t care for the prostate being removed and will utilize a foreign doctor for a different procedure if they can. they more accept what happens as God’s will then we do.

        just a suggestion but you need to calm down a little bit on your replies; state your opinion and quit pointing the finger, please. You’ll live longer if nothing else.

  19. I know one thing for certain: no bishop is going to dictate the kind of medical care I or any of my family receive.

    Bishops don’t do theology right and now I’m going to listen to them about healthcare, politics, climate change, reforestation, acid rain, and animal husbandry? Most bishops don’t even have terminal degrees in theology but they pretend to be experts in just about everything else.

  20. Your hypocrisy aside, I didn’t use a single unmerited word, and now I’ll add another- liar. I never described him as a friend, but paying accurate cognition and retention doesn’t seem to be your strengths.

    The fact is, you’ve been corrected by multiple other posters and now unable to pursue your inane claim of “isolation”, you cry foul when somebody describes you accurately.

  21. gestapo tactics; I also by pass by go fund me because they cooperated in shutting down those Canadian truckers by refunding the 9 million instead of giving it to the truckers

  22. About 30 yrs ago, I responded to an ad for a farm cultipacker for sale, which wasn’t too far away. It was a no phone but with an address so I wasn’t surprised when it was an Amish farm. In speaking with him, he told me he had to get his hip replaced, which he explained the church pd for from their tithes. He also was complaining about his eldest son who was getting married, moving away and going out on his own and all this work he would now have to do. I said gosh I work all week and try to farm on the weekends but if you really get in a jam let me know. He replied, Oh, I’ve got 6 more sons.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

All comments posted at Catholic World Report are moderated. While vigorous debate is welcome and encouraged, please note that in the interest of maintaining a civilized and helpful level of discussion, comments containing obscene language or personal attacks—or those that are deemed by the editors to be needlessly combative or inflammatory—will not be published. Thank you.


*