The (baffling) view from Rome Print E-mail

Web Exclusive 

By George Neumayr 

L’Osservatore Romano’s sympathetic front-page editorial by Giuseppe Fiorentino about Barack Obama’s first 100 days is baffling (full text available here). On every contested issue related to the natural moral law, Obama is advancing dangerous policies. Yet this editorial blithely says that even “on ethical issues…Obama doesn’t seem to have confirmed the radical changes he had aired.”
 
Yes, he has.

Within weeks of entering office, he reversed the Mexico City Policy as promised, thereby freeing up the tax dollars of Americans for the promotion of abortion overseas; he lifted George W. Bush’s ban on federal tax dollars for embryo-destructive research; he took the first steps toward abolishing the Bush’s “conscience clause” that protects the rights of pro-life nurses and doctors at hospitals that receive federal funds; he has appointed supporters of gay marriage and euthanasia to a host of important posts; and he has enlisted dissenting Catholics such as Kathleen Sebelius to serve as his agents of moral destruction.

“The new guidelines regarding embryonic stem-cell research don’t, in fact, line up with the changes foreseen months ago,” says Fiorentino. “They don’t permit the creation of new embryos for purposes of research or therapy, for cloning or reproductive ends, and federal funds may be used solely for experimentation with surplus embryos.”
 
Yes, they do. The guidelines forbid reproductive cloning but permit the cloning of embryos for research. And the research can go beyond “surplus embryos.”
 
It is more than a little disturbing that an editorial as ignorant as this one could appear in the Pope’s newspaper. At the very moment orthodox Catholics in America are reeling from Notre Dame's honoring of Obama, they wake up to find this editorial softpedaling his record. Et tu, L'Osservatore Romano?

 

George Neumayr is editor of Catholic World Report.

 

Comments
Add New Search
Tom  - L'OSSERVATORE-OBAMA?   |2009-05-01 08:05:52
The Catholic News Service item about the article in L'Osservatore Romano had the heading "LOSSERVATORE-OBAMA".

Recently a number of changes in the newspaper's format and content were made. That may be its new title and thus would explain the puff piece.
Sean Q. Gallagher     |2009-05-08 01:20:23
[/size]UNBELIEVEABLE!!!!!!!

[size=medium]
It is certainly true that a great nation can only be subdued from without if it has first been corrupted from within, but the CHURCH???!!!
Doral Hemm   |2009-05-09 11:01:15
Susan's observation is right on. The subversion of the Church from within was the one great accomplishment of Pope John Paul II.
Madame Defarge   |2009-05-11 13:39:16
"One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic."

Those four marks that let us know where the true Church of Christ is are no longer visible to me.

Holiness has become tarnished with the sex scandals and cover-ups by the bishops, who are supposed to be the successors to the Apostles.

The Church no longer speaks with one voice and there is no unity anymore on faith and morals.

When I can clearly see those four marks again, I'll start donating to the Catholic Church. Until then, I'll donate to other worthy charitable organizations.
PadreJim   |2009-05-12 15:31:48
l'Observatore Romano is not the Church and an editorial is not a factual report!
Sean Q. Gallagher   |2009-05-13 04:01:28
Father Jim

Respectfully, sir, l'Observatore Romano is an official organ of the Church, and the fact that we are commenting on an editorial is of no consequence to the argument. My comment is that the Church is being prevailed upon from within its own ranks.

The Church IS the totality of the Body of Christ. A single parishoner who voices an opinion incongruent with the Faith does not do so within a vacuum, especially when that member of Christ's Body is a politician supporting abominable government intervention in any of a number of human rights, or a reporter spouting abominable posturing in an official Church organ.

These positions are circulated to millions of Catholics, who in turn make a decision to assimilate that view into thier belief structure. Some of these Catholics are young, still forming in the faith. These mature and maybe even seek a religious vocation. And guess what, we end up with religious leaders who can't tell right from wrong as in the example spelled out by Madame Defarge.

The Church leadership needs to stop turning a deaf ear and a blind eye to such subversion of the One True Faith.
Sean Q. Gallagher   |2009-05-13 04:04:51
who cannot tell right from wrong as in Defarge's example above.

The Church needs to stop turning a blind eye and a deaf ear to such subversion of the One True Faith.
Bro. Ignatius Mary     |2009-07-12 18:51:35
Observatore Romano is NOT an official organ of the Church. It is quasi-official. But even if it were official, the newspaper is NOT the Church, as the Father said. The Church is vested in its priests and bishops, and in the faithful. No newspaper, or newspaper editor speaks for the Church.
Write comment
Name:
Email:
 
Website:
Title:
UBBCode:
[b] [i] [u] [url] [quote] [code] [img] 
 
 
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.

3.26 Copyright (C) 2008 Compojoom.com / Copyright (C) 2007 Alain Georgette / Copyright (C) 2006 Frantisek Hliva. All rights reserved."

 

Syndication

Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Joomla Templates by Joomlashack